Minutes of 149TH Meeting of NRC held on 13TH & 14TH September 2009

MINUTES OF 149TH MEETING OF NORTHERN REGIONAL COMMITTEE HELD ON 13TH TO 14TH SEPTEMBER 2009

The 149th meeting of the Northern Regional Committee (NRC), National Council for Teacher Education (NCTE) was held from 13TH to 14TH September 2009 at Jaipur. The following members and convener were present:

1.  / Prof. D.N.Sansanwal / Chairperson, NRC-NCTE
2.  / Prof. U. C. Vashishtha / Member, NRC-NCTE
3.  / Prof. M.K.Das / Member, NRC-NCTE
4.  / Mrs. Usha Bapna / Representative of the State Govt of Rajasthan.
5.  / Dr. Jagdish Prasad / Representative of the State Govt of Uttrakhand
6.  / Dr. R.S. Barar / Representative of the UT Chandigarh.
7.  / Dr. K.S. Yadav / Convener, RD, NRC, NCTE

Prof. F. U. Khan, Prof. M.P. Sharma, Prof. Bharti Baweja and Prof. S.P. Anand could not attend the meeting.

Dr K.S. Yadav, Convener RD, NRC, NCTE welcomed the Hon’ble Chairperson and members of Northern Regional Committee.

With the permission of the Chairperson, Dr. K.S.Yadav (Convener) presented the Agenda before the Committee. Agenda-wise decisions taken were as follows:-

S. NO. / AGENDA NO. / CASES / DECISION OF NRC
1 / 149.01. / CONFIRMATION OF THE MINUTES OF THE 148TH MEETING OF NRC. THE MINUTES OF 148TH MEETING OF NRC HELD ON 28-30 AUGUST 2009 HAVE BEEN UPLOADED ON THE WEBSITE OF NRC. / Minutes are confirmed.

AGENDA ITEM NO: 149.02.00 CONSIDERATION OF APPEAL ORDERS

S.NO. / AGENDA NO. / NAME OF THE INSTITUTION / APPEAL ORDER / APPEAL DECISION / DECISION OF NRC
2 / 1 / Guru Dronacharya College of Education, Vill-Dhani Kirarod, Post-Dharsu, The-Narnaul, Mohindergarh, Haryana, HR-1389, COURSE – B.Ed. / F.No.89-539 / 2009 / Appeal / dated 07.08.2009 / The appeal was accepted and NRC’s order dated 29.05.2009 was set aside with direction to the NRC to grant recognition to the institution immediately. / Appeal committee decision noted and process file as directed.
3 / 2 / Shree Ganpati Institute of Education & Technology, Vill-Faizabad, Post-Hudina, Tehs-Narnaul, Distt-Mohindergarh, Haryana, HR-1259, COURSE – B.Ed. / F.No.89-538 / 2009 appeal / 2009-appeal dated 07.08.2009 / The appeal was accepted and NRC’s order dated 23.04.09 was set aside with direction to the NRC to grant recognition to the institution immediately. / Appeal committee decision noted and process file as directed.
4 / 3 / V.B. TEACHER TRAININIG AND RESEARCH, JIND BYE PASS, TOWARD HISAR ROAD, THE.DISTT-ROHTAK, Haryana, HR-1368, COURSE – D.Ed., HR-1368 / F.No. 89-524 / 2009 appeal /2009-appeal dated 07.08.2009 / The appeal was accepted and NRC’s order dated 03.06.09 was set aside with the direction to the NRC to grant recognition to the Institution immediately. / Appeal committee decision noted and process file as directed.
5 / 4 / H.J. Institute of Education & Technology, VPO-Palri, Ranihara, Teh & Dist. Mohindergarh, Haryana,
HR-1001, COURSE-B.Ed. / F.No. 89-338/ 2009 appeal/ 2009-appeal dated 07.08.2009 / The appeal was accepted and NRC’s order dated 23.04.09 was set aside. / Appeal committee decision noted and process file as directed.
6 / 5 / Triveni College of Education, 4th Mile Stone, Hissar Road, Sirsa – 125 055, Haryana, HR-329, COURSE-B.Ed. / F.No. 89-338/ 2009 appeal/ 2009-appeal/ 99307 dated 07.08.2009 / The appeal was accepted and NRC’s order dated 15.06.2009 was set aside. / Appeal committee decision noted and process file as directed.
7 / 6 / Department of Physical Education, Chaudhary, Devi Lal University, Sirsa, Haryana. HR-877, COURSE-M.P.Ed. / F.No.89-586/ 2009 /Appeal/ dated 07.08.2009 / The appeal was accepted and NRC’s order dated 10.06.2009 was set aside with direction to the NRC to grant recognition to the institution immediately. / Appeal committee decision noted and process file as directed.
8 / 7 / Haryana College of Education, Kinana, Jind, Haryana.
HR-321, COURSE- JBT / F.No. 89-338/ 2009 appeal/ 2009-appeal/ 99787 dated 07.08.2009 / The appeal was accepted and NRC’s decision was set aside with direction to the NRC to re-examine the staff profile of the institution afresh to ascertain whether it has been appointed as per NCTE norms and procedure prescribed. / As per decision of appeal committee, the documents related to appointment of Faculty were screened and the committee directs the Institution to submit the photocopies of the mark-sheets of appointed Faculty members within 21 days.
9 / 8 / I.P.S.E. College of Education, Sco-17, Sector-13,VPO-Jundla, Teh-Karnai, Distt-Karnal, Haryana. HR-1764, B.Ed. / F.No.89-454/ 2009/ Appeal/07.08.2009 / The appeal of the institution was accepted, orders of NRC dated 12.05.2009 were set aside and the case was remanded back to the NRC for inspection of the institution immediately and thereafter to issue order. / Appeal committee decision noted and process file as directed.
10 / 9 / Sharbati College of Education, Gaushala Road, Mohindergarh, Distt-Mohindergarh, Haryana.
HR-413, COURSE-B.Ed. / F.No.89-593 / 2009 / 9379 /Appeal /
07.08.2009 / There was adequate ground to accept the appeal, set aside the NRC’s order dated 15.06.2009 and remand back the case to the NRC for issue of a revised order specifying that the withdrawal effective from the academic session 2009 - 2010. Accordingly, the case was remanded back to the NRC for issue of revised order. / Appeal committee decision noted and process file as directed.
11 / 10 / Mewat College of Education, Mewat, Haryan.
(Original file is awaited from NCTE Hq.) HR-1843, COURSE- B.Ed. / F.No.89-541/ Appeal/ dated 07.08.2009 / There was adequate grounds to accept the appeal, set aside NRC’s order dated 19.05.2009 and remand back the case for inspection of the institution to verify availability of necessary infrastructure, instructional and other facilities in accordance with the norms prescribed by the NCTE to become eligible for recognition by NCTE. Accordingly, the case was remanded back to the NRC for inspection of the institution immediately. / Appeal committee decision noted and process file as directed.
12 / 11 / Shri Ram Shikshan Samiti, Mohindergarh, Haryana. HR-1739, COURSE – B.Ed. / F.No.89-571/2009 /Appeal/ 100043 Dated 07.08.2009 / The appeal was rejected and NRC’s order dated 04.06.2009 was confirmed. / Appeal committee decision noted and process file as directed.
13 / 12 / Vaish College of Education, Rohtak, Haryana. HR-303, COURSE-D.Ed. / F.No.89-490/ 2009 /Appeal / 100141 Dated 07.08.2009 / The appeal was rejected and NRC’s order dated 09.06.2009 was confirmed. / Appeal committee decision noted and process file as directed.
14 / 13 / Balaji College of Education, Ballabgarh, Haryana. HR-1364, COURSE- M.Ed. / F.No.89-572/2009 Appeal /99967/dated 07.08.2009 / The appeal was rejected and NRC’s order dated 12.05.2009 was confirmed. / Appeal committee decision noted and process file as directed.
15 / 14 / Matu Ram College of Education, Kurukshetra, Haryana. HR-1390, COURSE-D.Ed. / F.No.89-468/2009 Appeal /99899/dated 07.08.2009 / The appeal was rejected and NRC’s order dated 23.04.2009 was confirmed. / Appeal committee decision noted and process file as directed.
16 / 15 / Aggarwal Vidya Pracharni Sabha’s Aggarwal College of Educatin, Milk Plont Road, Ballabgarh, Faridabad, Haryana. HR-1402,
COURSE-B.Ed. / F.No.89-489/2009 Appeal /99963/dated 07.08.2009 / The appeal was rejected and NRC’s order dated 29.05.2009 was confirmed. / Appeal committee decision noted and process file as directed.
17 / 16 / Vaish College of Education, Bhiwani, Haryana. HR-1294, COURSE- B.Ed. / F.No. 89-518/ Appeal/2009/99751/ dated 07.08.2009 / The appeal was rejected and NRC’s order dated 29.05.2009 was confirmed. / Appeal committee decision noted and process file as directed.
18 / 17 / K.L. Mehta Dayanand College for Women Faridabad. Haryana, HR-1359,
COURSE- B.P.Ed. / F.No. 89-317/ Appeal/2009/99655/ dated 07.08.2009 / The appeal was rejected and NRC’s order dated 11.05.2009 was confirmed. / Appeal committee decision noted and process file as directed.
19 / 18 / Gurudham College of Education, Hisar, Haryana. HR-1736, COURSE-B.Ed. / F.No. 89-339/ Appeal /2009/99647/ dated 07.08.2009 / The appeal was rejected and NRC’s order dated 12.05.2009 was confirmed. / Appeal committee decision noted and process file as directed.
20 / 19 / Doon Valley Institute of Education, Karnal, Haryana. HR-674, COURSE- M.Ed. / F.No. 89-699/ Appeal / 2009/99475/ dated 07.08.2009 / The appeal was rejected and NRC’s order dated 10.06.2009 was confirmed. / Appeal committee decision noted and process file as directed.
21 / 20 / Rani laxmi Bai college of Education, Kurukshetra, Haryana., HR- 1489,
COURSE- D.Ed. / F.No. 89-551/ Appeal /2009/99871/ dated 07.08.2009 / The appeal was rejected and NRC’s order dated 22.04.2009 was confirmed. / Appeal committee decision noted and process file as directed.
22 / 21 / Addarsh College of Education, Kurukshetra, Haryana.
HR-1492, COURSE- D.Ed. / F.No. 89-453/ Appeal /2009/99891/ dated 07.08.2009 / The appeal was rejected and NRC’s order dated 23.04.2009 was confirmed. / Appeal committee decision noted and process file as directed.
23 / 22 / Lord Krishna College of Education, Hissar, Haryana. HR-1731, COURSE- B.Ed. / F.No.89-475 /2009 / Appeal/99987/
Dated 07.08.2009 / The appeal was rejected and NRC’s order dated 23.04.2009 was confirmed. / Appeal committee decision noted and process file as directed.
24 / 23 / Satguru Shikshan Sansthan, Jhunjhunu, Rajasthan.
RJ-2075, COURSE- B.Ed. / F.No.89-508/ 2009 / Appeal /99723/
Dated 07.08.2009 / The appeal was rejected and NRC’s order dated 17.04.2009 was confirmed. / Appeal committee decision noted and process file as directed.

AGENDA ITEM NO 149.03.00 CONSIDERATION OF THE COURT CASE

S.L NO. / AGENDA NO. / COURSE / BRIEF OF CASE / DECISION OF NRC
25 / 1 / I.P. POST GRADUATE COLLEGE, BULANDSHAHAR, UP. COURSE – M.Ed.,
U.P. -1722 / AS PER DECISION OF NRC, IN ITS 147TH MEETING SCN REGARDING 7(9) ISSUED ON 22.8.2009. THE INSTITUTION SUBMITTED REPLY DATED 29.8.2009. / The original file of the institution, Reply of the Institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee observes the following:
·  As per NCTE norms One Professor, One Reader and three lectures are to be appointed. But the Institution has appointed Four Lectures as against three lectures. One Professor and one Reader have not been appointed.
Hence, the committee decides to refuse recognition to M.Ed. course.
26 / 2 / DHANVANTRI EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTE, KHASRA NO. 18, 19, 20, MAUZA – JALAL, FARAH, DISTT. – MATHURA, U.P.
UP-3154, COURSE – B.Ed. / AS PER DECISION OF NRC IN ITS 146TH MEETING RECOGNITION OF B.ED. COURSE REFUSED ON FOLLOWING GROUNDS:
(1) AS PER LETTER DATED 23.3.2009, THE INSTITUTION WAS DIRECTED TO REGISTER THE LAND IN THE NAME OF INSTITUTION WITHIN 90 DAYS. THIS HAS NOT BEEN DONE WITHIN THE STIPULATED TIME. (2) THE FACULTY HAS NOT BEEN SELECTED THROUGH DULY CONSTITUTED SELECTION COMMITTEE AS PER NCTE NORMS. THE INSTITUTION HAS FILED W.P. NO. 42498 / 2009 SHRI VENUDHAR SHIKSHA VIKAS SAMITI, AGRA VS. NATIONAL COUNCIL FOR TEACHER EDUCATION ON HON’BLE HIGH COURT ALLAHABAD. DIRECTION OF THE COURSE IS AS UNDER:
“ BY MEANS OF THIS WRIT PETITION, THE PETITIONER HAS CHALLENGED THE DECISION OF NRC , NCTE , JAIPUR IN HIS 146TH MEETING HELD FROM 5-7 AUGUST 2009 BY WHICH IT HAS BEEN RESOLVED THAT FACULTY HAS NOT BEEN SELECTED FOR GRANTING RECOGNITION. IT HAS BEEN SUBMITTED BY SRI M.K. GUPTA, LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONER THAT THE PETITIONER’S INSTITUTION HAS BEEN IGNORED ONLY FOR THE REASON THAT LAND IS NOT REGISTERED IN THE NAME OF INSTITUTION. IN HIS SUBMISSIONS, UNLESS RECOGNITION IS GRANTED, SALE DEED CAN NOT BE EXECUTED IN THE NAME OF INSTITUTION. HE HAS ALSO SUBMITTED THAT THE PETITIONER HAS BEEN DISCRIMINATED AS IN THE SIMILAR CIRCUMSTANCE, THE SAME COMMITTEE HAS RESOLVED AND GIVEN RECOGNITION TO GET THE SALE DEED REGISTERED IN THE NAME OF INSTITUTION WITHIN SIX MONTHS FROM THE DATE OF GRANT OF RECOGNITION IN RESPECT OF JAIN BALIKA VIDYA PEETH, KHERA BAGHPAT AND SAVITRI MAHILA DEGREE COLLEGE, TIKPURA, DISTT. – FAIZABAD AND MANY OTHERS. THESE INSTITUTIONS HAVE BEEN GRANTED TEMPORARY RECOGNITION SUBJECT TO EXECUTION OF SALE DEED IN THE MEETING HELD IN JULY 2009.
IN VIEW OF THAT, AN INTERIM MANDAMUS IS ISSUED DIRECTING THE RESPONDENT NO. 1 TO GRANT SAME TYPE OF RECOGNITION TO THE PETITIONER’S INSTITUTION OR SHOW CAUSE WITHIN TWO WEEKS. / The original file of the institution, Reply of the Institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee decides to issue letter under clause 7(11) of regulation 2007. The case may be referred to HQs regarding the academic session from which the recognition is to be granted.
27 / 3 / SHIV NATH VERMA SMARAK MAHAVIDYALAYA, DEV NAGAR, KHANPUR PILAI, SULTANPUR, U.P. / W.P. NO. 6207(M/B) OF 2009 JUDGEMENT OF HON’BLE HIGH COURT JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD LUCKNOW BENCH LUCKNOW DATED 22.7.2009 MATTER WAS PLACED IN NRC IN ITS 147TH MEETING AND COMMITTEE OBSERVED THE FOLLOWING :
(A) KHASRA NUMBER/ PLOT NUMBER IS NOT MENTIONED ON THE BUILDING PLAN.
(B) THE RESOLUTION OF GRAM PANCHYAT REGARDING APPROVAL OF BUILING PLAN IS NOT SUBMITTED.
(C) THE SUPPORTING DOCUMENTS REGARDING CLU IS NOT SUBMITTED.
ACCORDINGLY, SCN ISSUED TO THE INSTITUTION ON 20.8.2009. THE INSTITUTION HAS SUBMITTED REPLY DATED 1.9.2009 ATTACHED IN THE FILE FOR NECESSARY DECISION. / The original file of the institution, Reply of the Institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee decides to issue LOI.
28 / 4 / SHYAMA PRASAD MUKHERJEE COLLEGE, ROAD NO. 57, PUNJABI BAGH, WEST, NEW DELHI -26
COURSE – B.Ed. , DH-377 / THE C.P. NCTE HQRS. HAS SENT A NOTE ENCLOSING THEREIN A COPY OF THE NEW PAPER PUBLISHED AT DELHI WHEREIN SOME REFERENCE HAS BEEN MADE ABOUT THE INSTITUTION. / The committee decides to conduct inspection under section 17 of NCTE Act 1993.
29 / 5 / SMT. SHARBATI DAVI MAHILA T.T. COLLEGE, CHAOKI, GORDHANPURA, KOTPUTLI, JAIPUT, RAJASTHAN
COURE – B.Ed. RJ-1452 / Hon’ble High Court of Judicature for Rajasthan at Jaipur, directed the NCTE to process the case as per law. / The original file of the institution, Reply of the Institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee decides to issue letter under clause 7(11) of regulation 2007. The case may be referred to HQs regarding the academic session from which the recognition is to be granted.
30 / 6 / Smt. Chander Patti Tayal Education Society, 719-L, Model Town, Panipat, Haryana.
B.Ed. HR-1519 / S.B. Civil Writ Petition No.13104/2009 received from Hon’bls High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh / The Institution did not reply to the NRC, NCTE letter dated 7 July 2008 till date. Hence, the committee decides to close the file.
31 / 7 / Shri Radha Raman Educational Society, 509-L, Model Town, Panipat-132103, Haryana.
B.Ed. HR-1509 / S.B. Civil Writ Petition No.13150/2009 received from Hon’ble High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh / The Institution did not reply to the NRC, NCTE letter dated 7 July 2008 till date. Hence, the committee decides to close the file.

AGENDA ITEM NO: 149.04.00 CONSIDERATION OF THE REPLIES RECEIVED FOR CONVERSION FROM 7(9) TO 7(11)