Technical Documentation for: CC 7876Monthly CPM Collective Deficiency Settlement / Date: 1/12/11
Settlements & Billing
Monthly CPM Collective Deficiency Settlement
(CC 7876)
Version 5.0
CAISO, 2018 / Page 1 of 9Settlements & Billing / Version: 5.0
Technical Documentation for: CC 7876Monthly CPM Collective Deficiency Settlement / Date: 1/12/11
Table of Contents
1.Purpose of Document
2.Introduction
2.1Background
2.2Description
3.Charge Code Requirements
3.1Business Rules
3.2Predecessor Charge Codes
3.3Successor Charge Codes
3.4Inputs - External Systems
3.5Inputs - Predecessor Charge Codes or Pre-calculations
3.6CAISO Formula
3.7Outputs
4.Charge Code Effective Date
CAISO, 2018 / Page 1 of 9Settlements & Billing / Version: 5.0
Technical Documentation for: CC 7876Monthly CPM Collective Deficiency Settlement / Date: 1/12/11
1.Purpose of Document
The purpose of this document is to capture the requirements and design specification for a Charge Code in one document.
2.Introduction
2.1Background
The Capacity Procurement Mechanism (CPM) provides an orderly, pre-approved means for the CAISO to procure backstop capacity where and when needed to meet Reliability Criteria or otherwise maintain reliable grid operations.
Although RA programs are in place under California law, and RA requirements have been established by Local Regulatory Authorities, there may be instances when RA Resources are not sufficient to meet all of the operational needs of the ISO and enable it to meet reliability criteria. This may occur as a result of LSEs failing to comply with RA requirements, LSEs procuring sufficient resources to meet their RA requirements established by Local Regulatory Authorities, but not meeting all of the ISO’s specific reliability needs, and unforeseen or changed circumstances affecting system conditions or grid operations. The ISO must have the appropriate tools at its disposal under such circumstances to maintain reliable operations. In particular, the ISO needs the ability to procure resources when such instances occur in order to maintain the reliability of the CAISO Balancing Authority Area. The Interim Capacity Procurement Mechanism (ICPM) has provided that ability and, therefore, the ISO is retaining the key features of the ICPM in conjunction with a few key modifications that will enhance the program.
In reviewing the performance of both the ICPM and the ISO’s new market systemover the first 18 months of their operation, the ISO has come to two key conclusions –(i) the ICPM has operated effectively and successfully in fulfilling its intended purpose, and (ii) the need for a backstop capacity procurement mechanism continues to exist.
While the use of ICPM has been rather limited, thepotential circumstances and needs that motivated its implementation are stillrelevant today. Moreover, given the significant operational requirements facing the ISOin the near future as a result of the integration of large amounts of variable energyresources, not seeking the continuation of someequally-effective type of backstop capacity procurement mechanism would be irresponsible. In order to assureits ability to operate the system reliably under diverse system conditions, the ISO musthave both a backstop capacity procurement mechanism comparable to ICPM and anExceptional Dispatch mechanism as permanent features of its market and operatingstructure. As variable energyresources that are on line increase, they will comprise a greater proportion of LSEs’ RA
capacity and load-serving capacity.. Since variable energy resources’ qualifying capacity is unpredictable due to several inherent constraints (e.g., weather conditions), they may be unable to provide their full RA capacity, which, in turn, could adversely impact system reliability. A backstopcapacity procurement mechanism enables the ISO to procure specific capacity neededin response to outages in order to maintain the ISO’s compliance with applicable
reliability criteria.
In addition to those aspects of ICPM which the ISO intends to retain, the CPM will feature several enhancements:
- A new CPM procurement category for resources at risk of retirement that the ISO has determined will be needed for reliability in the following year;
- The addition of two criteria the ISO can consider in selecting capacity for a CPM designation or Exceptional Dispatch from eligible resources that will allow ISO operators to exercise a preference for non-use-limited over use-limited resources and to consider each resource’s operating characteristics;
- Adjustment of CPM compensation when a CPM resource becomes unavailable during the CPM procurement period due to a maintenance outage;
- An updated price for backstop capacity.
For the methodology for CPM Compensation, the ISO shall use a CPM price of $55/kW-year as established using the CEC’s updated “Comparative Costs of California Central StationElectricity Generation Technologies” study, issued in 2009.
For the CPM Allocation, the existing ISO Tariff Sections 43.7.1 through 43.7.6 establish the method for allocating the costs of CPM capacity payments for each category of CPM designation. The allocation method for each CPM category is as follows:
- For insufficient Local Capacity Area Resources in an annual or a monthly RA Plan, the CPM costs are allocated pro rata to each Scheduling Coordinator for a deficient LSE based on the ratio of that LSE’s deficiency to the deficiency within the TAC area.
- For a collective deficiency of Local Capacity Area Resources in an annual RA Plan, the CPM costs are allocated to all Scheduling Coordinators of LSEs serving load in the TAC area in which the deficient local capacity area was located.
- For insufficient RA resources to comply with an LSE’s annual and monthly demand and reserve margin requirements, the CPM cost allocation is made pro rata to each LSE based on the proportion of its deficiency to the aggregate deficiency.
- For a significant event, Exceptional Dispatch, or resource at risk of retirement CPM, the costs are allocated to all Scheduling Coordinators for LSEs that serve load in the TAC area where the need for the designation arose, based on each Scheduling Coordinator’s percentage of actual load in the TAC area to total load in that area.
2.2Description
The CC 7876 (Monthly CPM Collective Deficiency Settlement) provides for the settlement of CPM Capacity that the CAISO procures in response to all CPM Collective Deficiency. When the CAISO procures CPM for reason of one or more CPM Collective Deficiency, outputs for each Scheduling Coordinator a single total amount (in $) for the payment owed to the Scheduling Coordinator for the CPM that the SC sold to the CAISO over a Trading Month. The CPM amount is associated with all CPM Collective Deficiency, all LSEs that the SC represents, all resources with which the SC has offered to supply the CPM, and all Trading Days of the Trading Month for which the capacity is supplied.
3.Charge Code Requirements
3.1Business Rules
Bus Req ID / Business Rule1.0 / For April 1, 2011, the going-forward cost will reflect $55/kw-year.
1.1 / The CPM amount shall apply to all CPMCollective Deficiency CapacityEvents, all LSEs that the SC represents, all resources with which the SC has offered to supply the CPM, and all Trading Days of the Trading Month for which the capacity is supplied.
1.2 / The configuration shall output the total settlement amount for the CPM procured from the SC.
2.0 / This Charge Code shall provide an output on a monthly basis.
2.1 / This Charge Code shall be billed monthly.
3.0 / CPM Monthly MW Payment is equal to CPM MW * Availability Factor Forced * Monthly Shaping Factor * CPM Price * Pro-rated Planned % * Daily Shaping Factor.
4.0 / A settlement details file shall provide details for each monthly settlement amount.
5.0 / The percentage by which the capacity payment will be prorated must be calculated by taking a ratio of 1) the sum of actual availability capacity, taking into account only planned outages, across all the hours the unit is designated to 2) the CPM Capacity MW * hours the unit is designated
3.2Predecessor Charge Codes
Charge Code/ Pre-Calc NameMetered Demand Over TAC Area And CPM Pre-calculation
3.3Successor Charge Codes
Charge Code/ Pre-calc NameMonthly CPM Collective deficiency AllocationCC7877
3.4Inputs - External Systems
Row # / Variable Name / Description1 / BAMonthlyResourceCPMDailyShapingFactorBrtOUU’m / The actual number of days the resource was designated as CPM Capacity during the Billing Month and available to the CAISO to the total number of days in the Month. By Business Associate B, resource r, resource type t , Exceptional Dispatch Type O during Settlement Billing Period that extends from Bill Period Start Date U’ to Bill Period End Date U for Trading Month m.
2 / BAMonthlyResourceCPMAvailabilityFOFactorBrtOUU’m / The relevant CPM Availability Factor for Forced Outages as determined inaccordance with Appendix F, Schedule 6, By Business Associate B, resource r, resource type t , Exceptional Dispatch Type O during Settlement Billing Period that extends from Bill Period Start Date U’ to Bill Period End Date U for Trading Month m.
3.5Inputs - Predecessor Charge Codes or Pre-calculations
Row # / Variable Name / Predecessor Charge Code/ Pre-calc Configuration / Description1 / BAMonthlyResourceCPMPlannedAvailabilityPercentage BrtOUU’m / Monthly CPM Availability Percentage by Business Associate B, resource r, resource type t , Exceptional Dispatch Type O during Settlement Billing Period that extends from Bill Period Start Date U’ to Bill Period End Date U for Trading Month m.
2 / BAMonthlyResourceCPMCapacityDesignatedQuantity BrtOUU’m / Monthly CPM Capacity MW Designated by Business Associate B, resource r, resource type t , Exceptional Dispatch Type O during Settlement Billing Period that extends from Bill Period Start Date U’ to Bill Period End Date U for Trading Month m.
3 / BAMonthlyResourceCPMCalculatedPriceBrtUU’m / Monthly CPM Capacity Price by Business Associate B, resource r, resource type t , TAC Area v, during Settlement Billing Period that extends from Bill Period Start Date U’ to Bill Period End Date U for Trading Month m.
3.6CAISO Formula
The Monthly settlement of CPM for each Business Associate is derived according to the formulation below.
3.6.1BAMonthlyCPMColDefCapacitySettlementAmountBUU’m= BAMonthlyTotalCPMColDefCapacitySettlementAmountBOUU’m
3.6.2BAMonthlyTotalCPMColDefCapacitySettlementAmountBOUU’m = BAMonthlyResourceCPMColDefCapacitySettlementAmountBrtOUU’m
3.6.2.1CAISOMonthlyCPMColDefCapacitySettlementAmountUU’m= CAISOMonthlyTotalCPMColDefCapacitySettlementAmountOUU’m
3.6.2.2CAISOMonthlyTotalCPMColDefCapacitySettlementAmountOUU’m = BAMonthlyTotalCPMColDefCapacitySettlementAmountBOUU’m
3.6.3BAMonthlyResourceCPMColDefCapacitySettlementAmountBrtOUU’m= (-1)* BAMonthlyResourceCPMCapacityDesignatedQuantity BrtOUU’m *BAMonthlyResourceCPMAvailabilityFOFactorBrtOUU’m*BAMonthlyResourceCPMCalculatedPriceBrtUU’m*BAMonthlyResourceCPMDailyShapingFactorBrtOUU’m*BAMonthlyResourceCPMPlannedAvailabilityPercentage BrtOUU’m
Where Exceptional Dispatch Type O in (COLDEF1, COLDEF2, COLDEF3)
3.7Outputs
Output Req ID / Name / Description1 / In addition to any outputs listed below, all inputs shall be included as outputs. / All inputs
2 / BAMonthlyTotalCPMColDefCapacitySettlementAmount BOUU’m / Total CMP monthly payment for Business Associate B, Exceptional Dispatch Type O during Settlement Billing Period that extends from Bill Period Start Date U’ to Bill Period End Date U for Trading Month m
3 / BAMonthlyResourceCPMColDefCapacitySettlementAmount BrtOUU’m / CMP monthly payment for Business Associate B, resource r, resource type t , byExceptional Dispatch Type O during Settlement Billing Period that extends from Bill Period Start Date U’ to Bill Period End Date U for Trading Month m
4 / CAISOMonthlyTotalCPMColDefCapacitySettlementAmountOUU’m / CAISO Total CMP monthly payment for Business Associate B, Exceptional Dispatch Type O during Settlement Billing Period that extends from Bill Period Start Date U’ to Bill Period End Date U for Trading Month m
5 / BAMonthlyCPMColDefCapacitySettlementAmount BUU’m / Monthly CMP payment for Business Associate B, during Settlement Billing Period that extends from Bill Period Start Date U’ to Bill Period End Date U for Trading Month m
6 / CAISOMonthlyCPMColDefCapacitySettlementAmountUU’m / Monthly CAISO CMP monthly payment for Business Associate B, during Settlement Billing Period that extends from Bill Period Start Date U’ to Bill Period End Date U for Trading Month m
4.Charge CodeEffective Date
Charge Code/Pre-calc Name / Document Version / Effective Start Date / Effective End Date / Version Update Type
CC 7876 – Monthly CPM Collective deficiency Settlement / 5.0 / 04/01/11 / Open / Configuration Impacted
CAISO, 2018 / Page 1 of 9