1
Marsbugs: The Electronic Astrobiology Newsletter, Volume 12, Number 27, 3 August 2005
Marsbugs: The Electronic Astrobiology Newsletter
Volume 12, Number 27, 3 August 2005
Editor/Publisher: David J. Thomas, Ph.D., Science Division, LyonCollege, Batesville, Arkansas72503-2317, USA.
Marsbugs is published on a weekly to monthly basis as warranted by the number of articles and announcements. Copyright of this compilation exists with the editor, but individual authors retain the copyright of specific articles. Opinions expressed in this newsletter are those of the authors, and are not necessarily endorsed by the editor or by LyonCollege. E-mail subscriptions are free, and may be obtained by contacting the editor. Information concerning the scope of this newsletter, subscription formats and availability of back-issues is available at The editor does not condone "spamming" of subscribers. Readers would appreciate it if others would not send unsolicited e-mail using the Marsbugs mailing lists. Persons who have information that may be of interest to subscribers of Marsbugs should send that information to the editor.
1
Marsbugs: The Electronic Astrobiology Newsletter, Volume 12, Number 27, 3 August 2005
Articles and News
Page 1NEW MEASURES NEEDED TO KEEP NASA SPACECRAFT FROM CONTAMINATING MARS
National Academies release
Page 2OXYGEN PARADOX RESEARCH TO BE PRESENTED AT GEOLOGICAL CONFERENCE
By Eric Ramirez
Page 2JAPAN RESEARCHERS TO BE SEALED IN "MINI-EARTH" TO PLAN FOR SPACE LIFE
From Agence France-Presse and SpaceDaily
Page 2MYSTERY METHANE MAKER WANTED DEAD OR ALIVE
By David Tenenbaum
Page 3LOOKING FOR LIFE ON MARS IN AUSTRALIA'S OUTBACK
From Agence France-Presse and SpaceDaily
Page 4SCIENTISTS GIVE BOOST TO CLIMATE CHANGE PREDICTIONS
Massachusetts Institute of Technology release
Page 4NASA DEVELOPS A NUGGET TO SEARCH FOR LIFE IN SPACE
NASA feature
Page 5SPITZER FINDS LIFE COMPONENTS IN YOUNG UNIVERSE
NASA/JPL release 2005-123
Page 6BIG POSSIBILITIES FOR SMALL STARS
By Peter Backus
Page 6NASA SCIENTISTS DISCOVER TENTH PLANET
NASA release 05-209
Page 7PIONEER ASTRONAUTICS DEMONSTRATES A NEW TECHNOLOGY FOR FLYING AROUND MARS
Pioneer Astronautics release
Page 8PROVING THE CASE: IS METHANE THE FIRST DIRECT SIGN OF EXTRA-TERRESTRIAL LIFE?
By David Tenenbaum
Page 9EVOLUTIONARY ACCIDENT PROBABLY CAUSED THE WORST SNOWBALL EARTH EPISODE, STUDY SHOWS
California Institute of Technology release
Page 10MARS, THE BLUE ECOSYNTHESIS
Based on drawings and image commentary by Thierry Lombry
Announcements
Page 11NASA ASTROBIOLOGY INSTITUTE COOPERATIVE AGREEMENT NOTICE (CYCLE-4)
NAI release
Page 11GRIFFIN RIGHT HAND MAN TO SPEAK AT MARS SOCIETY CONVENTION
Mars Society release
Mission Reports
Page 11CASSINI UPDATES
NASA/JPL releases
Page 15MARS EXPLORATION ROVERS UPDATE
NASA/JPL release
Page 15MARS EXPRESS: WATER ICE IN A CRATER AT THE MARTIAN NORTH POLE
ESA release
Page 16MARS GLOBAL SURVEYOR IMAGES
NASA/JPL/MSSS release
Page 16MARS ODYSSEY THEMIS IMAGES
NASA/JPL/ASU release
Page 16MARS RECONNAISSANCE ORBITER UPDATES
Multiple agencies' releases
1
Marsbugs: The Electronic Astrobiology Newsletter, Volume 12, Number 27, 3 August 2005
1
Marsbugs: The Electronic Astrobiology Newsletter, Volume 12, Number 27, 3 August 2005
NEW MEASURES NEEDED TO KEEP NASA SPACECRAFT FROM CONTAMINATING MARS
National Academies release
25 July 2005
Over the coming decade, NASA should develop and implement new methods and requirements to detect and eliminate microorganisms on robotic spacecraft sent to Mars to prevent possible contamination of the planet, says a new report from the National Academies' National Research Council. If microbes aboard a spacecraft were to survive the trip to Mars and grow there, they could interfere with scientific investigations to detect any life that might be native to Mars. Existing techniques for cleaning spacecraft are outdated and typically eliminate only a fraction of microorganisms, said the committee that wrote the report.
Recent scientific findings suggest that liquid water could be present at many locations on Mars and that some organisms on Earth might survive in extreme, Mars-like conditions—such as very low temperatures and high salt concentrations. These discoveries have bolstered the case that Mars could be—or have been—hospitable to life and have created urgency to update policies and practices to prevent Mars contamination, the report says.
"Ongoing Mars missions have shown that the planet may have environments where some Earth microbes could grow," said Christopher F. Chyba, committee chair and professor of astrophysics and international affairs at PrincetonUniversity, Princeton, NJ. "Although we don't know for sure if this could happen, we need to understand whether liquid water exists in Martian near-surface environments, as well as the nature of microorganisms that are in our clean rooms and spacecraft. It will take a while to carry out the needed research and development, so we need to start in earnest now."
NASA currently uses screening techniques that detect heat-resistant and spore-forming bacteria on spacecraft and then reduces their numbers by cleaning the spacecraft and, in certain circumstances, baking components with dry heat. But these screening methods are not designed to give a comprehensive tally of the microbes present on the spacecraft, and dry heat can be applied only to spacecraft materials that can withstand high temperatures, the report notes.
NASA should sponsor new research efforts aimed at preventing Mars contamination, the committee said, such as new techniques for detecting biological molecules that do not require time for growing laboratory cultures and could speed spacecraft sterilization and assembly in clean rooms. Also, methods that determine genetic sequences of organisms and link them to known microbial species could allow NASA to tailor sterilization techniques toward spacecraft contaminants of greatest concern. NASA should also investigate alternative cleaning methods—such as the use of radiation or vapor disinfectants—for their effectiveness in killing different types of microorganisms and for their effects on various spacecraft materials.
NASA should develop a certification process to compare detection and cleaning methods and select the most promising ones, begin testing and validating improved techniques within the next three years, and fully implement selected new techniques in time for spacecraft to launch in 2016. Until NASA conducts the research needed to transition to a modern approach for planetary protection, the agency should apply more stringent sterilization levels to all Mars landing spacecraft, the committee said. An independent review panel should be created by NASA and meet every three years to review new knowledge about the Martian environment and recommend updates, as needed, to Mars protection requirements.
The study was sponsored by NASA. The National Research Council is the principal operating arm of the National Academy of Sciences and the National Academy of Engineering. It is a private, nonprofit institution that provide science and technology advice under a congressional charter.
Copies of Preventing the Forward Contamination of Mars will be available this fall from the National Academies Press; phone: 202-334-3313 or 1-800-624-6242 or order on the Internet at Read the report online at Reporters may obtain a pre-publication copy from the Office of News and Public Information (contacts listed below).
Contacts:
Patrice Pages, Media Relations Officer
Michelle Strikowsky, Media Relations Assistant
Office of News and Public Information
Phone: 202-334-2138
E-mail:
OXYGEN PARADOX RESEARCH TO BE PRESENTED AT GEOLOGICAL CONFERENCE
By Eric Ramirez
LyonCollege release
25 July 2005
Dr. David J. Thomas, associate professor of biology at LyonCollege, has been invited to share research at an upcoming conference for geoscientists, Earth System Processes 2. The Geological Society of America and the Geological Association of Canada are organizing the meeting. Earth System Processes 2 will be held August 11 in Calgary, Alberta, Canada. Approximately 350 geoscientists are expected to attend.
Dr. Thomas' research covers a topic known as the "Oxygen Paradox." The paradox states that photosynthetic organisms would need antioxidant systems to protect them. So, according to the paradox, it would be necessary for photosynthesis and antioxidant systems to evolve together. Antioxidants are important to all oxygen-using life because some by-products of using oxygen, called free radicals, are harmful and cause cellular breakdown. Which leads to the real question behind all of this:Which came first?
"It's a chicken or the egg type problem?"Dr. Thomas said. Thomas tested two different organisms under an environment and atmosphere similar to primordial Earth and his results yielded that photosynthesis might have evolved first.
This all began in 1995 when Dr. Thomas was working with antioxidants for his dissertation. The Oxygen Paradox had been posed sometime between the late '70s and early '80s. His current research started over a year ago when Dr. Thomas received a grant from the NASA/Arkansas Space Grant Consortium. Lyon students who have helped with the research include CaSandra Spurlock and Christy Schuchardt, both of whom graduated from Lyon this year, as well as John Boling and Tiffany McSpadden, two undergraduate students at Lyon.
"I know that I don't want to do this for a career, but I certainly know how to grow bacteria," said Tiffany McSpadden, who was busy moving test tubes into the refrigerator.
Dr. Thomas' research tells a lot about early life on Earth. According to Thomas, "We take photosynthesis for granted. The first organisms to photosynthesize were actually poisoning nearby organisms."
And what about other planets? He remembered talking with Dr. Julian Hiscox from the University of Leeds in England and discussing what kind of characteristics a martian microbe would need to survive on Mars. Thomas said that the surface of Mars was highly oxidized, much like rust, and that in order for anything to live on Mars it would require "very robust antioxidant systems."
All of Dr. Thomas' research was performed at the laboratories in the new DerbyCenter at LyonCollege. Thomas pointed out that one of the greater things about LyonCollege is that post-graduate students can do significant research.
Read the original news release at
JAPAN RESEARCHERS TO BE SEALED IN "MINI-EARTH" TO PLAN FOR SPACE LIFE
From Agence France-Presse and SpaceDaily
26 July 2005
Japanese researchers said Tuesday they would seal themselves in a "mini-Earth" in an experiment in self-sufficiency to plan for future life in space. Two researchers will spend one week in the controlled ecosystem at Rokkasho in the northern prefecture of Aomori, growing plants such as rice, breeding goats and recycling their water, oxygen and excreta. Apart from the goats, the researchers will be completely on their own, save for outside energy and the Internet. The facility to be set up by the Institute for Environmental Sciences will be 500 square meters (5,380 square feet) with separate spaces for the humans, animals and plants.
Read the full article at
MYSTERY METHANE MAKER WANTED DEAD OR ALIVE
By David Tenenbaum
From Astrobiology Magazine
27 July 2005
The detections of methane in the martian atmosphere have challenged scientists to find a source for the gas, which is usually associated with life on Earth. One source that can be ruled out is ancient history: methane can survive only 600 years in the martian atmosphere before sunlight will destroy it. If the global concentration of methane on Mars is 10 ppb, then an average of 4 grams of methane is being destroyed every second by sunlight. That means about 126 metric tons of methane must be produced each year to ensure a steady concentration of 10 ppb.
There is an outside chance that the methane is being delivered to Mars by comets, asteroids, or other debris from space. Calculations show that micrometeorites are likely to deliver only 1 kilogram of methane a year—far short of the 126-ton replacement level. Comets could deliver a huge slug of methane, but the interval between major comet impacts averages 62 million years, so it's unlikely that any comet delivered methane within the past 600 years.
If we can rule out methane delivery, then the methane must be manufactured on Mars. But is the source biology, or processes unassociated with life?
In hot water?
A small percentage of Earth's methane is made through non-biological ("abiogenic") interactions between carbon dioxide, hot water and certain rocks. Could this be occurring on Mars? Perhaps, says James Lyons of the Institute for Geophysics and Planetary Physics at UCLA.
These reactions require only rock, water, carbon and heat, but on Mars, where would the heat come from? The planet's surface is stone cold, averaging minus 63 degrees C. Volcanoes could be a source of heat. Geologists think the most recent eruption on Mars was at least 1 million years ago—recent enough to suggest that Mars is still active, and therefore hot deep below the surface.
A trickle of methane averaging 4 grams per second could come from such a geological hot spot. But any martian hot spot must be deep and well-insulated from the surface, since the Thermal Emission Imaging System on Mars Odyssey found no locations that are at least 15 degrees C warmer than the surroundings. However, Lyons thinks it's still possible that a deep body of magma could be supplying the heat.
In one computer model of simplified martian geology, a cooling body of magma 10 kilometers deep, 1 kilometer wide, and 10 kilometers long created the 375 to 450 degrees C temperature that drives abiogenic methane generation at mid-ocean ridges on Earth. Such a body of hot rock, Lyons says, "is perfectly sensible, there's nothing strange about it," because Mars probably retains some heat from planetary formation, much like Earth.
"It encourages us to think that this is a plausible scenario for explaining methane on Mars, and we would not see the signature of that dike (body of hot rock) on the surface," says Lyons. "That's the angle we are pursuing; it's the simplest, most direct explanation for the methane detected."
Past the looking glass
Although no one can rule out abiogenic sources for the methane on Mars, when you find methane on Earth, you are usually seeing the work of methanogens, ancient anaerobic microbes that process carbon and hydrogen into methane. Could methanogens live on Mars?
To find out, Timothy Kral, associate professor of biological sciences at the University of Arkansas, began growing five types of methanogens 12 years ago in volcanic soil chosen to simulate martian soil. He's now shown that methanogens can survive for years on the granular, low-nutrient soil, although when grown in Mars-like conditions, at just 2 percent of Earth's atmospheric pressure, they become desiccated and go dormant after a couple of weeks.
"The soil tends to dry out, and we have been able to find viable cells; they are still alive, but they don't produce methane anymore," Kral says.
Methanogens need a steady source of carbon dioxide and hydrogen. While carbon dioxide is abundant on Mars, "hydrogen is a question mark," Kral says.
Vladimir Krasnopolsky, a research professor at Catholic University of America in WashingtonDC, detected 15 parts per million of molecular hydrogen in the atmosphere of Mars. It is possible that this hydrogen is escaping from a deep source in the martian interior which methanogens could use. If methanogens are deep inside Mars, the methane gas they produce would slowly rise toward the surface. Eventually it could reach a pressure-temperature condition where it would get trapped in ice crystals, forming methane hydrate.
"If there were a subsurface biosphere, methane hydrate would be an inevitable consequence, if things behave as they do on Earth," says Stephen Clifford of the Lunar and Planetary Institute in Houston, Texas.
Frost dusts the red plains of southern Mars in early spring. Mars' mean annual temperature is -55 °C. Image credit: MSSS/JPL/NASA.
And there's a fringe benefit, Clifford adds. Methane hydrates, "would be an insulating blanket that would substantially reduce the thickness of frozen ground on Mars, from several kilometers at the equator, to maybe less than a kilometer." In other words, methane hydrate would both store evidence of life and insulate any life that remained from the ultra-cold surface temperatures.
Although data on conditions a kilometer or so below the martian surface are non-existent, the growing picture of the complexity, size and adaptability of Earth's underground biosphere certainly improves the chance that life exists in comparable conditions inside Mars. Earth's underground biosphere is composed largely of microbes, some of which live at depths, pressures and chemical conditions once thought inhospitable to life.
Deep inside Mars may be a hardscrabble place to make a living, but methanogens are no wimps, Kral says. "They are tough, durable. The fact that they have been around probably since the beginning of life on Earth, and continue to be the predominant life form below the surface and deep in the oceans, means they are survivors, they are doing extremely well."
Read the original article at
LOOKING FOR LIFEON MARS IN AUSTRALIA'S OUTBACK
From Agence France-Presse and SpaceDaily
28 July 2005
Australian scientists are planning to build a "space station" in the remote outback to simulate the conditions future human explorers could face on Mars. Mars Society Australia says the station will be the final step in a worldwide experiment which has seen similar projects set up in the Canadian Arctic, the Utah desert and Iceland.
"The idea is that if you have these places around the world, each place has its own unique Mars-like qualities or characteristics," spokeswoman Jennifer Laing told AFP Thursday.
The station, designed to simulate living quarters which could be landed on Mars, will be 36 meters (118 feet) long and include cabins, generators, airlocks and docking hatches plus a garage to house a "rover" to explore the surrounding area.
SCIENTISTS GIVE BOOST TO CLIMATE CHANGE PREDICTIONS
Massachusetts Institute of Technology release