Notice of Recount for the
Office of President of the United States
for Ashland County in the November 8, 2016 Election
9:00 a.m. on Thursday, December 1, 2016
Ashland County Courthouse
Ashland County Board Room
Room 204
Meeting was called to order at 9:00 am, Thursday, December 1, 2016.
Oath of Office was given to the new Board of Canvassers, Angela Kerfoot and Cindy Pritzl.
Due to the short timeline and organization of Election Recount Workers, motion by Angela Kerfoot
to recess until Monday, December 5, 2016. Second by Cindy Pritzl. Motion carried.
Recess at 9:05 a.m. until Monday, December 5, 2016 at 8:00 a.m.
Original Ashland County Results:
Trump/Pence / 3302 / Fox/Kushner / 0Clinton/Kaine / 4228 / McMullin/Johnson / 10
Castle/Bradley / 21 / Maturen/Munoz / 0
Johnston/Weld / 192 / Schoenke/Creighton / 0
Stein/Baraka / 167 / Keinston/Taylor / 0
Moorhead/Lilly / 10 / Kotlikoff/Leamer / 0
De La Fuente/Steinberg / 4 / Hoefling/Schulin / 2
Maldonado / 0
Soltysik/Walker / 0
Recount of the November 8, 2016 - Presidential General Election
Ashland County Courthouse
County Board Room 204
Meeting was called to order at 8:00 a.m. on December 5, 2016 by Heather Schutte, County Clerk for the purpose of recounting ballots (hand count only) from the November 8, 2016 Presidential General Election; office of the President of the United States.
Public notice was given to all municipalities and the Ashland Daily Press on November 30, 2016 and December 1, 2016 (reconvene).
Canvass Board Members:Heather W. Schutte, Angela Kerfoot, Cindy Pritzl
Other Personnel:Karen Polencheck, Mary Lou Kraft, Rose Evenson, Michael Gould, Jean Hahn-Thomas, Pam Ollanketo, KoleneArvidson, Jenny Smart, Cindy Eder, Sharon Huybrecht, Sandy Storck, Ruth Redinger and Barb Tody
Others Present: Kris DPW, Linda Calhan, Shane Dewitt, Kim Westman, Jan Anderson and Kirsten Scheid (sp)
Original County results as follows:
Trump/Pence / 3302 / Fox/Kushner / 0Clinton/Kaine / 4228 / McMullin/Johnson / 10
Castle/Bradley / 21 / Maturen/Munoz / 0
Johnston/Weld / 192 / Schoenke/Creighton / 0
Stein/Baraka / 167 / Keinston/Taylor / 0
Moorhead/Lilly / 10 / Kotlikoff/Leamer / 0
De La Fuente/Steinberg / 4 / Hoefling/Schulin / 2
Maldonado / 0
Soltysik/Walker / 0
Heather Schutte gave detailed instructions and procedures of the recount in accordance to the Recount Manual provided by the Wisconsin Elections Commission and Oath of Office.
Town of Gordon:
At poll voters:141
Absentee voters:10
Trump/Pence / 94 / Fox/Kushner / 0Clinton/Kaine / 49 / McMullin/Johnson / 0
Castle/Bradley / 0 / Maturen/Munoz / 0
Johnston/Weld / 5 / Schoenke/Creighton / 0
Stein/Baraka / 0 / Keinston/Taylor / 0
Moorhead/Lilly / 0 / Kotlikoff/Leamer / 0
De La Fuente/Steinberg / 0 / Hoefling/Schulin / 1
Maldonado / 0
Scattering / 1 / Soltysik/Walker / 0
Town of Peeksville:
At poll voters:89
Absentee voters:6
Trump/Pence / 52 / Fox/Kushner / 0Clinton/Kaine / 33 / McMullin/Johnson / 1
Castle/Bradley / 1 / Maturen/Munoz / 0
Johnston/Weld / 4 / Schoenke/Creighton / 0
Stein/Baraka / 3 / Keinston/Taylor / 0
Moorhead/Lilly / 0 / Kotlikoff/Leamer / 0
De La Fuente/Steinberg / 0 / Hoefling/Schulin / 0
Maldonado / 0
Scattering / 1 / Soltysik/Walker / 0
Town of Shanagolden:
At poll voters:55
Absentee voters:12
Trump/Pence / 32 / Fox/Kushner / 0Clinton/Kaine / 28 / McMullin/Johnson / 0
Castle/Bradley / 0 / Maturen/Munoz / 0
Johnston/Weld / 2 / Schoenke/Creighton / 0
Stein/Baraka / 1 / Keinston/Taylor / 0
Moorhead/Lilly / 0 / Kotlikoff/Leamer / 0
De La Fuente/Steinberg / 0 / Hoefling/Schulin / 0
Maldonado / 0
Scattering / 1 / Soltysik/Walker / 0
Village of Butternut:
At poll voters:161
Absentee voters:18
Trump/Pence / 84 / Fox/Kushner / 0Clinton/Kaine / 86 / McMullin/Johnson / 0
Castle/Bradley / 0 / Maturen/Munoz / 0
Johnston/Weld / 4 / Schoenke/Creighton / 0
Stein/Baraka / 1 / Keinston/Taylor / 0
Moorhead/Lilly / 0 / Kotlikoff/Leamer / 0
De La Fuente/Steinberg / 0 / Hoefling/Schulin / 0
Maldonado / 0
Scattering / 2 / Soltysik/Walker / 0
City of Ashland – Ward 1:
At poll voters:395
Absentee voters:86
Trump/Pence / 238 / Fox/Kushner / 0Clinton/Kaine / 213 / McMullin/Johnson / 0
Castle/Bradley / 1 / Maturen/Munoz / 0
Johnston/Weld / 12 / Schoenke/Creighton / 0
Stein/Baraka / 5 / Keinston/Taylor / 0
Moorhead/Lilly / 0 / Kotlikoff/Leamer / 0
De La Fuente/Steinberg / 0 / Hoefling/Schulin / 0
Maldonado / 0
Scattering / 7 / Soltysik/Walker / 0
City of Ashland – Ward 2:
At poll voters:213
Absentee voters:59
Trump/Pence / 90 / Fox/Kushner / 0Clinton/Kaine / 159 / McMullin/Johnson / 0
Castle/Bradley / 0 / Maturen/Munoz / 0
Johnston/Weld / 11 / Schoenke/Creighton / 0
Stein/Baraka / 2 / Keinston/Taylor / 0
Moorhead/Lilly / 3 / Kotlikoff/Leamer / 0
De La Fuente/Steinberg / 0 / Hoefling/Schulin / 0
Maldonado / 0
Scattering / 5 / Soltysik/Walker / 0
City of Ashland – Ward 3:
At poll voters:240
Absentee voters:83
Trump/Pence / 107 / Fox/Kushner / 0Clinton/Kaine / 201 / McMullin/Johnson / 0
Castle/Bradley / 0 / Maturen/Munoz / 0
Johnston/Weld / 7 / Schoenke/Creighton / 0
Stein/Baraka / 3 / Keinston/Taylor / 0
Moorhead/Lilly / 0 / Kotlikoff/Leamer / 0
De La Fuente/Steinberg / 0 / Hoefling/Schulin / 0
Maldonado / 0
Scattering / 1 / Soltysik/Walker / 0
City of Ashland – Ward 4:
At poll voters:362
Absentee voters:90
Trump/Pence / 164 / Fox/Kushner / 0Clinton/Kaine / 258 / McMullin/Johnson / 3
Castle/Bradley / 1 / Maturen/Munoz / 0
Johnston/Weld / 17 / Schoenke/Creighton / 0
Stein/Baraka / 5 / Keinston/Taylor / 0
Moorhead/Lilly / 0 / Kotlikoff/Leamer / 0
De La Fuente/Steinberg / 0 / Hoefling/Schulin / 0
Maldonado / 0
Scattering / 3 / Soltysik/Walker / 0
Meeting recessed at 12:15 p.m. for lunch.
Meeting reconvene at 1:15 p.m.
City of Ashland – Ward 5:
At poll voters:304
Absentee voters:94
Trump/Pence / 100 / Fox/Kushner / 0Clinton/Kaine / 271 / McMullin/Johnson / 0
Castle/Bradley / 2 / Maturen/Munoz / 0
Johnston/Weld / 10 / Schoenke/Creighton / 0
Stein/Baraka / 3 / Keinston/Taylor / 0
Moorhead/Lilly / 0 / Kotlikoff/Leamer / 0
De La Fuente/Steinberg / 0 / Hoefling/Schulin / 0
Maldonado / 0
Scattering / 10 / Soltysik/Walker / 0
City of Ashland – Ward 6:
At poll voters:246
Absentee voters:65
Trump/Pence / 94 / Fox/Kushner / 0Clinton/Kaine / 193 / McMullin/Johnson / 1
Castle/Bradley / 0 / Maturen/Munoz / 0
Johnston/Weld / 5 / Schoenke/Creighton / 0
Stein/Baraka / 10 / Keinston/Taylor / 0
Moorhead/Lilly / 1 / Kotlikoff/Leamer / 0
De La Fuente/Steinberg / 0 / Hoefling/Schulin / 0
Maldonado / 0
Scattering / 3 / Soltysik/Walker / 1
City of Ashland – Ward 7:
At poll voters:415
Absentee voters:61
Trump/Pence / 115 / Fox/Kushner / 0Clinton/Kaine / 303 / McMullin/Johnson / 0
Castle/Bradley / 0 / Maturen/Munoz / 0
Johnston/Weld / 15 / Schoenke/Creighton / 0
Stein/Baraka / 32 / Keinston/Taylor / 0
Moorhead/Lilly / 1 / Kotlikoff/Leamer / 0
De La Fuente/Steinberg / 0 / Hoefling/Schulin / 0
Maldonado / 0
Scattering / 10 / Soltysik/Walker / 0
City of Ashland – Ward 8:
At poll voters:263
Absentee voters:55
Trump/Pence / 105 / Fox/Kushner / 0Clinton/Kaine / 185 / McMullin/Johnson / 0
Castle/Bradley / 1 / Maturen/Munoz / 0
Johnston/Weld / 15 / Schoenke/Creighton / 0
Stein/Baraka / 7 / Keinston/Taylor / 0
Moorhead/Lilly / 0 / Kotlikoff/Leamer / 0
De La Fuente/Steinberg / 0 / Hoefling/Schulin / 0
Maldonado / 0
Scattering / 4 / Soltysik/Walker / 0
City of Ashland – Ward 9:
At poll voters:238
Absentee voters:50
Trump/Pence / 88 / Fox/Kushner / 0Clinton/Kaine / 175 / McMullin/Johnson / 0
Castle/Bradley / 3 / Maturen/Munoz / 0
Johnston/Weld / 6 / Schoenke/Creighton / 0
Stein/Baraka / 11 / Keinston/Taylor / 0
Moorhead/Lilly / 1 / Kotlikoff/Leamer / 0
De La Fuente/Steinberg / 0 / Hoefling/Schulin / 0
Maldonado / 0
Scattering / 3 / Soltysik/Walker / 0
City of Ashland – Ward 10:
At poll voters:296
Absentee voters:51
Trump/Pence / 136 / Fox/Kushner / 0Clinton/Kaine / 191 / McMullin/Johnson / 0
Castle/Bradley / 0 / Maturen/Munoz / 0
Johnston/Weld / 7 / Schoenke/Creighton / 0
Stein/Baraka / 7 / Keinston/Taylor / 0
Moorhead/Lilly / 0 / Kotlikoff/Leamer / 0
De La Fuente/Steinberg / 0 / Hoefling/Schulin / 0
Maldonado / 0
Scattering / 2 / Soltysik/Walker / 0
City of Ashland – Ward 11:
At poll voters:316
Absentee voters:68
Trump/Pence / 151 / Fox/Kushner / 0Clinton/Kaine / 199 / McMullin/Johnson / 0
Castle/Bradley / 0 / Maturen/Munoz / 0
Johnston/Weld / 11 / Schoenke/Creighton / 0
Stein/Baraka / 10 / Keinston/Taylor / 0
Moorhead/Lilly / 1 / Kotlikoff/Leamer / 0
De La Fuente/Steinberg / 0 / Hoefling/Schulin / 0
Maldonado / 0
Scattering / 10 / Soltysik/Walker / 0
Meeting recessed at 4:45 p.m.
Meeting reconvene at 8:00 a.m. Tuesday, December 6, 2016.
Canvass Board Members:Heather W. Schutte, Angela Kerfoot, Cindy Pritzl
Other Personnel:Karen Polencheck, Mary Lou Kraft, Michael Gould, Jean Hahn-Thomas, Pam Ollanketo, KoleneArvidson, Jenny Smart, Cindy Eder, Sharon Huybrecht, Sandy Storck, Ruth Redinger and Barb Tody
Others Present: Xris Ramirez, Sue Sederholm, Shane Dewitt, Michelle Lampson and Denise Ciebien
Town of Agenda:
At poll voters:216
Absentee voters:14
Trump/Pence / 151 / Fox/Kushner / 0Clinton/Kaine / 68 / McMullin/Johnson / 0
Castle/Bradley / 1 / Maturen/Munoz / 0
Johnston/Weld / 6 / Schoenke/Creighton / 0
Stein/Baraka / 0 / Keinston/Taylor / 0
Moorhead/Lilly / 0 / Kotlikoff/Leamer / 0
De La Fuente/Steinberg / 0 / Hoefling/Schulin / 0
Maldonado / 0
Scattering / 1 / Soltysik/Walker / 0
Town of Ashland:
At poll voters:288
Absentee voters:28
Trump/Pence / 147 / Fox/Kushner / 0Clinton/Kaine / 144 / McMullin/Johnson / 0
Castle/Bradley / 1 / Maturen/Munoz / 0
Johnston/Weld / 8 / Schoenke/Creighton / 0
Stein/Baraka / 7 / Keinston/Taylor / 0
Moorhead/Lilly / 1 / Kotlikoff/Leamer / 0
De La Fuente/Steinberg / 0 / Hoefling/Schulin / 0
Maldonado / 0
Scattering / 3 / Soltysik/Walker / 0
Town of Chippewa:
At poll voters:200
Absentee voters:14
Trump/Pence / 128 / Fox/Kushner / 0Clinton/Kaine / 72 / McMullin/Johnson / 0
Castle/Bradley / 1 / Maturen/Munoz / 0
Johnston/Weld / 4 / Schoenke/Creighton / 0
Stein/Baraka / 1 / Keinston/Taylor / 0
Moorhead/Lilly / 0 / Kotlikoff/Leamer / 0
De La Fuente/Steinberg / 1 / Hoefling/Schulin / 0
Maldonado / 0
Scattering / 2 / Soltysik/Walker / 0
Town of Gingles:
At poll voters:404
Absentee voters:29
Trump/Pence / 198 / Fox/Kushner / 0Clinton/Kaine / 211 / McMullin/Johnson / 0
Castle/Bradley / 3 / Maturen/Munoz / 0
Johnston/Weld / 5 / Schoenke/Creighton / 0
Stein/Baraka / 9 / Keinston/Taylor / 0
Moorhead/Lilly / 0 / Kotlikoff/Leamer / 0
De La Fuente/Steinberg / 0 / Hoefling/Schulin / 0
Maldonado / 0
Scattering / 4 / Soltysik/Walker / 0
Town of Jacobs:
At poll voters:325
Absentee voters:15
Trump/Pence / 204 / Fox/Kushner / 0Clinton/Kaine / 120 / McMullin/Johnson / 2
Castle/Bradley / 0 / Maturen/Munoz / 0
Johnston/Weld / 6 / Schoenke/Creighton / 0
Stein/Baraka / 1 / Keinston/Taylor / 0
Moorhead/Lilly / 0 / Kotlikoff/Leamer / 0
De La Fuente/Steinberg / 0 / Hoefling/Schulin / 0
Maldonado / 0
Scattering / 1 / Soltysik/Walker / 0
Town of La Pointe:
At poll voters:180
Absentee voters:67
Trump/Pence / 53 / Fox/Kushner / 0Clinton/Kaine / 159 / McMullin/Johnson / 0
Castle/Bradley / 0 / Maturen/Munoz / 0
Johnston/Weld / 8 / Schoenke/Creighton / 0
Stein/Baraka / 17 / Keinston/Taylor / 0
Moorhead/Lilly / 0 / Kotlikoff/Leamer / 0
De La Fuente/Steinberg / 1 / Hoefling/Schulin / 0
Maldonado / 0
Scattering / 4 / Soltysik/Walker / 0
Town of Marengo:
At poll voters:199
Absentee voters:13
Trump/Pence / 101 / Fox/Kushner / 0Clinton/Kaine / 92 / McMullin/Johnson / 3
Castle/Bradley / 0 / Maturen/Munoz / 0
Johnston/Weld / 8 / Schoenke/Creighton / 0
Stein/Baraka / 5 / Keinston/Taylor / 0
Moorhead/Lilly / 0 / Kotlikoff/Leamer / 0
De La Fuente/Steinberg / 1 / Hoefling/Schulin / 0
Maldonado / 0
Scattering / 2 / Soltysik/Walker / 0
Town of Morse:
At poll voters:269
Absentee voters:34
Trump/Pence / 138 / Fox/Kushner / 0Clinton/Kaine / 150 / McMullin/Johnson / 0
Castle/Bradley / 0 / Maturen/Munoz / 0
Johnston/Weld / 2 / Schoenke/Creighton / 0
Stein/Baraka / 1 / Keinston/Taylor / 0
Moorhead/Lilly / 1 / Kotlikoff/Leamer / 0
De La Fuente/Steinberg / 0 / Hoefling/Schulin / 0
Maldonado / 0
Scattering / 5 / Soltysik/Walker / 0
Town of Sanborn:
At poll voters:489
Absentee voters:13
Trump/Pence / 72 / Fox/Kushner / 0Clinton/Kaine / 398 / McMullin/Johnson / 0
Castle/Bradley / 2 / Maturen/Munoz / 0
Johnston/Weld / 6 / Schoenke/Creighton / 0
Stein/Baraka / 11 / Keinston/Taylor / 0
Moorhead/Lilly / 1 / Kotlikoff/Leamer / 0
De La Fuente/Steinberg / 0 / Hoefling/Schulin / 0
Maldonado / 0
Scattering / 8 / Soltysik/Walker / 0
Town of White River:
At poll voters:447
Absentee voters:21
Trump/Pence / 309 / Fox/Kushner / 0Clinton/Kaine / 128 / McMullin/Johnson / 1
Castle/Bradley / 4 / Maturen/Munoz / 0
Johnston/Weld / 6 / Schoenke/Creighton / 0
Stein/Baraka / 14 / Keinston/Taylor / 0
Moorhead/Lilly / 0 / Kotlikoff/Leamer / 0
De La Fuente/Steinberg / 0 / Hoefling/Schulin / 0
Maldonado / 0
Scattering / 2 / Soltysik/Walker / 0
City of Mellen:
At poll voters:279
Absentee voters:23
Trump/Pence / 152 / Fox/Kushner / 0Clinton/Kaine / 140 / McMullin/Johnson / 0
Castle/Bradley / 0 / Maturen/Munoz / 0
Johnston/Weld / 4 / Schoenke/Creighton / 0
Stein/Baraka / 1 / Keinston/Taylor / 0
Moorhead/Lilly / 0 / Kotlikoff/Leamer / 0
De La Fuente/Steinberg / 0 / Hoefling/Schulin / 0
Maldonado / 0
Scattering / 0 / Soltysik/Walker / 0
Recount Ashland County Results:
Total votes cast: 8,032
Donald J. Trump/Michael R. Pence / received / 3,303Hillary Clinton/Tim Kaine / received / 4,226
Darrell L. Castle/Scott N. Bradley / received / 21
Gary Johnson/Bill Weld / received / 194
Jill Stein/Ajamu Baraka / received / 167
Monica Moorehead/Lamont Lilly / received / 10
Rocky Roque De La Fuente/Michael Steinberg / received / 3
Cherunda Fox/Roger Kushner (write-in) / received / 0
Evan McMullin/Nathan Johnson (write-in) / received / 11
Michael A. Maturen/Juan Munoz (write-in) / received / 0
Marshall Schoenke/James Creighton Mitchell Jr. (write-in) / received / 0
Chris Keniston/Deacon Taylor (write-in) / received / 0
Laurence Kotlikoff/Edward E. Leamer (write-in) / received / 0
Tom Hoefling/Steve Schulin (write-in) / received / 1
Joseph Maldonado (write-in) / received / 0
EmidioSoltysik/Angela Nicole Walker (write-in) / received / 1
SCATTERING / received / 95
Adjourn at 11:00 a.m. Tuesday, December 6, 2016.
Submitted by,
Heather W. Schutte, Ashland County Clerk
Karen Polencheck, Secretary/Deputy County Clerk