Corrections:
-Year-by-Year results, 1894 has a typo and reads 1984
-1904 Colgate vs Colgate Academy score was 24-0, not 22-0:
-In the letter winners section F. Gorham Brigham says: 1901-92-03-04. 92 should be changed to 02.
-1900 game is listed as being vs Cortland St, but technically they were known as Cortland Normal at the time:
-The 2nd game vs Colgate Academy in 1900 was a 6-0 loss, not a 6-0 win. The Madisonensis article written after the game reports it as a 6-0 win for the Academy while the Salmagundi reports it as a 6-0 win for Colgate. The October 13, 1900 edition of the Rochester Democrat and Chronicle confirms that it was a loss for Colgate. This changes Colgate’s record in 1900 from 3-7 to 2-8. This also changes every milestone win (100th, 200th, 300th, etc.):
-Colgate defeated Colgate Academy 11-0 in 1899 (2nd game of the season). The game was not previously included in the record book. Makes the 1899 team’s record 4-5 instead of 3-5:
-Colgate tied Hamilton 6-6 on October 1, 1898 in a previously unreported game. This makes Colgate record for 1898 2-5-1:
-Not sure if you want to designate the 1897 victory over Union as a forfeit:
-1896 win over Hobart was also a forfeit:
-Colgate tied Hamilton 0-0 in 1893 in a disputed game. If counted, this would make Colgate’s record for 1893 3-0-2:
-Colgate game against Union in 1893 was away:
-Colgate game against Syracuse A.A. in 1893 was away:
-1893 Team Captain was Fayette S. Munro in addition to L. Jay Caldwell
-Letterwinners section: Not sure if it is Henry Sante. Everything I have found lists his name as Everett Sante
-Longest field goal section: Jonah Bowman’s name is spelled Jonas
-Marty McDonough is listed as having an 80 yd TD run vs Syracuse in 1933, but it was actually an 80 yd punt return for a TD
-Len Macaluso is listed as scoring 145 points in 1930, but I can only find evidence of 144 points.
-1932 game was vs Mississippi College, not Mississippi A&M
-1929 game was vs Hampden-Sydney, not Hampden-Sidney
Additions:
-Frank Clesson Taylor won a varsity letter in 1904 before dying in 1905. He is not listed in the Salmagundi as a letter winner, but that could be because he had already passed away. Taylor is listed in the box score of 5 of the 10 games which leads me to believe he was a letter winner:
-Longest kickoff return section: Carl Smith – 80yds (TD) vs St. Lawrence 1903:
-Longest fumble return section: Harry C. Buck – 75yds (TD) vs St. John’s Academy 1899:
-Longest scrimmage run section: George Embody – 95yds (TD) vs Union 1899
- Note: Field length was 110 yards
-Longest scrimmage run section: Leon Waite – 80yds (TD) vs St. John’s Academy 1898
-Most extra points made in a game section: (tied) Fayette Munro – 8 vs Syracuse 1893
-Most extra points attempted in a game: Fayette Munro – 10 vs Syracuse 1893
-Longest kick return section: Glen Treichler – 90yds (TD) vs Syracuse 1944
-Longest passing play section: Robert Behrens to Glen Treichler – 77yds (TD) vs Syracuse 1944
-Longest punt individual record and longest punt section: Joe Hoague – 86yds vs Cornell 1940
-Longest punt return section: Thomas Dowler – 65 yds (TD) vs Michigan State 1928
-Longest kickoff return section: Edward Tryon – 85 yds (TD) vs St. Bonaventure 1925
-Longest kickoff return section: Edward Tryon – 85 yds (TD) vs St. Bonaventure 1925
- Also makes single game team record 2 kickoff returns for TD
- Also makes single game individual record 2 kickoff returns for TD
- Tryon had 5 career kickoff returns for TD from 1922-1925
-Longest kickoff return section: Edward Tryon – 85 yds (no TD) vs Providence 1924
-Longest punt return section: Edward Tryon – 75 yds (TD) vs Clarkson 1922
-200 yard rush game: Edward Tryon – 210 yds vs Clarkson 1925
-Single game rushing record: Edward Tryon – 295 yds vs Providence 1924
-Longest kickoff return section: Robert Webster – 90 yds (TD) vs Cornell 1920
-Most punt returns for TD in one game: Robert Webster – 2 vs Columbia 1921
-Thomas Andrews lettered for the 1920 football team