Minutes of the 65th meeting of the Committee Constituted for Deciding the Consent under Orange Category, held on 27.06.2008 in the Conference Room of Chairman, DPCC.

The following persons attended the meeting:

1.  Sh. J. K Dadoo, Chairman DPCC.

2.  Sh. K. Mahesh, Member Secretary, DPCC.

3.  Sh. S.K.Gupta, Head Chemical Engineering Deptt. ,IIT Delhi

4.  Sh. M. Dwarakanath, SSO, Deptt. of Env., GNCTD

5.  EEs CMC – I, & III.

6.  AEEs and JEE of CMC – I, II & III.

Sh. B. Kumar, SEE, DPCC & Sh. B.M.S. Reddy, EE, CMC-II, DPCC could not attend the meeting as they were on earned leave.

Following decisions were taken in the said meeting:-

Agenda Item No.1 :- Personal hearing of P.P. Buildwell, Construction of Conventional Center , District Center, Janak Puri, Delhi

Personal hearing in this case deferred for 11.07.2008 at 8.15 PM, due to want of time.

Agenda Item No.2- Construction Project cases

Decisions taken with respect to this agenda are tabulated and annexed as Annexure – 1.

Agenda Item No.3- Complaint cases of Friends Colony Ind Area

Decisions taken with respect to this agenda are tabulated and annexed as Annexure – 2.

Agenda Item No.4- Cases of renewal of Okhla Industrial Areas

This agenda could not be taken up due to paucity of time and it was decided by the Committee to take up the same in the next CMC meeting to be held on 11.07.2008.

Agenda Item No.5: Cases of Naraina Industrial Area, Phase-I

This agenda could not be taken up due to paucity of time and it was decided by the Committee to take up the same in the next CMC meeting to be held on 11.07.2008.

Agenda Item No. 6- Cases of SMA, SSI and RUN Indl Areas

This agenda could not be taken up due to paucity of time and it was decided by the Committee to take up the same in the next CMC meeting to be held on 11.07.2008.

Table Agenda Item No 01 : - West End Mall, Janak puri Disrict Centre, New Delhi

The unit pleaded before MS on 26.06.2008 that it had been duped by his partners and architect and pressed for a personal hearing before the Committee. MS brought this information to the knowledge of the Committee and therefore he was allowed a personal hearing today.

In the personal hearing, the unit stated again that it was totally ignorant about the environmental conditions and clearances and was duped by his architect and partners. The unit also pleaded that it had taken a loan of Rs. 13 crores by mortgaging the mall and therefore a very lenient view may be taken. The Committee deliberated on this matter over an hour and finally decided that the unit may be allowed to comply with a cash penalty of 1 % of the project cost i.e. Rs. 50 Lakh and 3 % of the project cost i.e. Rs. 1.5 crores as Bank Guarantee by 11.07.2008 and the compliance must be filed in the CMC on 11.07.2008. If he does so, the closure orders will stand withdrawn and the Consent to Establish will be granted to the unit. Subsequently, a separate letter will be addressed to Addl. Secretary, MOEF indicating the sequence of events and the levying of final cash penalty & Bank Guarantee on the unit. The unit has agreed to the same and filed a written undertaking to this effect. Call on 11.07.2008.

Table Agenda Item No 02 : - Indian Oil Corporation Ltd., Bijwasan Hook up of Mathura – Jalandhar Pipeline with Tikrikalan

The unit has applied for Consent to Establish on 24.06.2008 vide I.D. No 26149. Ask the unit to submit the following documents by 31.07.2008:-

(i)  Affidavit indicating date of start of construction and date of completion.

(ii)  Completion certificate.

(iii)  Approved architectural drawing.

(iv)  Details of water drawl.

(v)  Permission from CGWA for ground water drawl.

(vi)  Details of waste water & its treatment.

(vii)  Details of D.G. Sets.

(viii)  Plot area.

(ix)  Built up Area.

(x)  Copy of Environmental Clearance.

Call on 31.07.2008.

Meeting ended with thanks to the Chair.

S.No / Ref. No / Name & Address / Date of EC accorded by MOEF / Status of CTE / Bult Up Area / Water / Waste Water details / Total Project Cost / Date of Commissioning / Earlier decisions / ATR/Remarks / Decision on 27.06.2008
1 / B-8 / Residential Complex near Rithala Metro Station by A.P. Real Estates / Pending with Moef / 30-08-07 / 29,889.65 Sqm / MCD 221 KLD/ 170 KLD (STP) / 93.28 Crores / 2008 / 18.02.2008
Ask the unit to file EIA clearance.
17.3.2008
MS may write to MOEF to find out the status of EIA clearance. Take up in April, 2008.
23.04.2008
Call on 21.05.2008 with response..
03.6.08
Call for personal hearing on 11.06.2008 at 7.45 PM.
11.6.2008
The unit was called for personal hearing today. He claims no construction taken place so far. The internet download of MOEF indicates that certain clarifications have been sought and Environmental Clearance is yet to be given to the unit. SIT may inspect and report on all points relating to Air, Water & Noise pollution, Green Building concept and efficient waste management practices. Unit may also be asked to file permission from CGWA for ground water drawl. Call on 25.06.2008. / Letter issued on 8.5.08 to MoEF and reply awaited.
Letter issued to the unit.
Reply awaited. / Call for personal hearing on 11.07.2008 at 8.30 PM.
2 / A-15 / BES Buildcon Pvt. Ltd., Swatantra Bharat Mills Complex, Plot No 15, Najafgarh Road, Delhi / Pending with MOE&F / 24.06.2008 / 850401 sqm / MCD - 2195 KLD / WW - 3129 KLD
(STP) / 1684.61 Crores / 2010 / 03.6.2008
The unit says that it will apply for Consent to Establish within a week and it has filed revised application for Environmental Clearance with MOEF on 28.04.2008.
Ask the unit to file Environmental Clearance & Consent to Establish expeditiously. The unit may be asked to file clarification on the extent of ground water drawl and the permission for the same. It may also be asked to file its water cess returns when it became applicable. / Notice u/s 25/26 of Water Act and u/s 21/22 of Air Act was isued on 30.04.2008 for CTE.
Reply received on 13.05.2008.
Applied for CTE on 24.06.2008 vide I.D. No. 26156 / Call on 04.07.2008 after inspection by Chairman, DPCC with Sh. M. Dwarkanath, SSO.
In view of the very large scope of the project of 20 acres and cost involvement of nearly Rs. 1700 crores.
3 / A-20 / Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd., CTO Project, ARA Centre, Jhandewalan, Delhi / Built up area 13655.7 sqm / 25-04-08 / 13655.1 Sqm / MCD-35 KLD And GW 30 KLD / 40 (STP) / 48.42crores / 31-07-07 / 03.6.08
Ask the unit to file details of waste water discharge, D.G. Set, ground water drawl and water cess payment as per Cess Act. / Applied for CTE on 25.04.2008 vide I.D. No 25584.
Built up area : 13655.71 sqm
Proposed date of commencement : 31.07.2007
D.G. Set : 2 x 1000 KVA with acoustic enclosure. / SIT to inspect and report. Call on 31.07.2008.
4 / A-22 / DLF I.T. Park, 15, Shivaji Marg, Delhi / Applied on 21.05.2008 / 13.06.2008 / 430789.322 sqm / MCD-1262 KLD
GW - Nil
WW - 2471 KLD
(STP Proposed) / 916.63 crores / Dec-10 / _ / Applied for CTE on 13.06.2008 vide I.D. No. 26056. / Call on 04.07.2008 after inspection by Chairman, DPCC with Sh. M. Dwarkanath, SSO.
In view of the very large scope of the project of 10 acres and cost involvement of nearly Rs. 1000 crores.
5 / C-40 / Construction of IT Towers (Office Cum Reatil Complex) at F-79-80, Okhla, Phase-I, New Delhi by Mohan Machines Ltd., DLF Centre, Sansad Marg, New Delhi / 23.06.2008 / 54316.89 sqm / MCD-92.2 KLD
GW - Nil
WW - 180.3 KLD
(STP Proposed) / 102.2 crores / October, 2010 / _ / Applied for CTE on 23.06.2008 vide I.D. No. 26138. / Ask the unit to submit the following documents by 31.07.2008:-
(i) Affidavit indicating date of start of construction and date of completion.
(ii) Completion certificate.
(iii) Approved architectural drawing.
(iv) Details of water drawl.
(v) Permission from CGWA for ground water drawl.
(vi) Details of waste water & its treatment.
(vii)Details of D.G. Sets including the information of the acoustic enclosure & stack height.
(viii) Copy of Environmental Clearance.
(ix) Floor wise built up area.
(x) Built up area of basement.
(xi) Built up are calculation drawing of each floor and basement.
Call on 31.07.2008.
S.No. / Ref.No. (163 List) / NAME / ADDRESS / ACTIVITY / CATEGORY / letter issued on / Latest Status / Decision on 26.06.2008
CTO / CTR / CTE
1 / 1 / A.I. ENTERPRISES / J-18, Gali No.5, Friends Colony Industrial Area, GT Road, Shahdara, Delhi - 95. / Copper Wire Drawing / Orange Category / PENDING / Not Applied / NO / 23.04.2008 / No reply received / Final reminder. Call on 07.08.2008
2 / 2 / ADISH JAIN / Plot No-8, Gali NO. 4, Friends Colony Industrial Area, GT Road, Shahdara, Delhi - 95. / Copper Wire Drawing / Orange Category / valid 24.07.06 / PENDING / NO / 23.04.2008 / Applied for CTE / Two CMC-III Trainees inspect. Call on 07.08.2008.
3 / 3 / ADITYA METAL / 458-466, Gali No.8, Friends Colony Industrial Area, GT Road, Shahdara, Delhi - 95. / Copper Wire Drawing / Orange Category / valid 05.06.06 / PENDING / NO / 23.04.2008 / No reply received / Final reminder. Call on 07.08.2008
4 / 4 / AMIT METAL / 1/536-B, B/5, Gali No. 4, Friends Colony Industrial Area, GT Road, Shahdara, Delhi - 95. / Copper wire drawing, mfg. of PVC Compound, PVC wire & cables / Orange Category / No / No / 24.05.05 / 25.04.2008 / CTO(No reply received) / Final reminder for Consent to Operate. Call on 07.08.2008
5 / 7 / ARIHANT METALS / 29B-30, Gali No.6, Friends Colony Industrial Area, GT Road, Shahdara, Delhi - 95. / Copper Wire Drawing / Orange Category / NA / valid 12.07.06, Not appied / NO / 23.04.2008 / Applied for CTE. / Two CMC-III Trainees inspect. Call on 07.08.2008.
6 / 8 / ARIHANT TRADING & METAL INDUSTRIES / 22/3, Gali No- 3, Friends Colony Industrial Area / Copper Wire Drawing / Orange Category / NA / Valid 25.07.08 / NO / 23.04.2008 / No reply received / Final reminder for Consent to Establish. Call on 07.08.2008
7 / 9 / Arihant Wires / 458-466, S.N. Compound Gali No 8, Friends Colony Industrial Area, GT Road, Shahdara, Delhi - 95. / Copper Wire Drawing / Orange Category / NA / PENDING / NO / 23.04.2008 / Applied for CTE. / Two CMC-III Trainees inspect. Call on 07.08.2008.
8 / 10 / ASHISH ENTERPRISES / 537/3, Gali no. 8, Friends Colony Industrial Area, GT Road, Shahdara, Delhi - 95. / Copper Wire Drawing / Orange Category / valid 07.10.06 / Not Applied / NO / 23.04.2008 / No reply received / Final reminder. Call on 07.08.2008
9 / 11 / ASHISH METAL / Plot No.10,(Part) Gali No.4, Friends Colony Industrial Area, GT Road, Shahdara, Delhi - 95. / Copper Wire Drawing / Orange Category / valid 25.07.05 / PENDING / NO / 23.04.08 / Letter returned back / Two CMC-III Trainees inspect carrying the copy of the letter with them. Call on 07.08.2008.
10 / 12 / ASHOK JAIN & CO. / 1/359-B, Gali No-3, Friends Colony Industrial Area / Copper Wire Drawing / Orange Category / NA / valid 17.01.09 / NO / 23.04.08 / No reply received / Final reminder. Call on 07.08.2008
11 / 13 / ASHOK METAL INDUSTRIES / Plot No. 357-A Gali No 1 Friends Colony Industrial Area, GT Road, Shahdara, Delhi - 95. / Copper Wire Drawing / Orange Category / Valid 25.07.05 / Not Applied / NO / 23.04.08 / No reply received / Final reminder. Call on 07.08.2008
12 / 14 / B. C. ENTERPRISES / 1/342/G, st. 1, Friends Colony Industrial Area / Copper Wire Drawing & mfg of PVC Wire & Cable / Orange Category / Valid 01.08.05 / Not Applied / NO / 23.04.08 / Letter returned back / Two CMC-III Trainees inspect carrying the copy of the letter with them. Call on 07.08.2008.
13 / 15 / BHAWANI INDUSTRIES / 340/1, Gali No-1, Friends Colony Industrial Area, GT Road, Shahdara, Delhi - 95. / Copper Wire Drawing / Orange Category / Valid 24.07.05 / Not Applied / NO / 23.04.08 / Letter returned back / Two CMC-III Trainees inspect carrying the copy of the letter with them. Call on 07.08.2008.
14 / 16 / BOMBAY METAL INDUSTRIES / B-19, Gali No.7, Friends Colony Industrial Area G. T. Road, Shahdara / Copper Wire Drawing / Orange Category / Valid 24.07.05 / PENDING / NO / 25.04.08 / No reply received / Final reminder. Call on 07.08.2008
15 / 17 / CALCUTTA CABLE INDUSTRIES / 32-A, Gali No-6, Friends Colony Industrial Area, GT Road, Shahdara, Delhi - 95. / Copper Wire Drawing / Orange Category / Valid 25.07.05 / Not Applied / NO / 23.04.08 / No reply received / Final reminder. Call on 07.08.2008
16 / 18 / CAPITAL METAL / 47/1,E-421, Gali no 6, Friends Colony Industrial Area, GT Road, Shahdara, Delhi - 95. / Copper Wire Drawing / Orange Category / Valid 08.11.05 / PENDING / NO / 25.04.08 / Applied for CTE. / Two CMC-III Trainees inspect. Call on 07.08.2008.
17 / 20 / CONTINENTAL ENGINNERS / 421-A, Gali No. 6, Friends Colony Industrial Area, GT Road, Shahdara, Delhi - 95. / Copper Wire Drawing only(Without Super Enamelling) / Orange Category / valid 25.07.05 / Not Applied / NO / 23.04.08 / No reply received / Final reminder. Call on 07.08.2008
18 / 21 / COPPER HOUSE / 1/421, GAli No 5, Friends Colony Industrial Area, GT Road, Shahdara, Delhi - 95. / Copper Wire Drawing / Orange Category / valid 25.07.05 / PENDING / NO / 25.04.08 / No reply received / Final reminder. Call on 07.08.2008
19 / 22 / D. P. METAL PVT / 22/2, gali no. 3, Friends Colony Industrial Area, GT Road, Shahdara, Delhi - 95. / Copper Wire Drawing / Orange Category / valid 29.07.05 / Not Applied / NO / 23.04.08 / Letter returned back / Two CMC-III Trainees inspect carrying the copy of the letter with them. Call on 07.08.2008.