MODERNIZING AGRICULTURAL KNOWLEDGE
AND INFORMATION SYSTEMS
ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT
Final Report
June, 21, 2004
Prepared by
Dr. Violeta Visan
Bucharest
ROMANIA
CONTENTS
Acronyms iv
SUMMARY v
1. INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND 1
1.1 Purpose 1
1.2 Modernizing Agricultural Knowledge and Information Systems Project 1
2. LEGAL PROVISIONS APPLICABLE FOR ENV. ASSESSMENT 3
2.1 Public authorities for environmental protection 3
2.2 National permitting legislation for construction works 3
2.3 Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) legislation 3
2.4 Operating permits for existing activities 5
2.5 Environmental Monitoring and Control 5
2.6 Selected national legislation on waste management 6
2.7 National requirements for management of waste generated from research laboratories other than sanitary-veterinary laboratories 7
2.7.1 Waste classification 7
2.7.2 Waste management requirements 7
2.8 National requirements for management of waste generated from veterinary activity including the research, diagnosis, treatment and disease prevention activity 8
2.8.1 Waste classification 8
2.8.2 Requirements for laboratory waste management 8
2.8.3 Requirements for management of veterinary waste other than laboratory waste 9
2.9 Requirements for BIP infrastructure and operation 10
2.9.1 Requirements for BIP infrastructure 10
2.9.2 Requirements for BIP operation 10
2.10 Laboratory certification on GLP 11
3. METHODOLOGICAL APPROACH FOR ENV. ASSESSMENT 12
3.1 Project screening / Initial evaluation of the proposed projects 12
4. ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT 14
4.1 Project I: Rehabilitation of existing physical infrastructure or erection of new buildings for three Road BIPs 14
4.1.1. Location and environment state 14
4.1.2 Characteristics of the infrastructure needed for sanitary inspection activity 14
4.1.3 Assessment of potential environmental impact during construction and operation 15
4.2 Project II: A) New building for Institute of Veterinary Hygiene and Public Health (IVHPH) and (B) Laboratory facility (building and some equipment) for analysis of animal feeding stuffs 17
4.2.1 Location and environment state 17
4.2.2 General technical characteristics of the infrastructure needed 17
4.2.3 Assessment of potential environmental impact during construction and operation 17
4.3 Project III Demonstration and Training Facility for Animal Welfare 19
4.3.1 Project III.A Facility rehabilitation for setting up the National Center for Animal Welfare 19
4.3.1.1 Location and environment state 19
4.3.1.2 Assessment of potential environmental impact during construction and operation 20
4.3.2 Project III.B Training Base for Animal Welfare. 21
4.3.2.1 Location and environment state 21
4.3.2.2 Civil works needed 21
4.3.2.3 Assessment of potential environmental impact during construction and operation 21
4.4 Project IV: Rehabilitation, extension and equipping of an existing building for RISSA 22
4.4.1 Location and environment state 22
4.4.2 General technical characteristics of the proposed civil works 22
4.4.3 Assessment of potential environmental impact during construction and operation 23
5. ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT PLAN 27
5.1 General 27
5.2 Mitigation Plan 27
5.3 Monitoring Plan 29
5.4 Capacity development and training 29
5.5 Costs 29
Table 5.1 Mitigation plan for impacts during operation 30
Annex 1: References 32
Annex 2 :Guidelines for Bio-safety Handbook 33
Figure 1
Acronyms
LegislationAPHC / Animal Products for Human Consumption
GD / Governmental Decision
GEO / Governmental Emergency Ordinance
MO / Ministerial Order
Administration/Institutions
MoA / Ministry of Agriculture (generic name)
MoE / Ministry of Environment (generic name)
MoH / Ministry of Health (generic name)
MoL / Ministry of Labour (generic name)
MoPW / Ministry of Public Works (generic name)
AVSA / Agency for Veterinary and Food Safety
DoBIPICC / Directorate for BIP Inspection, Control and Coordination
LEPA / Local environmental protection agency (county level)
REPA / Regional environmental protection agency (development region level)
IVHPH / Institute of Veterinary Hygiene and Public Health
RIISA / Research Institute for Soil Science and Agro-chemistry
Others
MAKIS / Modernizing Agricultural Knowledge and Information Systems
APNHC / Animal Products not for Human Consumption
BIP / Border Inspection Point
HC-T / Human Consumption under Temperature Control
HC-NT / Human Consumption not under Temperature Control
LATC / Live Animals under Temperature Control
LANTC / Live Animals Not under Temperature Control
NHC-T / Not Human Consumption under Temperature Control
NHC-NT / Not Human Consumption not under Temperature Control
EA / Environmental Assessment
ELV / Emission Limit Values
MAC / Maximum Allowable Concentration
GLP / Good Laboratory Practice
GMP / Good Manufacturing Practice
HSE / Health Safety and Environment
HWM / Hazardous Waste Management
WWTP / Wastewater Treatment Plant
SUMMARY
1. INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND
The World Bank is assisting the Government of Romania to prepare the IBRD-funded Project: Modernizing Agricultural Knowledge and Information Systems (MAKIS) with the objective to assist the Romanian Government to improve the competitiveness of farmers and agro-processors in the EU accession environment. This will be achieved through: (i) increased access of farmers and agro-processors to knowledge on technologies related to production, quality control, food safety, processing and marketing in order to meet EU standards; (ii) implementation of measures for inspection/control, risk management and communication in food safety matters; and (iii) improved linkages between agricultural research, extension, education and clients of the Romanian AKIS to the global knowledge pool. Towards this, the project comprises three components:
a) Strengthening the National Agency for Sanitary, Veterinary and Food Safety (AVSA) and Phyto-sanitary Units;
b) Support for Agricultural Research; and
c) Support for Advisory and Information System
Components a) and b) will undertake activities that involve construction works such as:
I. Rehabilitation of existing physical infrastructure or erection of new buildings for three Border Inspection Points; some BIPs will be specialized for the veterinary checks of live animals and animal products, while others will be exclusively for check of the animal products and other commodities.
II. (A) A new building to be built for Institute of Veterinary Hygiene and Public Health (IVHPH) and (B) a laboratory facility (building and some equipment) for analysis of animal feeding stuffs to be established; both establishments would be located on AVSA-owned land near Bucharest.
III. Demonstration and Training Facility for Animal Welfare to be established also on the premises provided by Pasteur Institute; the project will have two components: (A) Facility rehabilitation and supplementary equipment for setting up the National Center for Animal Welfare and (B) Establishing a Training Base for Animal Welfare.
IV. Rehabilitation, extension and equipping of an existing building for Research Institute for Soil Science and Agro-chemistry located in Bucharest
The constructed buildings will include laboratories and the related activity/processes will possibly result in hazardous waste whose disposal may require incineration. Housing of live animals over a short time period but frequently will be part of activity in those BIPs aiming for veterinary control of live animals.
Within component a), the WB Project will also support (i) the provision of essential equipment in 5 regional laboratories under AVSA, (ii) the upgrading, additional laboratory and IT equipment for the Central Laboratory for Phytosanitary Quarantine and the Central Laboratory for Pesticides Residues Control for Plants and Plant Products and (iii) additional equipment for some of the Regional Laboratories. Laboratory operation might also have both occupational health & safety and environmental impacts that have to be identified, mitigated and monitored.
The MAKIS Project has been categorized by the World Bank as category B and in accordance with the Bank’s Operational Policy 4.0 requirements, an environmental assessment (EA) is necessary. The overall objective of this EA is to ensure that the proposed investments will meet the requirements of the World Bank environmental assessment policy as described in OP/BP/GP 4.01, as well as both the Romanian laws and regulations on environmental expertise and impact assessment and the EU requirements in terms of environment protection related to infrastructure projects and to the operation of laboratories and of other facilities concerned.
2. LEGAL PROVISIONS APPLICABLE FOR EA
The national legislation is very comprehensive and fully transposes the EU directives as regards the following issues:
· Mandatory EIA process for projects with significant environmental impact and the development consent issued on the basis of the environmental agreement as legal act (MO 860/2002 of MoE and MO 1943/2002 of MoPW).
· Operating permits for existing activities issued by the involved authorities (GD 573/2002); for instance, local representatives under AVSA are the permitting authority for veterinary activities while the health & safety permit is issued by local Local Work Inspectorate (authorities under MoL) and Public Health Directorate.
· Environmental Monitoring and Control carried out both by the relevant authorities with control powers and by the activity holder/operator who has the obligation to set up its own internal monitoring system according to the requirements provided by the environmental agreement and permit (MO 541/2000 of MoE).
· Waste management: waste classification and waste and hazardous waste lists (GEO 78/2000 and GD 856/2002); regulations for landfill of waste (GD 162/2002); norms for operation, surveillance and control of waste incineration and co-incineration process (GD 182/2002); registers on waste management activities.
· Requirements for management of waste generated from laboratories other than sanitary-veterinary laboratories (GD 162/2002); each type of waste should be collected separately, the solid non-hazardous waste might be transported to the urban landfill, the liquid hazardous waste should be neutralized and then might be discharged to the sewerage system, the solid hazardous waste should be treated if possible and then transported to the urban landfill, the solid hazardous waste that can not be treated should be incinerated.
· Regulations for management of waste generated from veterinary activity including the research, diagnosis, treatment and disease prevention activity (MO 373/2001 as amended by 483/2001 of MoA): organizing and equipping of the sanitary-veterinary laboratories, regulation on sampling, conditioning, packaging and transport of samples; health & safety rules; handling of hazardous waste and contamination prevention; collection, containment, storage and disposal of solid, liquid and radioactive waste, testing of the hazardous waste management; waste incineration; staff training. These regulation provide that:
- The liquid and solid waste resulting from sample processing should be i) sterilized, neutralized or only collected, ii) packaged in sterile and tight closed recipients and iii) directed to one of the following compartments: a) sterilization and neutralization room; b) platform for waste temporary storage; c) incinerator
- Laboratory for hygiene and environmental protection within the Animal welfare department is responsible for the control of HWM on the technological flow in all departments and laboratories.
- The control of HWM is realized through inspection, quick tests or complex laboratory tests, periodical reporting of incidents to the department top management
- Testing is focused on inside surfaces, wastewater from sanitary-veterinary laboratory, air pollutant emission, soil samples, ash resulting from incinerator.
- The incineration is recommended as the most efficient final disposal method for the solid hazardous waste.
- The liquid hazardous waste should be first decontaminated/sterilized and neutralized and only then discharged to the urban sewerage system.
· Requirements for BIP infrastructure and operation (MO 71/2003 of MoA which fully transposes the EU Commission Decision 2001/818/EC and Council Directive 91/496/EEC dealing with the inspection of animals):
- The minimum infrastructure requires the following elements: Office with communication equipment; Social rooms consisting of changing rooms, toilets and hand washing facilities; Facilities for loading and unloading the different means of transport; Inspection facilities; Appropriate storage rooms (for storage of food, waste and dead animals); Room for (taking and) processing samples; Equipment and facilities for cleaning and disinfecting; Separate facilities for livestock (cattle, sheep/goats and pigs), horses and small animals; Specialized laboratory and the services of an undertaking in the immediate vicinity which has the facilities and equipment to house, water, treat and, if necessary, slaughter the animals.
- The functionality of veterinary BIPs has to match the following requirements: to have access to all parts of the consignment, to keep up the hygienic status of the consignment, to not spread possible hazards into the environment, to retain consignments at the BIP if clearance need more time consuming checks and laboratory examinations, to have special laboratory equipment for disease investigation, to address the requirements of animal protection and animal welfare when living animals are transported, to address appropriately the issue of waste disposal (a rendering plant or the own incinerator).
· Requirements for activities dealing with animal by-products not for human consumption aiming to protect the public and animal health (MO 723/2003 of MoA transposes the CE Regulation 1774/2002): Animal by-products named also „materials” are clasified in three categories (the imported APNHC that failed the sanitary border inspection fall in the 2nd category); Depending on the category, the materials shall be collected, transported, identified and: (a) directly disposed of as waste by incineration, (b) processed in a processing plant using appropriate processing methods strictly defined or (c) disposed of as waste by burial in a landfill approved under Directive 1999/31/EC; minimum requirements for the incineration plants; less strict requirements applicable to low-capacity incineration plants (such as those located on farms and at pet crematoria) to reflect the lower risk posed by the material treated and to avoid unnecessary transport of animal by-products.
· Laboratory certification on GLP (MO 370/2003 for laboratories with activities related to environmental protection, MO 146/2000 of MoA for sanitary-veterinary laboratories) and inspection of compliance with GPL principles and requirements (MO 117-56-248/2002 of MoI, MoH and MoA).
3. METHODOLOGICAL APPROACH FOR ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT
According to the ToR, the infrastructure projects I, II, III and IV referred to in chapter 1 have already been categorized by the World Bank as category B being comparable with those under point (k) – rehabilitation or modification of existing industrial facilities (small scale) – and therefore the environmental assessment was required. Comparison with the type of projects listed in Annex I.1 and Annex I.2 of MO/860 shows that none of the proposed projects is found on Annex I.1 which means that no significant environmental impact might be generated by these projects. Projects I will be developed on locations placed outside human settlements and might be assimilated to projects on Annex I.2 point 12 (d) - Permanent camp sites and caravan sites. Project II, Project III and Project IV will be located in urban areas and they can be considered like projects on Annex I.2 point 10 (b) - Urban development projects, including the construction of shopping centres and car parks.