The Review of THE article for THe periodical journal “Sjani”

Year/Month/Date

Author(s) of the article ......

......

Title of the article......

......

Date of submission of the article ......

Review

The title of the article reveals the focus of the issue / acceptable
needs improvement
The statement of theaim(s)of the article / acceptable
needs improvement
The presence of the analysis of the existing approaches to the research issue / acceptable
needs improvement
The author demonstrates awareness of the most recent analysis of the problem in international literature / acceptable
needs improvement
The identification of the research issue / acceptable
needs improvement
The degree of topicality of the research issue / acceptable
needs improvement
The choise of the research methods / acceptable
needs improvement
The focus of the article stays on the aim(s) declared at the introduction / acceptable
needs improvement
The conclusions follow the research method(s) logically / acceptable
need improvement
The conclusions and/or recommendations are related to the aim(s) of the article. / acceptable
need improvement
Citaton requirements are observed / accurate
need improvement
The keywords, the abstract and the summary reveal the scope of the article / acceptable
need improvement

Additional comments and suggestions for improvement:

......

The final conclusion of the reviewer

The article is recommended to be published in “Sjani” without further amendments.

The article is recommended to be published in “Sjani” with some minor amendments.

The article is recommended to be published in “Sjani” after substantial amendments.

The article is not recommended to be published in “Sjani”.

The article is recommended for publication in a different research paper/ journal (identify the title)…………………………………………………………………………………………………………..

______

(Reviewer’s name, last name, signature)

______

(Academic degree)

______

(Institution of employment)

______

(Position)

______

(Tel./fax.)

______

(Email)

*information on the reviewer is confidential and shall not be disclosed to the author of the reviewed article.

**the completed form should be submitted to theEditor Prof. Irma Ratiani by email: