October 2015 IEEE doc. # 15-15-0783-04-0010
IEEE P802.15
Wireless Personal Area Networks
Project / IEEE P802.15 Working Group for Wireless Personal Area Networks (WPANs)Title / TG10 BRC Conference Call Minutes for September -- October 2015
Date Submitted / October 27th, 2015
Source / [Charlie Perkins]
[Futurewei] / E-mail: [
Phone: [+1-408-330-4586]
Re: / TG10 BRC meeting for comments on D2_P802-15-10_Draft_Recommended_Practice
Abstract / TG10 Conference Call Minutes for the following teleconferences:
September 28, 2015
October 5, 2015
October 12, 2015
October 19, 2015
October 26, 2015
Purpose / Minutes for IEEE 802.15 TG10 Conference Calls
Notice / This document has been prepared to assist the IEEE P802.15. It is offered as a basis for discussion and is not binding on the contributing individual(s) or organization(s). The material in this document is subject to change in form and content after further study. The contributor(s) reserve(s) the right to add, amend or withdraw material contained herein.
Release / The contributor acknowledges and accepts that this contribution becomes the property of IEEE and may be made publicly available by P802.15.
IEEE Project 802
IEEE 802.15 TG10 Conference Call
Meeting Minutes: October 26, 2015
Chair: Clint Powell
Technical Editor: Verotiana Rabarijaona
Secretary: Charlie Perkins
Chair called the meeting to order at 6:05pm.
Attendance
- Verotiana Rabarijaona
- Clint Powell
- Jaehwan Kim
- Charlie Perkins
- Kiyoshi Fukui
- Soo-Young Chang
- Fumihide Kojime
- Noriyuki Sato
Agenda
1. Roll Call
2. Reminder of IEEE Policies and Procedures (please review http://standards.ieee.org/board/pat/pat-slideset.ppt BEFORE the call)
3. Review Agenda.
4. Comment Resolution– Verotiana – see doc. # 15-15-0318-28 for the consolidated comment database
a) Doc. # 15-0799-00 – SSPAN (Verotiana)
b) Doc. # 15-0792-00 – (Verotiana)
c) Doc. # 15-0780-00 – Assigned comments (Sato-san)
d) Other proposed resolutions as posted
5. AoB
Reminder of IEEE Policies and Procedures
Chair reminded everyone of their responsibility to inform of any essential patents. Made a call for potential or essential patent claims - no response was heard.
Review Agenda
No agenda revisions noted
Comment Resolution – Verotiana
a) Doc. # 15-0792-01 – IE-related comments (Verotiana)
o CID 1178: Accept in Principle, modified from previous discussion
o CID 1329: Tabled until Dallas: wait for opinion from Pat Kinney
o CID 1330: Reject: 0x40 is already assigned
o CID 1331: Revise; delete the clause entirely
o CID 1335: Accept in Principle / modification to suggested name
o CID 1342: Revise; insert new text
o CID 1343: Accept in Principle; add
o CID 1347: Accept in Principle
o CID 1352: Accept in Principle
o CID 1354: Accept in Principle
o CID 1357: Accept in Principle
o CID 1358: Accept in Principle
o CID 1359: Accept in Principle
o CID 1364: Accept in Principle
o CID 1366: Accept in Principle
o CID 1368: Accept in Principle; related to last week’s R1121
o CID 1375: To be reviewed; change remaining float to integer # milliseconds
o CID 1383: Accept in Principle; see CID 1368
o CID 1385: Accept in Principle
o CID 1386: Accept in Principle
o CID 1387: Accept in Principle; see CID 1386 for similar added text
o CID 1392: Accept in Principle
o CID 1394: Accept in Principle; add new terminology SLSN versus LSN
o CID 1402: Accept in Principle
o CID 1405: Withdrawn
o CID 1406: Accept in Principle; similar to previous comment 1343 but just one service and new figure
o CID 1407: Accept in Principle; see also CID 1406
o CID 1411: Withdrawn
o CID 1417: Accept in Principle; SSPAN only has a single mesh
o CID 1171, CID R1181: see CID 1425
o CID R1173: Accept in Principle; similar to previous comment
o CID R1175: Accept in Principle; similar to previous comment
o CID R1179: Accept in Principle; similar to previous comment
o CID R1188: Accept in Principle
b) Doc. # 15-0799-00 – SSPAN (Verotiana)
o CID 1393, CID 1413, CID 1416: Accept in Principle; clarifying text and terminology added; also added indication primitive L2RLME-NOTIFY in 7.1
c) Doc. # 15-0780-00 – assigned comments (Sato-san) [not enough time to discuss]
AoB
None mentioned
Action items
· Doc. # 15-0792-02 revision required (Verotiana)
· Doc. # 15-0799-01 revision required (Verotiana)
Adjourned at 8:08pm
IEEE Project 802
IEEE 802.15 TG10 Conference Call
Meeting Minutes: October 19, 2015
Chair: Clint Powell
Technical Editor: Verotiana Rabarijaona
Secretary: Charlie Perkins
Chair called the meeting to order at 6:06pm. Problems perhaps stemming from holding meeting across firewall.
Attendance
- Verotiana Rabarijaona
- Clint Powell
- Jaehwan Kim
- Charlie Perkins
- Kiyoshi Fukui
- Soo-Young Chang
- Jaebeom Kim
- Noriyuki Sato
Agenda
1. Roll Call
2. Reminder of IEEE Policies and Procedures (please review http://standards.ieee.org/board/pat/pat-slideset.ppt BEFORE the call)
3. Review Agenda.
4. Resolve comments – Verotiana – see doc. # 15-15-0318-27 for the consolidated comment database
a) Doc. # 15-0780-00 – Assigned comments (Sato-san)
b) Doc. # 15-0789-00 -- Routing (Jaehwan)
c) Doc. # 15-0798-00 -- Routing (Verotiana)
d) Doc. # 15-0799-00 -- SSPAN (Verotiana)
e) Other comment resolutions as posted
5. LB Recirculation Timeline
6. Dallas agenda Doc. #15-800-00 review; will try recirculation after the meeting
7. AoB
Reminder of IEEE Policies and Procedures
Chair reminded everyone of their responsibility to inform of any essential patents. Made a call for potential or essential patent claims - no response was heard.
Review Agenda
No agenda revisions noted
Comment Resolution – Verotiana
a) Doc. # 15-0780-00 – Additional MCO-related comments (Jaehwan)
o CID 1039 Reject; original sentence is correct (double checked)
o CID 1041 Accept in Principle
o CID 1043 Accept in Principle with numerous revisions as suggested by Verotiana
b) Doc. # 15-0789-01 – MCO-related comments (Jaehwan)
o CID 1149 Accept in Principle
o CID 1199 Accept in Principle
o CID 1367 Accept in Principle – needs to be checked
o CID 1370 Work in Progress
o CID 1458 Accept in Principle – to be checked
c) Doc. # 15-0789-00 – MCO-related comments (Jaehwan)
o CID 1162 Accept in Principle
o CID 1163 Accept in Principle
d) Doc. # 15-0798-00 – R1121 resolution (Verotiana)
o CID R1121Accept in Principle; discussion about whether NT entry really needs to be deleted or perhaps kept as a “last resort”
e) Doc. # 15-0799-00 – (Verotiana) [not enough time to discuss]
AoB
None mentioned
Action items
· Doc. # 15-0789-01 revision required
o CID 1370 WiP. ETRI will provide a text describing the use of the "Parent PAN coordinator Channel Number" field
o CID 1458 TBR. Verotiana will send an email to Tero to check if he agrees with the resolution.
· Doc. # 15-0798-00 revision required (Verotiana)
o Charlie, Verotiana and Sato-san will continue the discussion offline.
Adjourned at 7:30pm
IEEE Project 802
IEEE 802.15 TG10 Conference Call
Meeting Minutes: October 12, 2015
Chair: Clint Powell
Technical Editor: Verotiana Rabarijaona
Secretary: Charlie Perkins
Chair called the meeting to order at 6:08pm.
Attendance
Submission Page XXX Charlie Perkins (Futurewei)/ Clint Powell (PWC)
October 2015 IEEE doc. # 15-15-0783-04-0010
- Clint Powell
- Verotiana Rabarijaona
- Kojima Fumihide
- Jaehwan Kim
- Charlie Perkins
- Kiyoshi Fukui
- Soo-Young Chang
- Jaebeom Kim
- Noriyuki Sato
Agenda
1. Roll Call
2. Reminder of IEEE Policies and Procedures (please review http://standards.ieee.org/board/pat/pat-slideset.ppt BEFORE the call)
3. Review Agenda.
4. Resolve comments – Verotiana – see doc. # 15-15-0318-26 for the consolidated comment database
a) Doc. # 15-0787-00 – MCO-related (Jaehwan)
b) Doc. # 15-0788-00 -- MCO-related (Jaehwan)
c) Doc. # 15-0789-00 -- Routing (Jaehwan)
d) Doc. # 15-0790-00 -- Tech Editorial (Verotiana)
e) Doc. # 15-0765-01 -- (Charlie)
f) Doc. # 15-0784-00 -- Routing (Jaehwan)
g) Doc. # 15-0785-00 -- Routing (Jaehwan)
h) Doc. # 15-0786-00 -- Routing (Jaehwan)
5. Next call on 10/19-10/20 (change in duration) 9:00am-10:30am (6:00pm-7:30pm Pacific)
6. AoB
Reminder of IEEE Policies and Procedures
Chair reminded everyone of their responsibility to inform of any essential patents. Made a call for potential or essential patent claims - no response was heard.
Review Agenda
No agenda revisions noted
Comment Resolution – Verotiana
a) Doc. # 15-0787-00 – MCO-related comments (Jaehwan)
o CID 1186 Accept
o CID 1187 Accept in Principle
o CID 1188 Accept in Principle
o CID 1189 Accept in Principle; question about whether multiple PANs can use a single channel. Proposal to remove Figure 3 and the cross-reference to Figure 3 on pg. 8. Reference instead the new section with L2R and TMCTP in 5.4.1.3
o CID 1191 Accept
o CID 1194 Accept in Principle
o CID 1195 Accept in Principle
o CID 1197 Accept in Principle with revisions as suggested by Verotiana
o CID 1200 Accept in Principle
b) Doc. # 15-0788-00 – Additional MCO-related comments (Jaehwan)
o CID 1247 Accept
o CID 1253 Accept
o CID 1264 Accept in Principle with numerous revisions as suggested by Verotiana
o CID 1262 Accept in Principle with revisions as suggested by Verotiana
o CID 1271 Accept in Principle; improve language about beacons
o CID 1260 Accept in Principle
o CID 1263 Accept in Principle; related to resolution for CID 1264
o CID 1266 Accept in Principle
o CID 1267 Accept in Principle with numerous revisions as suggested by Verotiana
o CID 1268
o CID 1270 Accept in Principle
o CID 1272 Work in Progress…
c) Doc. # 15-0778-02 – Promiscuous mode (Verotiana)
o CID 1182 Accept in Principle
d) Doc. # 15-0765-01 - (Charlie)
o Revised resolutions are accepted
e) Doc. # 15-0792-00 – IE-related comments (Verotiana)
o Only comments which are Accept will be discussed
o CID 1344 Accept in Principle
o CID 1348 Accept in Principle
o CID 1353 Accept in Principle
o CID 1381 Accept in Principle
o CID 1383 Work in Progress; delete the sentence
o CID 1403 Accept in Principle
o CID 1406 Accept
AoB
None mentioned
Action items
· Doc. # 15-0787-00 revision required (Jaehwan)
· Doc. # 15-0788-00 revision required (Jaehwan)
· Doc. # 15-0778-02 Promiscuous mode revisions (Verotiana)
Adjourned at 8:04pm
IEEE Project 802
IEEE 802.15 TG10 Conference Call
Meeting Minutes: October 5, 2015
Chair: Clint Powell
Technical Editor: Verotiana Rabarijaona
Secretary: Charlie Perkins
Chair called the meeting to order at 6:06pm.
Attendance
- Clint Powell
- Verotiana Rabarijaona
- Kojima Fumihide
- Jaehwan Kim
- Charlie Perkins
- Kiyoshi Fukui
- Soo-Young Chang
- Jaebeom Kim
Agenda
1. Roll Call
2. Reminder of IEEE Policies and Procedures (please review http://standards.ieee.org/board/pat/pat-slideset.ppt BEFORE the call)
3. Review Agenda.
4. Resolve comments – Verotiana – see doc. # 15-15-0318-25 for the consolidated comment database
a) Doc. # 15-0790-00 - Tech Editorial (Verotiana)
b) Doc. # 15-0765-00 - (Charlie)
c) Doc. # 15-0784-00 – Airtime Metric (Jaehwan)
d) Doc. # 15-0785-00 - Routing (Jaehwan)
e) Doc. # 15-0786-00 - Routing (Jaehwan)
f) Doc. # 15-0787-00 - Routing (Jaehwan) [ran out of time, postponed]
g) Doc. # 15-0788-00 - Routing (Jaehwan) [ran out of time, postponed]
h) Doc. # 15-0789-00 - Routing (Jaehwan) [ran out of time, postponed]
5. AOB
Reminder of IEEE Policies and Procedures
Chair reminded everyone of their responsibility to inform of any essential patents. Made a call for potential or essential patent claims - no response was heard.
Review Agenda
No agenda revisions noted
Comment Resolution – Verotiana
a) Doc. # 15-0790-00 - Tech Editorial (Verotiana)
o Rogue comments have been accepted; to be added to the rogue spreadsheet page
b) Doc. # 15-0765-00 - (Charlie)
o 1020: accepted as is
o R1091: figure can be used for suggested changes
o R1124: insert “of” before “children”
o R1202: accepted
c) Doc. # 15-0784-00 – Airtime Metric (Jaehwan)
o Verotiana request to copy entire comment; Clint will submit rev 01 for that
o 1166, 1167: accepted
d) Doc. # 15-0785-00 - Routing (Jaehwan)
o 1212 accepted with revision suggested by Verotiana
§ delete sentence; table 42, pg. 94, line 6
§ insert P2P Request IE after L2R Routing IE
o 1216 accepted with revision suggested by Verotiana
§ allow faster frame transmission after receiving P2P-RP IE.
o 1217 Work in Progress
§ Change “Direct Response” to be “Intermediate Response”
§ Add in Response Enabled and Response Disabled description
o 1395 accepted with revisions as suggested by Verotiana
§ reserved field in Figure 50.
§ Delete bit 2 in Figure 50, as well as the bottom sentence
§ Change “Direct Response” terminology
§ Use “Mesh Address Mode” instead of “Mesh Root Address Mode”
o 1396 accepted
o 1397 Accept in Principle; the last two sentences are going to be deleted anyway
o 1398 Work in Progress, with revision as suggested by Verotiana
o 1399 Work in Progress
e) Doc. # 15-0786-00 – Rogue Editorial comments (Jaehwan)
o R1087 Accept in Principle with revisions as suggested by Verotiana
o R1112 accepted: Work in Progress, related to resolutions in 15-15-0788
o R1132 accepted; inserted acronyms in section 3.2
o R1140 Accept in Principle, use subscript for t0
o R1142 Accept in Principle, use subscript for t1
o R1143 Accept in Principle
o R1144 Accept in Principle, use subscript for t2
o R1145 Accept in Principle
AoB
None mentioned
Action items
· Doc. # 15-0765-00 revision required (Charlie)
· Doc. # 15-0784-00 revision required (Jaehwan)
· Doc. # 15-0785-00 revision required (Jaehwan)
· Doc. # 15-0786-00 revision required (Jaehwan)
Adjourned at 8:04pm
IEEE Project 802
IEEE 802.15 TG10 Conference Call
Meeting Minutes: September 28, 2015
Chair: Clint Powell
Technical Editor: Verotiana Rabarijaona
Secretary: Charlie Perkins
Chair called the meeting to order.
Attendance
- Clint Powell
- Verotiana Rabarijaona
- Noriyuki Sato
- Kiyoshi Fukui
Agenda