California State University Fullerton Affirmative Caselist

CALIFORNIA STATE UNIVERSITY FULLERTON AFFIRMATIVE CASELIST

Bakersfield GW Error! Bookmark not defined.

Berkeley HS 2

Berkeley KM 2

CEU SW 2

Cal Poly Slo GW 2

Catholic CP 2

Catholic SJ 2

Catholic SW 3

Chico BR 3

Chico JJ 3

Claremont BW 3

Dartmouth LT 3

Fort Hays MS 3

Fort Hays RR 3

George Mason BW 3

George Mason HH 4

Harvard CM 4

Harvard KT 4

Harvard/Georgetown CG 4

Lewis & Clark MZ 4

Lewis & Clark PS 5

Long Beach HW 5

Long Beach RS 5

Miami of Ohio BH 5

Miami of Ohio ST 5

Michigan FO 5

Michigan MV 5

Michigan State CM 6

Michigan State SS 6

Northwestern FG 6

Oregon BF 6

Oregon CK 6

Pace BW 6

Pepperdine FO 7

Redlands AB 7

Redlands ST 7

San Francisco State RS 7

Seattle SS 7

Southern Utah DT 8

Texas BL 8

Texas BM 8

Texas DP 8

Texas MY 8

Trinity DD 8

USC BS 8

USC FW 9

USC GV 9

USC HT 9

USC MS 9

Wake Forest DP 9

Wake Forest EK 9

Wake Forest ES 9

West Georgia EH 10

West Georgia ET 10

Whitman BO 10

Whitman BT 11

Whitman CS 11

Whitman DM 11

Whitman GW 11

Whitman RW 11

SAME AS SECONDARY SOURCES CASELIST

CLOSE APPROXIMATION! U.S. Congress pass legislation to create an Indian Copyright Act that allows for collective indigenous works of Native peoples. Disputes arising over application of the term “collective indigenous works” will be decided by Tribal Courts according to Tribal laws and customs.

Observation One:

-  status quo copyright act contrary to N.A. Tribal ethos Jordan 2001

Observation Two:

-  stereotyping/representations kill culture risk survival Riley 2000, Dougherty 1998

Observation Three:

-  plan solves and fulfills trust doctrine Riley 2000

Berkeley HS

Affirmative against Chico JJ

SAME AS ON THE SECONDARY SOURCES CASELIST.

The USFG will prohibit uranium mining throughout Indian Country.

Berkeley KM

SAME AS ON THE SECONDARY SOURCES CASELIST.

The USFG will prohibit uranium mining throughout Indian Country.

CEU SW

Given the harms outlined, the USFG should mandate and ratify negotiated compacts between state and tribes for the taxation of Non-Indians to Indian Country, specifying the primacy of non-litigative dispute resolution as specified by the tribes. Funding and enforcement guaranteed consistent in the intent of the plan. We get to clarify.

Cal Poly Slo GW

The US Supreme Court will overturn the Employment division vs Smith decision in favor of the constitutionally protected right of the religious use of peyote. Affirmative speaking serves as intent. We reserve the right to clarify.

Catholic CP

THE United States National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration and the US commissioner to the International Whaling Commission should directly endorse and support Native Americans to the IWC for aboriginal subsistence Whaling and exemptions when the petition, must IWC standards or are compelled by previously signed treaties support for petition includes the development of appropriate whaling schedules with native Americans that qualify for an exemption.

Catholic SJ

WHALING (Same as catholic cp)

-Mekeh right to whale Gonzonaga law review ’01

-allow to whale no ASW LAT ‘2000

-ASW collapse into bad Bradford ’01

-Treaties = space for resistance Alan ‘2001

-Support indian identity Dirlik ’99

-Struggles = survival Dirlik ‘99

-Recover rights San juan ‘2001

Solve

-ASW would protect whale extinction journal of env. Law ‘2000

-Extinction = survival Honnald ’95

-International rights solve Bradford ‘2000

-US indigenous rights make credible international law Baloga ’99

AFFERMATIVE AGAISNT SO. UTAH DT

ANWAR D/A- -No link; No Specific story; No link NOAA; C/P links more; No time frame; Case outweighs;

WENT FOR—RVI mixing Burdens; Morphing violation. And a discourse of the oppressed underview

Catholic SW

Though then available means, the USFG should support the offer to substantially increase federal control throughout “Indian country” in the areas of taxation and resource management by issuing federal tax credits to non-Indian entities doing business in Indian country. The tax credits should be equivalent to any state or local taxes levied as per William and Taradash. The federal government will never waive, susspend or reduce royality to tribes for fossil fuels development. Funding and enforcement guaranteed, we will clarify intent.

Chico BR

-No plan-whole resolution, wx refund cultural artifacts or intrust

-Pomo hit leads to uncover simulations of historical representations and expose the foundational theories of social science and vernacular radicalism ( Gerald Visnor, American Indian Quarterly, Winter 1993, vol 17 Issue 1. Pg.7)

-Narrative of almost Browne-Vicenor 1991- Landfill Mediations

2AR- They don’t explain anything- vote Aff to deconstruct identity roles

Chico JJ

The USFG should substantially increase Federal control throughout Indian Country in the area of environmental protection and resource management, by an executive mandate to shield Indian Country from environment threats and protect native rights against adverse agency action as per the recommendations of Wood. Funding and enforcement guaranteed. We’ll clarify.

Claremont BW

Plan: Reform the ICWA to increase anglo adoptions of indian children

Case: Indian schools are bad. Indian parents are uneducated. We need to increase white adoptions of indians to save native peoples.

Underview: Ironic presentations are best way to address colonization of native peoples. Irony is transformative tool that deconstructs oppression and hegemony. Native Americans support use of irony to deconstruct the fed. And to tell their story.

Cites: John Seery, Political returns, 1991

Jean camaroff .92

Linda Hutcheon, Irony’s Edge, 1995

Gulriz Buken, Journal of Am. Studies in turkey, 1998 p. 43-49

Herbert Marcuse, One dimensional man, 1964.

Dartmouth LT

The USFG should remove the good cause language of the section 1911(b) of the Indian Child Welfare Act.

-  USFG took Indian children from their homes Bilchik 2001

-  the G.C.C. is paternalistic Jones 1997

-  the ICWA recognizes presumptive jurisdiction for tribal courts Connoley 1993

-  objectification of G.C.C. denied Native American subjectivity Carriere 1994

-  denies value to life – justifies extermination Dillon 1999

-  intersubjectivity Zizek 1998, Carreier 1994, Ruffin 1999

AFFERMATIVE AGAINST REDLANDS AB

-K’s of the DA’s: speaking for others, calculability, moral geography.

-Went for the K’s in 2AR

Fort Hays MS

Fort Hays RR

George Mason BW

The department of interior of land management, through all necessary means will reinterpret all existing regulations regarding gold mining t/o Indian country. The BLM will functionally determine the gold mining t/o Indians country causes unnecessary and undue degradation to the land and require the “most appropriate technology and practices” be taken to return the lands and waters to produce the use. Any further determinations of gold mining operations will be based on plans original determination. Funding and enforcement are guaranteed.

George Mason HH

As per casebook

The department of interior of land management, through all necessary means will reinterpret all existing regulations regarding gold mining t/o Indian country. The BLM will functionally determine the gold mining t/o Indians country causes unnecessary and undue degradation to the land and require the “most appropriate technology and practices” be taken to return the lands and waters to produce the use. Any further determinations of gold mining operations will be based on plans original determination. Funding and enforcement are guaranteed.

Harvard CM

The United States Department of Justice should substantially increase prosecution of sexual assaults committed against residents of Indian Country by non-residents. The Department of Justice should appoint and train special assistant United States Attorneys from the ranks of local prosecutors and supercede PL 280 jurisdiction of the states.

Advantage One: rape and violence

Advantage Two: colonialism

Harvard KT

Harvard/Georgetown CG

SAME AS ON THE SECONDARY SOURCES CASELIST

The plan gives Kennewick Man and other ancient remains to scientists for study, it prevents reburial in Indian Country.

Observation One: Kennewick Man will be given back

Advantage One: Archaeology

-  all remains will be repatriated

-  restrictions are killing archaeology Kimtign 1998 and Meighan

-  arch. Key to humyn adaptation

-  arch. Allows inclusion of Native American perspectives

-  science is self-correcting Clark 1996

Advantage Two: Church and State

-  decision to return KM is a violation of church and states

-  this will spill over to other areas

-  separation key to solve religious wars

-  key to solve anti-semitism Sherry 1996

-  must reject anti-semitism

-  church and state key to stop reactionary narratives Sherry 1996

-  causes a renewed holocaust

-  holocaust would occur Maddox 1996

Observation Two: Solvency

-  separation between church and state collapsing

-  we uphold separation

Underview:

-  Remains 9000 years old are not affiliated causes stereotyping of native americans

AFFIRMATIVE VERSUS MIAMI OF OHIO:

MORAL NIHILISM (COLESON, 1997, LAW AND MEDICINE III; HANGAR, 1995, HEALTH MATRIX)

Lewis & Clark MZ

The United States Congress should amend the Indian Child Welfare Act to end the use of “existing family doctrine” and “good cause” exceptions as per Ruffin and Metteer. Full funding and enforcement of the ICWA guaranteed; we’ll clarify intent.

Observation One: Inherency

-  courts us EIFD to take kids out of cultural contexts Ruffin 1999

-  state courts abuse good cause Carriere 1994

Observation Two: The Advantages

-  6500 kids/year Cross 2000

-  suicide rate 4 times normal for removed kids Graham 1998

-  removal is racist Philips 1997

-  reject racism Gordon and Gordon

-  removal is genocidal Churchill 1994

-  removal is cultural genocide Ruffin 1999

-  we must each reject racism Churchill 1994

Observation Three: Solvency

-  strengthening the ICWA will prevent state court removal of children Prim 2000

-  amending is key to solve Meteer 1998

-  enforcement deconstructs white supremacy Ruffin 1999

-  use of terms is transformative Ruffin 1999

-  1AC presents a cultural narrative Ruffin 1999

-  politics of joy is transformative Ruffin 1999

-  must reject strict textual understanding of the law Ruffin 1999

-  discussion of ICWA creates real change Ruffin 1999

-  remedial legislation solves Ruffin 1999

AFFIRMATIVE VERSUS WHITMAN DM

POLITICS OF JOY (RUFFIN 1999)

GEOPOLITICS CRITIQUE

-  TUATHAIL AND AGNEW, POLITICAL GEOGRAPHY, 1992, P. 195

-  DALBY, CREATING THE SECOND COLD WAR, 1990, P. 15

Lewis & Clark PS

SEE LEWIS & CLARK MZ

Long Beach HW

ENFORCE AFFIRMATIVE TRUST DUTY TO STOP ENCROACHMENT (WOOD 1994 AND WOOD 1995)

Observation One: corporate development causes extinction

Observation Two: solvency

-  Guidance documents increase knowledge

-  Plan creates preservation of sovereignty

2AC AND 1AR FOCUS ON THEIR UNDERVIEW – INCLUSIVITY IN DEBATE IS GOOD, SPEED AND TECHNOLOGY BAD

Affirmative Strategy: argues running topicality to gain critique links is illigitamate.

Long Beach RS

Miami of Ohio BH

Overturn Oliphant (on Secondary Sources Caselist)

Uranium Mining – use best available technology

AFFERMATIVE AGAINST WEST GORGIA ET (Uranium mining)

Control T- Bielski 2000

2AC claims multiple performative contradictions, primarily that narratives with a plan is a more cohesive critical structure than K’s without a social alternative.

Miami of Ohio ST

Overturn Oliphant (on Secondary Sources Caselist)

Uranium Mining – use best available technology

Michigan FO

Michigan MV

Michigan State CM

Wake Case List

Observation 1

-Testing now (3 cards)

-Testing in Indian country

Observation 2

-Genocide.. nuclear testing is genocidal and outweighs all

Observation 3

-We build alliance to challenge the nuclear state.

AFFERMATIVE AGAISNT CALTHLIC SJ

-Went for “WE ARE T”

Michigan State SS

AFFERMATIVE VERSUS USC HT

C/P- Informed consent = genocide, research groups not tell N.A. they are stealing genes, trick natives into saying yes

Breast Cancer add-on- patents subvert public health to commercial goals council for responsible genetics ’98 www.ukabe.org/udpaten2.html ……Then breast cancer kills

Affirmative went for conditionally bad claims dispo is ok to check neg offense on dispo—breast cancer add-on

*do both perm may not be competitive.

Northwestern FG

The USFG should prohibit the mining, milling, and waste citing of nuclear materials throughout Indian Country

Contention One:

-  nuclear development increasing Abraham

-  narrative about nuclear development Gloria Bird

-  zone of sacrifice Kuletz

-  new movements are calling on us to join them WPI

Contention Two:

-  our plan is a metaphoric condemnation against colonization Zizek

-  nuclear zones exposes oppression Kuletz

-  witnessing voices solves Bind

Oregon BF

Plan:

The US DOJ will direct all US attorneys whose territories include any part of IC to establish a policy of full and fair prosecution of the crimes of sexual assault and other violence against women in IC when the victim of such violence is from IC and the perpetrator is not. The DOJ will make available to all governments and other entities conducting law enforcement functions training programs for prosecutors and other officials enabling them to effectively represent community interests in prosecutions in IC. At the request of either local IC governments of the victims local prosecutions shall be depiction of crimes mentioned above, funding and enforcement guaranteed. We reserve the right to clarify intent.

-No changes; DOJ distributes Indian prosecutors

-Plan decreases colonialism

-Impact turn

-No solvency for counterplan

-Case outweighs

Oregon CK

Pace BW

WHALING (disclosure sheet says no change)

Affirmative said everything was anthropocentric

Affirmative tried to double turn politics

Pepperdine FO

The US Supreme Court will over turn the employment division vs. Smith decision in favor of the constitutionally protected right of the religious use of peyote.

-Inh. Smith 1990

-House report 1994

-Adv1 Colonialism

-Adv2 Religious Discrimination

-General claims:

-  Suicide

-  Genocide

-  Politics of Joy

Redlands AB

Affirmative 1: Thus we present the following plan. In order to substantially increase Federal Control over Indian Country in the area of taxation, the federal government should establish that the telecommunications act pre-empt state taxation telecommunications in Indian Country.

Affiramtive 2: Thus we present the following plan. In order to substantially increase Federal Control in areas of criminal justice and gaming the federal government should amend PL280 removing jurisdiction from the state to enhance section 27l0 in the GRA in order to ensure that a fixed percentage of revenue be earmarked for tribal justice systems.