ORAL PRESENTATION EVALUATION FORM
Student Papers Competition
46th AIAA/ASME/ASCE/AHS/ASC Structures, Structural Dynamics & Materials Conference
13th AIAA/ASME/AHS Adaptive Structures Conference
7th AIAA Non-Deterministic Approaches Forum
6th AIAA Gossamer Spacecraft Forum, and
1st AIAA Multidisciplinary Design Optimization Specialist Conference
Austin, TX, April 18-21, 2005
Tracking# ______Paper # AIAA 2005-______Evaluation Date:______
Paper Title:______
______
Presenter’s Name (The paper must be presented by the student author (first/primary author): ______
Evaluator’s Name ______
Affiliation:______
E-Mail: ______
Evaluator’s Comments:
(I.) Numerical Score: Please write your evaluation score in Column (b) for each of the 5 criteria:
Evaluation Criteria (a) / Raw score by evaluator (b) / Weight(c) / Weighted Points
(d) = (b)x(c)
1. Originality / ______(Max. 10) / 1.5 / ______(Max. 15)
2. Technical Content & Quality / ______(Max. 10) / 2.5 / ______(Max. 25)
3. Relevance of Contribution / ______(Max. 10) / 1.0 / ______(Max. 10)
4. Oral Presentation Quality / ______(Max .10) / 2.5 / ______(Max. 25)
5. Visual Quality / ______(Max .10) / 1.0 / ______(Max. 10)
6. Personal Contribution / _____ (Max. 10) / 1.5 / ______(Max. 15)
TOTAL Points / _____ (Max. 60) / ------ / ______(Max 100)
(II) Written Comments: Please give your written comments on the above criteria based on your evaluation of the oral presentation of the paper.
______
*Return completed form to: Ramesh B. Malla (Chair, Student Papers Competition) or Chris Horton at the Conference Registration desk immediately after you judge the oral presentation.
**There will be a meeting of the Student Papers Competition Selection Committee at 6PM on Tuesday, April 19, 2005 to select the winner(s). All student paper & presentation evaluators/judges are members of the committee. Please mark your calendar and attend the meeting. If any question, please contact Ramesh Malla, Ph.D., Department of Civil & Environmental Engineering, University of Connecticut, Storrs, CT 06269-2037, U.S.A./Tel. (860)486-3683/Fax. (860)486-2298/E-Mail:
------