International Journal of Psycho-Educational Sciences: Reviewer Evaluation Form

This form is a mere suggestion. You can freely use a separate sheet.

Editor-in-Chief Prof.Dr.Mourad Ali Eissa Saad Email:

Title:

Yes / No / not apply
1 / Is this an original contribution? /  /  / 
2 / Is the title suitable? /  /  / 
3 / Is the abstract sufficiently informative especially when read in isolation ? /  /  / 
4 / Is the statement of the objectives adequate and appropriate in view of the subject matter? /  /  / 
5 / Is the material clearly presented? /  /  / 
6 / Are the results presented clearly and discussed satisfactorily? /  /  / 
7 / Are figures and tables adequate in quality and number? /  /  / 
8 / Is the statistical analysis sound and carefully chosen ? ( If applicable) /  /  / 
9 / Are scientific reasoning, argumentation and interpretation adequate? /  /  / 
10 / Is reference to previous work adequate? /  /  / 
11 / Is the length of the paper satisfactory? /  /  / 
12 / Is there any repetition in the article? /  /  / 
13 / Please suggest changes or brief additions or deletions (Words, phrases) that could improve the style of this paper? /  /  / 
14 / Are scientific writing style and language clear and correct? /  /  / 
* / Other comments: You can freely use a separate sheet. / 
15 / Please select the type of the researchwork / Article / Review Article / Brief Article(short note)

Reviewer's recommendation .

( ) Acceptable as it is. ( ) Requires minor revision.

( ) Requires substantial revision. ( ) Inacceptable.

Reviewer 's Name :