NORTHWEST TERRITORIES
LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY
2nd Session Day 23 16th Assembly
HANSARD
Thursday, June 5, 2008
Pages 899 to 954
The Honourable Paul Delorey, Speaker
Legislative Assembly of the Northwest Territories
Members of the Legislative Assembly
Speaker
Hon.Paul Delorey
(Hay River North)
Mr.Glen Abernethy(Great Slave)
Mr.Tom Beaulieu
(Tu Nedhe)
Ms.Wendy Bisaro
(Frame Lake)
Mr.Bob Bromley
(Weledeh)
Mrs.Jane Groenewegen
(Hay River South)
Mr.Robert Hawkins
(Yellowknife Centre)
Mr.Jackie Jacobson
(Nunakput)
Mr.David Krutko
(Mackenzie Delta)
Hon.Jackson Lafferty
(Monfwi)
Minister of Justice
Minister of Education, Culture and Employment / Hon.Sandy Lee
(Range Lake)
Minister of Health and Social Services
Minister Responsible for the Status of Women
Minister Responsible for Persons with Disabilities
Hon.Bob McLeod
(Yellowknife South)
Minister of Human Resources
Minister of Industry, Tourism and Investment
Minister Responsible for the Public Utilities Board
Hon.Michael McLeod
(Deh Cho)
Minister of Municipal and Community Affairs
Minister of Public Works and Services
Minister Responsible for Youth
Mr.Robert McLeod
(Inuvik Twin Lakes)
Mr.Kevin Menicoche
(Nahendeh) / Hon.Michael Miltenberger
(Thebacha)
Deputy Premier
Government House Leader
Minister of Environment and Natural Resources
Minister Responsible for the NWT Housing Corporation
Minister Responsible for the Workers' Safety and Compensation Commission
Mr.David Ramsay
(Kam Lake)
Hon.Floyd Roland
(Inuvik Boot Lake)
Premier
Minister of Finance
Minister Responsible for the Financial Management of Board Secretariat
Minister of Aboriginal Affairs and Intergovernmental Relations
Hon.Norman Yakeleya
(Sahtu)
Minister of Transportation
Minister Responsible for the NWT Power Corporation
Minister Responsible for Seniors
Officers
Clerk of the Legislative Assembly
Mr.Tim Mercer
Deputy Clerk
Mr.Doug Schauerte / Principal Clerk of Committees
Ms.Patricia Russell / Principal Clerk, Operations
Ms.Gail Bennett / Law Clerks
Mr.Glen Boyd
Ms.Kelly Payne
Box 1320
Yellowknife, Northwest Territories
Tel: (867) 669-2200 Fax: (867) 920-4735 Toll-Free: 1-800-661-0784
http://www.assembly.gov.nt.ca
Published under the authority of the Speaker of the Legislative Assembly of the Northwest Territories.
June 5, 2008 NORTHWEST TERRITORIES HANSARD Page 953
Table of Contents
Prayer 899
Speaker’s Ruling 899
Ministers’ Statements 900
53-16(2): Drive Alive: Summer Safety Initiatives (Yakeleya) 900
54-16(2): Protected Area Strategy (B. McLeod) 900
Members’ Statements 901
Inuvialuit Final Agreement 25th Anniversary (Jacobson) 901
Early Entry to Kindergarten Programs (Hawkins) 901
Inuvialuit Final Agreement 25th Anniversary (Krutko) 902
Elimination of Business Incentive Policy (Groenewegen) 902
Guidelines for Seismic Lines (Bromley) 903
Inuvialuit Final Agreement 25th Anniversary (McLeod) 903
Cabinet Communications (Abernethy) 904
Acknowledgement of Crystal Milligan (Bisaro) 904
Kam Lake Access Road (Ramsay) 905
High Cost of Living in Small Communities (Beaulieu) 905
Proposed Elimination of Deh Cho Youth Worker Position (Menicoche) 906
Inuvialuit Final Agreement 25th Anniversary (Roland) 906
Recognition of Visitors in the Gallery 906
Oral Questions 907
263-16(2): Early Entry to Kindergarten Programs (Hawkins) 907
264-16(2): Renewal of Mining Company Land Use Leases (Bisaro) 908
265-16(2): Guidelines for Seismic Lines (Bromley) 908
266-16(2): High Cost of Living in Small Communities (Beaulieu) 909
267-16(2): Teaching Position Vacancies in Beaufort-Delta Region (Jacobson) 910
268-16(2): Access to Gravel Sources for Aklavik (Krutko) 910
269-16(2): Kam Lake Access Road (Ramsay) 911
270-16(2): Elimination of Business Incentive Policy (Groenewegen) 912
271-16(2): Seniors’ Supplementary Benefit (McLeod) 913
272-16(2): Employment for Summer Students (Hawkins) 914
273-16(2): Protected Areas Strategy (Bromley) 915
274-16(2): Elimination of Business Incentive Policy (Groenewegen) 915
275-16(2): Elimination of Business Incentive Policy (McLeod) 916
Consideration in Committee of the Whole of Bills and Other Matters 917
Main Estimates 2008–2009 Department of Health and Social Services 918
Committee Motion 29-16(2): To Reinstate Stanton Hospital Telehealth Coordinator Position and Associated Contribution Funding for a Total Amount of $210,000, Health and Social Services, Program Delivery Support (Committee Motion Carried) 922
Committee Motion 30-16(2): To Defer Further Consideration of the Operations Expenditures, Department of Health and Social Services (Committee Motion carried) 948
Committee Motion 31-16(2): To Defer Further Consideration of Infrastructure Acquisition Plan, Department of Health and Social Services (Committee Motion Carried) 952
Main Estimates 2008–2009 Department of Human Resources 953
Report of Committee of the Whole 953
Orders of the Day 953
June 5, 2008 NORTHWEST TERRITORIES HANSARD Page 953
June 5, 2008 NORTHWEST TERRITORIES HANSARD Page 953
Yellowknife, Northwest Territories
Thursday, June 5, 2008
Members Present
Mr.Abernethy, Mr.Beaulieu, Ms.Bisaro, Mr.Bromley, Hon.Paul Delorey, Mrs.Groenewegen, Mr.Hawkins, Mr.Jacobson, Mr.Krutko, Hon.Jackson Lafferty, Hon.Sandy Lee, Hon.Bob McLeod, Hon.Michael McLeod, Mr.McLeod, Mr.Menicoche, Hon.Michael Miltenberger, Mr.Ramsay, Hon.Floyd Roland, Hon.Norman Yakeleya.
June 5, 2008 NORTHWEST TERRITORIES HANSARD Page 953
The House met at 1:32 p.m.
Prayer
Prayer.
Speaker’s Ruling
Speaker(Hon.PaulDelorey): Good afternoon, colleagues. Welcome back to the Chamber. I will now provide my ruling on the point of privilege raised by the Member for Hay River South on Monday, June 2, 2008.
The role of the Speaker when a point of privilege is raised is twofold. First, the Speaker must determine whether the point of privilege was raised at the earliest possible opportunity. I find that Mrs.Groenewegen did raise her point of privilege at the earliest possible opportunity.
Secondly, the Speaker must determine whether a prima facie breach of privilege took place.
In stating her point of privilege, the Member for Hay River South referenced the following comments made by the Member for Thebacha on May 30, 2008, during debate on a motion to delete a capital project from his constituency from the Main Estimates.
“And as we keep open minds to look at all the options, one of the options that hadn’t been considered is we’re talking about repatriating a bunch of adults into a supportive living structure that has yet to be built. Has that been considered as a possibility for Arctic Tern? I don’t know. But clearly it’s a circumstance that strikes me as interesting and somewhat ironic.”
Mrs.Groenewegen went on to say, and I quote from the unedited Hansard from June 2:
“I believe the Member for Thebacha’s comments were made to intimidate me as I attempted to carry out my duty...as a Member to vote the way I wished on this potentially contentious motion.”
In responding to the point of privilege, the Member for Thebacha stated, and again I quote from the unedited Hansard:
“My one comment on that issue was that there’s an option that hasn’t been considered that I think is fully valid, and in fact, other Members, when it was discussed with them, agreed that it should be worth at least looking at.
“In the course of debate...I raised that comment and I raised that option. It was done within the context of broad debate. It was no threat.”
We are thus left with two competing interpretations of the spirit and intent of the Member for Thebacha’s comments. In the absence of further evidence I find it difficult to come to any clear and certain conclusion as to what exactly he was getting at.
Breaches of privilege are serious and should only be found to exist in rare circumstances. Intimidation and instruction of a Member is one of the most serious breaches of parliamentary privilege. When such actions are found to have occurred with absolute certainty, they should be and have been met with serious consequences in this House.
While the Member for Hay River South was justified to raise the matter, I am unable to find a prima facie breach of privilege with the evidence before me.
Members, the events in question occurred in Committee of the Whole. In reviewing the transcripts in the context of the point of privilege, I was surprised and concerned by the tone and context of the debate that day. The debate was frequently unrelated to the matter at hand, and in some circumstances it reflected upon previous votes of the House. False or hidden motives were attributed to some Members, and comments were made that were likely to and, in my view, intended to create disorder in this Chamber.
The debate before you is important and can be taxing. I want to urge each of you to exercise restraint and self-control when debating issues in this House. A failure to do so would be inconsistent with the traditions of consensus government and could usher in a new era of conflict and confrontation in the Legislative Assembly. The people we serve expect better from us as elected leaders. Thank you, Members.
Orders of the Day. Item 2, Ministers’ statements. The honourable Minister responsible for Transportation, Mr.Yakeleya.
Ministers’ Statements
Minister’s Statement 53-16(2)Drive Alive: Summer Safety Initiatives
Hon.NormanYakeleya: Mahsi, Mr.Speaker. [English translation not provided.]
Mr.Speaker, we all know the terrible effects of transportation accidents. This is why we continue to enhance the Drive Alive! Transportation safety program — to ensure the public has the information to make good choices when they travel in the NWT.
I am very passionate about this issue. We are particularly committed to our young people’s safety, as we all want them to grow into strong, healthy adults who can contribute to the northern way of life. Today I want to share some of the ways we are helping to increase the safety of young people, especially when they travel.
It has been proven that our children are very vulnerable when drivers do not pay full attention when driving in school zones. Although we have lower speed limits in school zones, some drivers fail to reduce their speed and place our children at risk. Changes to the Motor Vehicles Act regulations will double the fines for offences in school zones and construction zones. We are following the lead of a number of other jurisdictions that have found that increasing fines further assists in reducing speed in these critical zones.
We recently had a writing contest asking young people to share ways they and their families can reduce the risk of accidents and injuries when travelling. The winning entries are now posted on the Department of Transportation Web site youth page. I’m very impressed with the quality of these essays. Clearly, they gave a lot of thought to this important issue, and it demonstrates the quality of our young people and their teachers.
Nikita Larter from Thomas Simpson School said, “If you are traveling with two or more people, you are not only trying to keep yourself safe, but everyone else.”
Nadine Menacho from Chief Albert Wright School said, “On the road, we can wear our seatbelts, and babies should be in a car seat.... On the water, we can wear our life jackets.... On trails, we can wear our helmets.... When we do all of these things, we can make it safer for us.”
These are some of the worthy suggestions, and I hope people will listen to the wisdom of our young people.
One area of concern this summer is the safety of young people on bicycles. Sometimes our children do not drive as well as they should, and I encourage drivers to pay extra attention to kids on bikes. I’m very pleased to tell Members that as a result of a very generous contribution from BHP Billiton, 500 bicycle helmets will soon be available to young bicyclists across the territory. Drive Alive! is working with the Department of Health and Social Services to distribute these helmets across the Northwest Territories, and I want to acknowledge my colleague the Minister of Health and Social Services for the valuable assistance her department is providing.
This summer preschool and young school-aged children, along with their parents, will have an opportunity to learn more about transportation safety through a children’s activity book promoting safe choices. Each Member will receive copies of this book for distribution in their constituencies.
I encourage the Members and the public to keep an eye on the Department of Transportation Web site for important safety messages and to drive alive. Mahsi.
Mr.Speaker: Thank you, Mr.Yakeleya. The honourable Minister responsible for Industry, Tourism and Investment, Mr.Bob McLeod.
Minister’s Statement 54-16(2)Protected Area Strategy
Hon.BobMcLeod: Mr.Speaker, the Northwest Territories Protected Area Strategy helps NWT communities protect special areas of land for the long term. The strategy is the collective effort of both federal and territorial levels of government, aboriginal government and organizations, industry, and environmental organizations.
Through a variety of legislative tools and processes the strategy enables communities to identify and protect culturally and ecologically significant or core representative areas of our territory. For example, a chosen area can be preserved under the Territorial Parks Act as a cultural conservation area, a heritage park, a natural environment park or a wilderness conservation area. These classifications were determined through extensive collaborations with our partners in the Protected Area Strategy, including aboriginal representatives, environmental organizations and the federal government.
The Department of Industry, Tourism and Investment has created an information package to help communities understand the processes and tools that are available for establishing territorial parks as a means of protecting our valuable lands. I have forwarded this information to Members of this Assembly, and ITI representatives are looking forward to meeting with communities who would like to learn more about how territorial parks can be used as a tool in the PAS process.
We depend on our land and natural resources for our wealth and our livelihood. Land management options such as the creation of territorial parks under the Protected Area Strategy are one way that we can work in partnership to manage our lands and resources for the future.
Mr.Speaker: Thank you, Mr.McLeod. Item 3, Members’ statements. The honourable Member for Nunakput, Mr.Jacobson.
Members’ Statements
Member’s Statement onInuvialuit Final Agreement25th Anniversary
Mr.Jacobson: Thank you, Mr.Speaker. It’s with great pride that I rise today, for today is a special day for all Inuvialuit everywhere. Today is the 24th anniversary of the signing of the Inuvialuit Final Agreement.
Back in the early ’70s a group comprised of both young and old Inuvialuit realized that if they did not get organized, they might lose their rights as Inuvialuit people, so they established the Committee of Original Peoples’ Entitlement, also known as COPE. In 1974 they entered into formal negotiations with the Government of Canada. After ten years of negotiations, on June 5, 1984, COPE and the Government of Canada signed the Inuvialuit Final Agreement. This was the first comprehensive land claim agreement signed north of the 60th parallel and only the second in Canada at that time.