1.1. Hiroshi Mano (Koden Techno Info)
November 2014 doc.: IEEE 802.11-14/1559r2
IEEE P802.11
Wireless LANs
Date: 2014-11-27
Author(s):
Name / Affiliation / Address / Phone / email
Hitoshi Morioka / SRC Software / Fukuoka JAPAN /
Tuesday November 11th, 2014
10:00ET
1. Attendee
1.1. Hiroshi Mano (Koden Techno Info)
1.2. Marc Emmelmann (Self-Employed)
1.3. Hitoshi Morioka (Allied Telesis R&D Center)
1.4. Lee Armstrong (US DoT)
1.5. Santosh Abraham (Qualcomm)
1.6. Xiaofei Wang (InterDigital)
1.7. sriram
2. Chair called the meeting to order at 10:02.
3. Agenda 11-14/1551r0.
4. Chair reminder on meeting and patent policy.
5. TGai LB204 comments for Draft 3.0 11-14/1351r14 Marc Emmelmann
5.1. CID6552
5.1.1. Accept.
5.2. CID6320, 6321, 6322
5.2.1. Revised.
5.2.2. Page number is wrong.
5.2.3. Correct P96 to P97.
5.3. CID6323
5.3.1. Accept.
5.4. CID6369
5.4.1. Accept.
5.5. CID6477
5.5.1. Accept.
5.6. CID6544, 6545
5.6.1. Accept.
5.7. CID6548
5.7.1. Accept.
5.8. CID6549
5.8.1. Accept.
5.9. CID6299
5.9.1. Accept.
5.10. CID6551
5.10.1. Accept.
5.11. CID6748
5.11.1. Accept.
5.12. CID6553, 6554
5.12.1. Reassigned to George Cherian.
5.13. CID6555
5.13.1. Need to be reassigned.
5.14. CID6571
5.14.1. Accept.
5.15. CID6572
5.15.1. Revised.
5.16. CID6573
5.16.1. Revised.
5.17. CID6601
5.17.1. Accept.
5.18. CID6732, 6742
5.18.1. Accept.
5.19. CID6745
5.19.1. Accept.
5.20. CID6550
5.20.1. Accept.
5.21. Resolved comments will be moved to 2014-11-11-telco tab in 11-14/1351r15.
6. Lee will prepare new revision of the draft next week.
7. Teleconference information (Web-EX) will be changed from next week.
8. Adjourned at 10:51.
Tuesday November 18th, 2014
10:00ET
1. Attendee
1.1. Hiroshi Mano (Koden Techno Info)
1.2. Marc Emmelmann (Self-Employed)
1.3. Hitoshi Morioka (Allied Telesis R&D Center)
1.4. Lee Armstrong (US DoT)
1.5. Ping Fang (Huawei)
1.6. Santosh Abraham (Qualcomm)
1.7. Xiaofei Wang (InterDigital)
1.8. Yunsong Yang (Huawei)
1.9. Joseph Levy (InterDigital)
1.10. Brent Bischoff (Cox Communication)
2. Chair called the meeting to order at 10:01.
3. Agenda 11-14/1551r1.
4. Chair reminder on meeting and patent policy.
5. Comment Resolutions by Yunsong Yang
5.1. CID6495
5.1.1. Revised.
5.1.2. Mark Rison accepted this resolution. (Yunsong)
5.2. CID6514
5.2.1. Yunsong’s personal preference is “reject”. But it’s OK to “accept”.
5.2.2. The group agreed to “accept”.
6. Some comment resolutions for draft 3.0 assigned to Xiaofei Wang 11-14/1560r0 Xiaofei Wang
6.1. CID6077
6.1.1. Revised.
6.1.2. Marc notified the message from Adrian.
6.1.2.1. "There is a syntax: "[optionally] present if <condition> [; otherwise not present]" Whether the protocol should be restrictive or not is a matter of philosophy. Some believe you shouldn't specify things you cannot test, and you cannot test absence for all time. Others believe in tying up loose ends to stop surprising things being discovered."
6.2. CID6121
6.2.1. Revised.
6.2.2. No objections.
6.3. CID6190
6.3.1. Revised.
6.3.2. No objections.
6.4. CID6247
6.4.1. Reject.
6.4.2. No objections.
6.5. CID6587 and 6815
6.5.1. Discuss whether to support DMG or not in Atlanta f2f meeting.
6.5.2. If “accept”, bigger submission is required. (Marc)
6.6. CID6812
6.6.1. Revised.
6.6.2. No objections.
6.7. CID6830
6.7.1. Revised.
6.7.2. No objections.
6.8. CID6831
6.8.1. Copy and paste the resolution for CID6830. (Ping)
6.8.2. We cannot use any cross references to other CIDs. (Marc)
6.9. CID6857
6.9.1. Revised.
6.10. CID6861
6.10.1. Revised.
6.11. CID6863
6.11.1. Revised.
6.12. CID6931
6.12.1. Reject.
6.12.2. The group agreed to “reject”.
6.13. CID6940
6.13.1. Revised.
6.13.2. No objections.
6.14. CID6978
6.14.1. Revised.
6.14.2. No objections.
6.15. CDI6983
6.15.1. Revised.
6.15.2. No objections.
6.16. Xiaofei will upload r1.
7. Adjourned at 11:02.
Tuesday November 25th, 2014
10:00ET
1. Attendee
1.1. Hiroshi Mano (Koden Techno Info)
1.2. Marc Emmelmann (Self-Employed)
1.3. Hitoshi Morioka (Allied Telesis R&D Center)
1.4. Lee Armstrong (US DoT)
1.5. Ping Fang (Huawei)
1.6. Xiaofei Wang (InterDigital)
1.7. Hiroki Nakano (Trans New Technology)
2. Chair called the meeting to order at 10:02.
3. Agenda 11-14/1551r2.
4. Chair reminder on meeting and patent policy.
5. Editor report from Lee.
6. MIB issues
6.1. Asking Lee to get TGai MIB. (Ping)
6.2. Complete by next f2f meeting. (Ping)
6.3. To be able to complie MIB. (Marc)
6.4. In Atlanta meeting, approved comment resolutions should be immediately check that it's safe to compile. (Marc)
7. Adjourned at 10:13.
Submission page 6 Hitoshi Morioka, SRC Software