National Preconstruction Services Problem
Evaluation Form
Dear ASC Preconstruction Services Problem Teams/Team Leaders:
Please have each team leader complete this evaluation form and return it with the Team Leader to the Debrief and Answer Session on Friday, February 13, 2009 at 6:45 PM. The provided evaluation form is your admission ticket for your team to the Debrief and Answer Session.
Your feedback is important to our team as we improve the quality of this problem in the years to come. Be honest and forthright with your answers. If you need additional space, please use the back of this form for your comments. Please label the question number to which you are responding.
Thank you for your time and consideration.
PCL Construction Services, Inc.
700 N. Central Ave, Suite 700, Glendale, ca 91203
Telephone (818)246-3481 u FAX (818)247-5775
Recipient
Page 2
1. Why did you choose this particular problem?
2. What was the most challenging component of the problem statement?
3. What time on Thursday did your team complete the written Phase II portion of the problem?
4. How well does your class work prepare you for this problem?
5. How much time (in total hours) did your team exercise the industry at large in preparing for this problem?
6. How satisfied are you with the time allotment to respond to each section of the problem?
a. Phase I - Prequalification
Very Dissatisfied Dissatisfied Neither Dissatisfied or Satisfied Satisfied Very Satisfied
b. Phase II – Proposal
Very Dissatisfied Dissatisfied Neither Dissatisfied or Satisfied Satisfied Very Satisfied
c. Presentation
Very Dissatisfied Dissatisfied Neither Dissatisfied or Satisfied Satisfied Very Satisfied
7. List any recommended changes to the competition rules. Include how to implement your recommendation.
8. Overall, how satisfied were you with the Preconstruction Services Problem?
Very Dissatisfied Dissatisfied Neither Dissatisfied or Satisfied Satisfied Very Satisfied
9. Overall, how satisfied were you with the Preconstruction Services Problem as a learning tool?
Very Dissatisfied Dissatisfied Neither Dissatisfied or Satisfied Satisfied Very Satisfied
10. Overall, how satisfied were you as to the professionalism of the PCL Problem team members?
Very Dissatisfied Dissatisfied Neither Dissatisfied or Satisfied Satisfied Very Satisfied
11. List three positive things about this years’ competition. Does not have to be Preconstruction Services Problem specific.
12. List three negative things about this years’ competition. Does not have to be Preconstruction Services Problem specific.
13. On a scale of 1-10, (ten being the best) how would you rate this year’s competition?
14. Rate each category using the following evaluation scoring system:
1 = Poor 2 = Needs Improvement 3 = Average 4 = Good 5 = Excellent
a. _____ Location of facilities
b. _____ Quality of the presentation room & equipment
c. _____ Applicability to school course work
d. _____ Availability of support from the Architect/Contracting/Engineering community
e. _____ Format of the problem statement
f. _____ Amount of work to the problem statement
g. _____ Quality of the problem statement
h. _____ Clarity of the Addendum
i. _____ Amount of presentation time
15. How much of the financial burden of this trip was paid by the students (not including entertainment and gambling) as a percentage of total costs?