Clinical Uncertainty in Primary Care: The challenge of collaborative engagement
Chapter 98
Practice Inquiry: Uncertainty Learning in Primary Care Practice
On-line Resource #2
The CME Programs: Practice Inquiry - Improving Clinical Judgment and Clinical Practice, at the Department of Family & Community Medicine at University of California, San Francisco,and at Kaiser Permanente Medical Center Oakland, California
Lucia S. Sommers, DrPH
The Practice Inquiry CME Program at UCSF based in the Department of Family and Community Medicine began in 2005 preceded by 2 ½ years of pilot work. As of summer 2012, seven PI groups are part of the program. Two PI groups have been meeting in Kaiser Permanente Medical Centers based in the Departmentof Medicine; one group has been CME- certified since 2005 and the other group is currently applying for accredited CME status.In the US, most states require physicians and mid-level practitioners to obtain ‘CME credits’ in order for licensure renewal.
Practice Inquiry Groups
GroupSite
(in Northern California) / Affiliation / First Mtg Date / Current Members / Meeting Frequency/
Time / Facilitation
- Maxine Hall Health Center (San Francisco))
(publicly funded) / 2002 / 6 PCPs
1 NP / Every other month / LS
- Asian Health Services
1 PA / Weekly / MD member
- Kaiser Permanente (Oakland)
2-3 specialists / Monthly, ON HOLD (Physician facilitator retired) / MD member
- Lakeshore
(San Francisco) / Private, non-profit,
university sponsored / 2005 / 6 PCPs
2 NPs / Monthly / LS
MD members
- Potrero Hill Health Center
1 NP
1 Specialist / Every other month / LS
- Baywest
1 NP / Monthly, ON HOLD (Lost members; new hires as of 7/12)
- Axis Health
(Pleasanton) / Community health center (publicly funded) / 2009 / 6-8 PCPs
1 NP / Monthly / LS
MD member
- Sutter East Bay Foundation
2 NPs / Monthly / LS
- Kaiser Permanente (Richmond)
3-4 specialists / Weekly / MD member
PCP- primary care physician, NP- nurse practitioner, PA – physician assistant, LS- Lucia Sommers
Funding: $500annual accreditation review feewaived by UCSF as a community service in the interest of supporting non-commercial, practice-based CME; no fees at Kaiser Permanente
CME Program Clinician Educational Objectives:
- To share uncertainties in managing difficult/complex patients with colleagues
- To practice blending multiple clinical judgment input into strategies for engaginguncertainty
- To identify recurring uncertainties requiring clinic-wide educational/ system interventions
CME Program Group Participation Requirements:
- Minimum of 3 clinicians to count as CME credit-worthy (Category 1 CME credit)
- Facilitator present (4th group member or external person of group’s choosing)
- Case log maintained (See example case log below.)
- Participant comments via annual PI Feedback Questionnaire (See Figure 1 attached.)
UCSF CME Program (#MGR12059) Department of Family and Community Medicine
PRACTICE INQUIRY
(Name of Group)CASE LOG (November – January )
Date / # / New/Old / Clinical Uncertainty / Case Description/Issues / Feedback/Discussion
11/18 / Old / Follow-up #68: 25 yo male prescribed Levaquin for bad bronchitis (ABX allergies); subsequently complained couldn’t move shoulder; saw commercial regarding tendon rupture caused by Levequin / Pt. cancelled apt with PCP
Implications for larger practice – should we tell patients about potential adverse effects of certain antibiotics (e.g., cipro) and sterioids?
To do lit review: frequency of tendon rupture with levaquin & cipro,
11/18 / #69 / New / “I’m not sure what needs to be done next.” 75yo female experiencing drug interaction between Seroquel and her cardiac meds – SOB and tachy while walking. I need to negotiate management changes with pt’s psychiatrist and cardiologist to reduce symptoms / Pt currently on seroquel, clonopin, lomectil, coumdin, digoxin, and flecamide. Gets SOB and tachy, hot and sweaty while walking; anxiety re falling. Cardioverted with no improvement; now to receive holter / Consider getting EKG to look at QT interval
Consider referring to new cardiologist.
To do lit review on how seroquel interacts with cardiac meds
1/20 / #72 / New / “He keeps getting admitted… looks like patient and daughter have given up trying.” / Mid 70’s male with CHF from Pakistan lives with caregiver daughter; HTN, DM; ambulatory , 02 dependent; 4 admits in 4 months, non-compliant with meds, now on verge of being admitted again. / Common CHF dilemma
Placement in B&C, nursing home?
Ready for hospice?
Depressed? (anti-depressants were prescribed but probably doesn’t take)
What does he want out of life?
Consider counseling referral
1/20 / Old / Follow-up #56: 39 yo female with many atypical problems over a lot of systems (hx of Cushings syndrome, pos adrenal insuffic, PCOS, and ovarian mass being worked up at UCSF OBGYN; post chole developed DVT on BCP; warfarin rx failed to impact INRs,) struggling with the insurance company to cover her Lovenox / At last visit, complaining of abdom pain; referred to GI, negative colonoscopy.; not anti-coag.
Keeps cancelling visits at last minute and only comes when in crisis
Consider phone call/letter to lay out terms of relationship
JO
Key Statistics:
- Largest number of groups in any one year: 14
- Number of groups meeting for at least 3 years: 10
- Number of groups meeting for at least 5 years: 6
- Number of groups meeting regularly for at least 18 months no longer participating: 3
Program Evaluation:
- Case Series Analysis (150 cases)
- Uncertainty type: 33% diagnostic, 25% management uncertainties, 23% diagnostic/management; 19% clinician-patient relation
- 15% - adverse outcome; 8% End-of-life
- Top 7 condition types: morbid obesity, chronic pain, use of the prostate specific antigen (PSA) test, lipid abnormalities, and incidental findings on studies, bi-polar disorders, and patients with both diabetes and hypertension.
(See On-Line Resource #3“Practice Inquiry Clinical Uncertainty Taxonomy” fora description of the work underway to categorize 350 uncertainty cases using an automated data collection and categorization tool.)
- Seven-Year Trend Analysis (Data collected via annual PI Feedback Questionnaire; see Figure 1, attached.)
Practice Inquiry Clinician Self-Report Trend Analysis
Program Years2005-06 / 2006-07 / 2007-08 / 2008-09 / 2009-10 / 2010-11 / 2011-12
# SF Bay Area Groups / 7 / 9 / 10 / 6 / 7 / 8 / 7
#Forms distributed / 60 / 110 / 72 / 65 / 77 / 83 / 57
Response Rate / 80% / 71% / 75% / 55% / 73% / 68% / 79%
Overall Value* / 3.9 / 4.0 / unavailable / 4.0 / 3.8 / 4.1 / 4.0
% Clinicians writing case comments ** / 58% / 67% / 67% / 57% / 47% / 51% / 66%
*5-point Likert scale, 5 = highest value
**Examples
- “Blind older female with chronic renal disease and diabetes needing to use insulin but refusing. Came here daily for injections but can’t continue forever.. Patient refusing to self-inject; no family. Group advised to offer oral meds and if in the end the patient refuses, then to just accept that it’s the patient’s choice”
- “Elderly female with anemia - will check an additional test and then stop worrying about it”
- “Long-term use of Fosamax in patients who have been on it for >5 years; I’ll repeat Dexa and consider DC-ing med”
- “Patient with newly diagnosed lupus. Since patient not be able to be seen by specialist for a couple of months, what should I be doing if the patient is not having a flare…Patient has mildly elevated ESR. Question: without symptoms, need to lower ESR?Group thought ‘no.’“
- “Patient with chronic pain, depression, poor motivation. Brought to the group – came away with different interpretation of patient behavior – ultimately more successful management of the patient”
1