The 185th Meeting of the Northern Regional Committee (NRC), National Council for Teacher Education (NCTE) was held from 26 July 2011 to 31st July, 2011 at NRC, Jaipur.

In pursuance of the Gazette Notification No.213 dated 25.08.2010, NRC has been terminated under Section 21(2)(a) of NCTE Act, 1993 and the powers and duties on behalf of the Northern Regional Committee are being exercised and performed under Section 21(2)(b) by Shri Hasib Ahmad, former Member Secretary, NCTE.

The following member and convener were present:-

  1. Shri Hasib Ahmad, Chairperson, NRC, NCTE
  2. Shri. R.D. Sharma, Regional Director, NRC, NCTE

With the permission of Shri Hasib Ahmad, Chairman, Shri R.D. Sharma (Convener) presented the Agenda before the Committee. Item-wise decisions taken are as follows:--

AGENDA ITEM No. 185.01:- Confirmation of the minutes of 184th NRC Meeting

S. No / Cases / Decision of NRC
The minutes of 184th NRC Meeting held from 27th June to 1st July, 2011 has been uploaded on the website of NRC. / Minutes of 184thmeeting are confirmed.

AGENDA ITEM:--185.02.

CONSIDERATIOIN OF REPLY OF DEFICIENCIES OF NEW APPLICATIONS

Sr. No. / File Code No. / Name of the Institution / Name of the Society / Name of the Course / Decision of NRC
NRCAPP-478 / M.P. Institute of Management and Computer Application, Plot No.- 285/116, Village- Raimala, Post Office- Amauli, Tehsil- Chiraigaon, Distt.- Varanasi-221001, U.P. / Deen Dayal Upadhyay Shikshan Samiti, Plot No. 285, Street / Road – Balua Ghat Road, Village – Bhagatua, Post Office – Amauli, Tehsil – Chiraigaon, Town / City & District – Varanasi – 221001, U.P. / D.El.Ed. /
  1. In response to the letter of Deficiency, the Institution’s reply dated 07.01.2011 has been considered. The Institution submitted copies of ‘Dakhil Kharij’ ‘Kishan Bhai’ and a copy of the Sale Deed (Notarized) for 0.579 Hectare of land in the name of this Society. However, a certified copy of the land document, as required in Regulation, has not been submitted.
  2. The Institution submitted a building plan with the title “Existing and Proposed Plan of M.P. Institute of Management and Computer Application”. This map does not provide the details of existing built up area and the manner in which it is being used for its existing courses. The plan also does not give the earmarked land and earmarked built up area for the proposed course. Thus, the proposal is not in accordance with the Regulation 8(7)(1) of NCTE Regulation, 2009 which requires specific earmarked land built up area for a teacher training Institution.
  3. The Institution is already conducting MBA, BBA courses, but it did not provide the details of these courses in the relevant column of the application making it incomplete and liable to the rejected.
Hence NRC decided to issue Show Cause Notice to the institution under section 14(3) (b) of the NCTE Act 1993 on the above points and directs the Institute to reply within 30 days.
NRCAPP-523 / K.V. Educational Institute, Plot No-462, Street Road-Shamsabad Road, Village/ Town/City-Naubary, Post Office-Gutila, Tehsil-/Taluka-Sadar, Town/City-Agra, District-Agra, Pin Code-282001 (U.P) / Khushi Educational Society, Plot No-462, Street Road-Shamsabad Road, Village/Town/City-Naubary, Post Office-Gutila, Tehsil-/Taluka-Sadar, Town/City-Agra, District-Agra, Pin Code-282001 (U.P) / D.El.Ed. / VT to be Constituted.
NRCAPP-465 / Seth Gagan Das Smriti Samiti Girls College, Khasra /Plot No. S-4, Street/Road – Ratanpur, Village/Town/City – Ratanpur, Post Office – Panki, Tehsil/ Taluka – Kanpur, Town/City – Kanpur, Distt. – Kanpur Nagar, State – Uttar Pradesh, Pin Code – 208020 / Seth Gagan Das Smriti Samiti, Plot No. 117/N/5, Street/Road – MBM House, Village/Town/ City – Raniganj N Block, Post Office – Naveen Nagar, Tehsil/Taluka – Kanpur, Town/City – Kanpur, Distt. – Kanpur Nagar, State – Uttar Pradesh, Pin Code 208025 / D.El.Ed / The reply of the Institution dated 17.01.2011 with reference to the letter of Deficiency has been considered, whereas the Institution has met the deficiencies; the Institution also applied for a B.Ed.Course which has been sanctioned to the Institution on 2nd July, 2011 by NRC. As such, the Institution is not entitled for recognition of another teacher training course before completing 3 academic sessions of the newly recognized course in view of provision under clause 8(2) and 8(3) of the NCTE Regulation, 2009.
Hence the committee decided to issue Show Cause Notice to the institution under section 14(3) (b) of the NCTE Act 1993 on the above points and directs the Institute to reply within 30 days.
NRCAPP-758 / Guru Nanak College of Education, Plot Number-5/5,25/27, Street Number -Gopalpur, Village-Gopalpur, Post office-Dehlon, Tehsil/Taluka-Ludhiana, Town/city-Dehlon, District-Ludhiana, State-Punjab, Pin code-141118 / Guru Nanak Educational Charitable Society, Plot Number-5/5,25/27, Street /Road-Ludhiana Malerkotla Road, Village/Town/city-Gopalpur, Post office-Dehlon, Tehsil/ Taluka-Ludhiana, Town/city-Dehlon, District-Ludhiana, State-Punjab, Pin code-141118 / M.Ed. / The reply of the Institution dated 03.01.2011 with reference to the letter of deficiency has been considered. The application of the Institution continues to suffer from following infirmities:
  1. The land in possession of the Institution is on lease from a party, which is not in accordance with clause 8(7)(i) of the NCTE Regulation, 2009.
  2. The Institution was recognized for a B.Ed.Course on 05.05.2008 and has not yet completed three academic sessions. As such, Institution was not ever eligible to apply for an additional Course as per provisions in Clause 8(3) of the NCTE Regulations, 2009.
Hence the committee decided to issue Show Cause Notice to the institution under section 15(3) (b) of the NCTE Act 1993 on the above points and directs the Institute to reply within 30 days.
NRCAPP-610 / District Institute of Education and Training Rajlamai, Farrukhabad, Plot Number - 1,279, Street/Number – NA, Village/Town/city – Rajlamai, Post office – Kisroli, Tehsil/Taluka – Kayamganj, Town/city – Rural, District – Farrukabad, State – Uttar Pardesh, Pin code – 207502 / Government Institution, Plot Number -1,279, Street/Road – Kayamganj, Village/ Town/city – Rajlamai, Post office – Kisroli, Tehsil/Taluka – Kayamganj, Town/ city – Rural, District – Farrukabad, State – Uttar Pardesh, Pin code – 207502 / D.El.Ed. / VT to be Constituted.
NRCAPP-466 / N.K. College Nagla Balu Mainpuri, Plot No.-1167, Street No.- Kusm Road, Village- Nagla Balu, Post Office- Alau, Tehsil- Bhongaon, Town/City- Alau, Distt.- Mainpuri-205001, U.P. / Ch. Suraj Singh Memorial Trust Mainpuri, Plot No.80, Street/Road – Station Road, Village/ Town/City – Mainpuri, Post Office – Mainpuri, Tehsil/Taluka – Mainpuri, Town/City – Mainpuri, Distt. – Mainpuri, State – Uttar Pradesh, Pin Code-205001 / D.El.Ed. / VT to be Constituted.
NRCAPP-443 / Smt. Shiv Dulari Singh, Mahaila Degree College, Khasara No. – 1329 to 1333, 1339, 1342, Village – Gungwachh, Tehsil-Amethi, Distt.- Sultanpur-227405, U.P. / Ranjeet Singh Vidyalaya Samiti, Plot No.- 1339,1342, Durapur Amethi Road, Village- Gungwachh, Post Office-Karundi, City-Amethi, District-Sultanour-227405, U.P. / D.El.Ed. / VT to be Constituted.
NRCAPP-447 / Raja Kanh Degree College,Village- Jagesharganj, Tehsil/Taluka- Gauriganj, Town/City – Sultanpur, Distt. – Sultanpur-227809, State – Uttar Pradesh. / Raja Kanh Degree College Shiksha Samiti, Plot/Khasra No. 234, 235, Street/Road- JagdishpurJayas Road Village- Jagesharganj, Post Office- Jagesharganj, Tehsil/Taluka- Gauriganj, Town/City – Sultanpur, Distt. – Sultanpur, State – Uttar Pradesh, Pin Code- 227809 / D.El.Ed. / The reply dated 11.02.2011 in response to the letter of deficiency has been considered. The following infirmities in the application of the Institution has been noted:
  1. The Institution namely Raja Kanha Degree College is an affiliated College of Dr. R.M. L. Awadh University, Ferozabad and must be conducting multi-faculty courses. However, no details of the existing courses, other than teacher education courses, being conducted by the Institution has been given in the application. The application is therefore incomplete and misleading.
  2. The building plan of Raja Kanha Degree College has been submitted by the Institution but no earmarking of required built up area has been done in the building plan. The Institution has not given details of existing courses and enrollment in these courses, so as to appreciate the availability of required built up area in the college building for the proposed D.El.Ed. Course.
Hence the committee decided to issue Show Cause Notice to the institution under section 14(3) (b) of the NCTE Act 1993 on the above points and directs the Institute to reply within 30 days.
NRCAPP-537 / Ram Kaliash Teacher Training Institute, Plot Number – 717,718, Street/ Number – 0, Village/Town/city – Akma, Post office – Kumarganj, Tehsil/Taluka – Milkipur, Town/city – Faizabad, District – Faizabad, State – Uttar Pradesh, Pin code - 224229 / Ram Kailash Shikshan Evam Sewa Sansthan, Plot Number – 717, Street/ Road – Kumarganj-Khandasa Road, Village/Town/city – Akma, Post/ office – Kumarganj, Tehsil/Taluka – Milkipur, Town/city – Faizabad, District – Faizabad, State – Uttar Pradesh, Pin code - 224229 / D.El.Ed. / VT to be Constituted.
NRCAPP-538 / Sri Ram Chandra Singh Shikshan Prashikshna Sansthan, Plot Number – 279, Street/Road – Rudauli- Saidpur Marg, Village/Town/city – Lohti Saraiya, Post office – Amraigaon, Tehsil/Taluka – Rudauli, Town/city – Faizabad, District – Faizabad, State – Uttar Pradesh, Pin code – 225411 / Rohit Gramodyog Sansthan, Plot Number – 279, Street/Road – Rudauli- Saidpur Marg, Village/Town/city – Lohti Saraiya, Post office – Amraigaon, Tehsil/Taluka – Rudauli, Town/city – Faizabad, District – Faizabad, State – Uttar Pradesh, Pin code – 225411 / D.El.Ed. / VT to be Constituted.
NRCAPP-511 / Chandrabali Singh Urmila Mahavidyalay, Khasra Plot No. 1250, 1263, 1264, 1326, 1334, Street/Road – 00, Village/Town/City – Bhawan, Post Office – Kumarganj, Tehsil/Taluka – Milkipur, Town/City – Faizabad, Distt. – Faizabad, State – Uttar Pradesh, Pin Code 224229 / Chandrabali Singh Urmila Shikshan Sansthan, Plot No. 1250, Street/Road– Faizabad Raibareily, Village/Town/City–Bawan, Post Office– Kumarganj, Tehsil/Taluka-Milkipur, Town/City –Faizabad, Distt.–Faizabad, State–Uttar Pradesh, Pin Code 224229 / D.El.Ed. / The Institution is an existing Degree College having BA level course in various disciplines. The Institution has a total built up area of 2283.29 Sq. metres and has earmarked 782.76 Sq. Metre for its existing B.A. Course. The Institution has not provided details of the existing courses and the manner of use of the total built up area of the college by the existing courses, so as to clearly establish the exact available space for the proposed D.El.Ed. Course. In view of the subject in B.A. Course and total enrolment therein, it is not possible to appreciate, whether the Institution would be able to earmark required 1500 Sq. Meter for the proposed D.El.Ed. Course.
Hence the committee decided to issue Show Cause Notice to the institution under section 14(3) (b) of the NCTE Act 1993 on the above points and directs the Institute to reply within 30 days.
NRCAPP-554 / Maa Saraswati College of Education, Plot No.- 408, Street/Road- 0, Village/Town/City- Kurauna, Post Office- SAruni, Tehsil/Taluka- Sadar, Town/City- Varanasi, District- Varanasi, Pin Code- 221302, Uttar Pradesh / Maa Saraswati Ucchatter Madhyamik Vidyalay Samiti, Plot No-408, Street Road-Varanasi-Bhadohi Road, Village/Town/City-Kurauna, Post Office-Saruni, Tehsil-/Taluka-Sadar, Town/City-Varanasi, District- Varanasi, Pin Code-221302 (U.P.) / D.El.Ed. / The reply of the Institution dated 14.02.2011 with reference to the letter of deficiency has been considered. Following infirmities in the application of the Institution has been found:
  1. The teacher training Institution is proposed by the Management Committee of the “Maa Saraswati Ucchatter Madhyamic Vidyalay” and is located in the same premises/land in which the school exists. The applicant Society has not given any details of the existing land/building of its Senior Secondary School and earmarking of the land and built up area for the proposed teacher training institution.
  2. It is also apparent from the facts given in the CLU that the Institution plans to run the D.El.Ed. course in the School building, which is not permissible and is contrary to provision 8(7)(ii) of the NCTE Regulations, 2009.
Hence the committee decided to issue Show Cause Notice to the institution under section 14(3) (b) of the NCTE Act 1993 on the above points and directs the Institute to reply within 30 days.
NRCAPP – 817 / Kishanpyari Shukla College, Plot Number – 608, Street Number – 0, Village – Mundesi, Post Office – Dhangaon, Tehsil/Taluka – Mathura, Town/City – Mathura, District – Mathura, State – UP, Pin Code – 281004 / Shri Girraj Maharaj Educational and Charitable Society Mathura, Plot No. 5, Street / Road – Army Garden, Village/ Town/City - Krishna Nagar, Post Office – Krishna Nagar, Tehsil/Taluka – Mathura, District – Mathura, State – UP, Pin Code – 281004 / D.El.Ed. / The reply of the institution dated 14.02.2011 w.r.t .the letter of deficiency has been considered the following infirmities have been noted in the application
(a)The Institution namely Kishanpyari Shukla College is proposed on plot number 608, Vill.-Mundesi. The same society is running a B.Ed. Course in the same village with the name SGM Institution of Management, Mundesi, Mathura. The Institution in its present application did not indicate this B.Ed. Course. However, Society also applied for a D.El.Ed. Course in this SGM Institution of Management and a reference of this application has been made. Thus, the Society is already having an Institution with B.Ed. Course in the Village Mundesi at Plot No. 608 and has applied for a D.El.Ed. Course in the same village in the name of another Institution. This situation amounts to circumventing the provision in the NCTE Regulation 2009, which requires that an Institution can apply for an additional course only after 3 academic sessions. Moreover, opening two teacher training institution by a society at the same place or in the vicinity with two different names amounts to commercialization of teacher education and NCTE is bound to curb it as per mandate given to it under NCTE Act.
Hence the committee decided to issue Show Cause Notice to the institution under section 14(3) (b) of the NCTE Act 1993 on the above points and directs the Institute to reply within 30 days.
NRCAPP-589 / SGM Institute OF Management Mundesi Mathura, Plot No 625, Village-Mundesi, Post Office-Dhangaon, Tehsil-Mathura, District- Mathura-281004 (U.P.) / Shri Girraj Maharaj Educational and Charitable Society, Plot No. 5, Street / Road – Army Garden, Village & Post Office – Krishna Nagar, Tehsil – Matura, District – Mathura – 281004 (U.P.) / D.El.Ed. / The reply of the Institution dated 14.02.2011 with reference to the letter of deficiency has been considered. The following infirmities has been found in the applications:
i.The Institution has been recognized for a B.Ed. Course on 20.02.2010 (UP-3196/153) and was affiliated to the University only in June, 2010. The Institution has therefore not completed 3 academic sessions of its B.Ed. Course and was therefore not even eligible to apply for an additional course in view of clause 8(2) of the NCTE Regulations, 2009. The present application therefore needs to be rejected.
Hence the committee decided to issue Show Cause Notice to the institution under section 14(3) (b) of the NCTE Act 1993 on the above points and directs the Institute to reply within 30 days.
NRCAPP-471 / Aprup Shikshan Sansthan, Plot No.- 16KA, 16KH, 17KA, 17KH, 17GA, 17GHA, Village- Ahirauli, Post Office- Ayar, Tehsil- Sadar, Varanasi, Distt.- Varanasi-221210, U.P. / Apruva Devi Memorial Trust, Plot Number -197, Street No-Vidhya Wasini Nagar Colony, Village/Post Office/Town-Orderly Bazar, Tehsil-/Taluka-Sadar, Town/City Varanasi, District-Varanasi, Pin Code-221002, U.P. / D.El.Ed. / VT to be Constituted.
NRCAPP-1033 / RSD Acadedmy Girls Degree College, Plot Number – 12, Street Number – 0, Village – Harthala Ahtamali, Post office – Moradabad, Tehsil/Taluka – Moradabad, Town/city – Moradabad, District – Moradabad, State – UP, Pin code – 244001 / S V G Charitable Trust, Plot Number – 12, Street/Road – Ram Ganga Vihar, Village/Town/city – Moradabad, Post office – Mordabad, Tehsil/ Taluka – Moradabad, Town/city – Moradabad, District – Moradabad, State – UP, Pin code – 244001 / D.El.Ed. / In reply of the Institution dated 24.02.2011 with reference to the letter of deficiency has been considered and following observations made:
  1. The Institution has got approved a huge Management/Educational Complex from Moradabad Development Authority. The original approved map has not been submitted and the photocopy is not clearly legible. The Society also submitted another small building plan with 1553 Sq. Metre of built up area, but then it has not approval of the Moradabad Development Authority.
  2. The Institution has not given any details of the existing courses being conducted on the Campus whose building plan was approved by MDA in 2009 and the location of the said degree college in that campus.
Hence the committee decided to issue Show Cause Notice to the institution under section 14(3) (b) of the NCTE Act 1993 on the above points and directs the Institute to reply within 30 days.
NRCAPP-615 / Smt Jawala Devi College Of Education, Plot/Khasara Number- 24, Street/Road- GT Road, Village/Town/City- Sanghol, Post Office- Sanghol, Tehsil/Taluka- Khamano, Town/City- Sanghol, District- Fatehgarh Sahib, State- Punjab, Pin Code- 141128 / Smt Jawala Devi Memorial Trust, Plot Number- 24, Street/Road- GT Road, Village/Town/City- Sanghol, Post Office- Sanghol, Tehsil/Taluka- Khamano, Town/City- Sanghol, District- Fatehgarh Sahib, State- Punjab, Pin Code- 141128 / D.El.Ed. / The reply dated 07.02.2011 of the Society with reference to the letter of deficiency has been considered and following observations made:
  1. The building plan submitted is not approved by competent authority. Notarized copy of the building plan is not acceptable.
  2. The notarized copy of the building plan is on the same building, which is being used for B.Ed. Course and has a 1325 Sq. Metre of built up area. The new building of the building plan gives built up area as 1506 Sq. Metre. This area is short of the prescribed area of 3000 Sq. Metre for a combined B.Ed. and D.El.Ed. Course.
  3. The Institution has failed to give a notarized copy of the CLU.
Hence the committee decided to issue Show Cause Notice to the institution under section 14(3) (b) of the NCTE Act 1993 on the above points and directs the Institute to reply within 30 days.
NRCAPP-515 / Premwati Devi Smarak Mahila Mahavidyalaya, Plot No. 3,4,7 to 11, 13, 14 & 16, Street / Road – N.H. 74, Village & Post Office – Puraini, Tehsil – Nagina, District – Bijnor – 246762, U.P. / Premwati Devi Memorial Shiksha Samiti, Plot No. 3,4,7,8 & 9, Street / Road – N.H. 74, Village & Post Office – Puraini, Tehsil – Nagina, District – Bijnor – 246762 (U.P.) / D.El.Ed. /
  1. The Institution is an existing Degree College having BA Level Course in 7 disciplines. The degree college as per building plan has a total built up area of 1791 Sq. Metres. in three floors. The Institution has not provided details of the existing courses and use of the total built up area of the college by the existing courses, so as to clearly establish the exact available space for the proposed D.El.Ed.Course. In view of number of other courses at graduate level required area of 1500 Sq. Meters is not available for the proposed course.
  2. The Institution could not submit proper CLU issued by SDM under section 143 of the UP Land Act. The Court Document regarding comprises of two parties on the ownership of land cannot be accepted in lieu of CLU.
  3. The Institution is not providing details of the existing courses in the college, submitted an incomplete application and also mislead the Council. The application is therefore liable to be rejected.
Hence the committee decided to issue Show Cause Notice to the institution under section 14(3) (b) of the NCTE Act 1993 on the above points and directs the Institute to reply within 30 days.