Minutes of 150th Meeting of NRC held on 09th – 11th October, 2009
MINUTES OF 150TH MEETING OF NORTHERN REGIONAL COMMITTEE HELD ON 09THto11TH OCTOBER, 2009
The 150th meeting of the Northern Regional Committee (NRC), National Council for Teacher Education (NCTE) was held from 09thto 11th October, 2009 at Jaipur. The following members and convener were present:
Prof. U. C. Vashishtha / Member, NRC-NCTE – Presided the meetingProf. M.P. Sharma / Member, NRC-NCTE (on 9th10th October, 2009)
Prof. Bharti Baweja / Member, NRC-NCTE (on 10th October, 2009)
Dr. R.S. Barar / Representative of the UT Chandigarh
Dr. S.P. Singh / Representative of the Haryana (On 10th11th October, 2009)
Dr. K.S. Yadav / Convener RD, NRC, NCTE
Prof. D.N. Sansanwal, Prof. F. U. Khan, Prof. S. P. Anand, Prof. M.K. Das, Prof. M.P. Sharma (on 11th October,2009) and Prof. Bharti Baweja (on 09th11thOctober 2009) could not attend the meeting. Since the quorum was not complete, the meeting was adjourned for half an hour, from 10.00 A.M. to 10.30 A.M. The meeting started at 10.30. A.M.
Dr. K.S. Yadav , Convener RD, NRC, NCTE welcomed the Hon’ble Chairperson and members of Northern Regional Committee.
With the permission of the officiating Chairperson, Dr. K.S. Yadav (Convener) presented the Agenda before the Committee. Agenda-wise decisions taken were as follows:-
SL. NO. / AGENDA NO. / CASES / DECISION OF NRC1 / 150.01. / CONFIRMATION OF THE MINUTES OF THE 149TH MEETING OF NRC. THE MINUTES OF 149TH MEETING OF NRC HELD ON 13th to 14th SEPTEMBER 2009 HAVE BEEN UPLOADED ON THE WEBSITE OF NRC. / Minutes are confirmed with the following corrections:
(i)In item No. 149.03.00.2 of minutes, the following point may be added:-
As per the directions of Hon’ble High Court, six months time may be given to the institution to get the sale deed registered in the name of the institution.
(ii) In item No. 149.04.00.6 of minutes, the institution name may be read as LATE DILEEP KUMAR SMARAK MAHAVIDYALAYA, KORA JAHANABAD, TEHSIL-BINDKI, FATEHPUR, U.P.
in place of DILEEP KUMAR SMARAK MAHAVIDYALAYA, KORA JAHANABAD, TEHSIL-BINDKI, FATEHPUR, U.P.
AGENDA ITEM NO: 150.02.00 CONSIDERATION OF APPEAL ORDERS
SL.No. / Agenda No. / Name of the Institution / Appeal Order / Appeal Decision / Decision of NRC2 / 1 / AKALCOLLEGE OF PHYSICAL EDUCATION, GURSAGAR MASTUANA SAHIB, TEHSIL + DISTRICT- SANGRUR, PUNJAB.
PB-314, COURSE- B.P.ED / F.No. 89-449/2009- Appeal A2191/ Dated 11.09.2009 / Remand the case to NRC for examination of the staff profile and thereafter pass appropriate orders. Accordingly the case was remanded to NRC. / The original file of the institution, VTR along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee observes the following:
- Nomination letter from the University for VC’s nominees is not available.
- Affidavit contents were covered with an ordinary paper containing some information, which is not acceptable. A fresh affidavit regarding staff is needed.
3 / 2 / NEELAM COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, VILL- JAMJIMA, POST- BUL, TEHSIL- JOGINDER NAGAR, DISTRICT- MANDI, HIMACHAL PRADESH.
HP-301, COURSE- B.ED / F.No. 89-652/2009- Appeal A2175/ Dated 11.09.2009 / Remand the case to NRC for Causing inspection of the institution to ascertain the availability of infrastructure and instructional facilities as per NCTE norms and thereafter pass appropriate order. Accordingly, the case was remanded to NRC. / NCTE Hqrs. Appeal order noted. NRC to comply with. Inspection of the institution recommended to ascertain the availability of infrastructural and instructional facilities as per NCTE norms.
4 / 3 / ARYANS COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, VILL- NEPRA, CHANDIGARH- PATIALA HIGHWAY, NEAR BANUR, TEHSIL- RAJPURA, DISTRICT- PATIALA, PUNJAB.
PB-604, COURSE- B.ED / F.No. 89-645/2009- Appeal A2123/ Dated 11.09.2009 / Remand the case to NRC for causing inspection of the institution to ascertain the availability of staff in particular and other facilities as per NCTE norms and thereafter pass appropriate order. Accordingly, the case was remanded back. / NCTE Hqrs. Appeal order noted. NRC to comply with. Inspection of the institution recommended to ascertain the availability of staff in particular and other facilities as per NCTE norms.
5 / 4 / MAHARAJA RANJIT SINGH COLLEGE, VPO- PIND MALOUT, TEHSIL- MALOUT, DISTRICT- MUKTSAR, PUNJAB.
PB-645, COURSE- C.P.ED. / F.No. 89-626/2009- Appeal A2051/ Dated 11.09.2009 / The appeal was accepted and case was remanded to NRC for causing inspection of the institution, to ascertain it readiness to offer in the course in terms of infrastructural and institutional facilities as per NCTE norms. / NCTE Hqrs. Appeal order noted. NRC to comply with. Inspection of the institution recommended to ascertain readiness to offer in the course in terms of infrastructural and instructional facilities as per NCTE norms.
6 / 5 / SANT BABA BHAG SINGH MEMORIAL GIRLS COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, VPO- SUKHANAND, TEHSIL- BAGHA PURANA, DISTRICT- MOGA, PUNJAB.
PB-506, COURSE- ETT / F.No. 89-702/2009- Appeal A2279/ Dated 11.09.2009 / Remand the case to NRC for examination of staff profile, after obtaining the same from the institution and thereafter pass appropriate orders, in continuation to the earlier order dated 09.08.2008 / NCTE Hqrs. Appeal order noted. NRC to comply with. The Committee observes the following deficiency:
- Documents related to appointment of faculty not submitted
7 / 6 / SHARAN COLLEGE OF EDUCATION FOR WOMEN, VPO- GHURKARI, TEHSIL- KANGRA, DISTRICT- KANGRA, HIMACHAL PRADESH.
HP-308, COURSE- JBT ADD INTAKE / F.No. 89-631/2009- Appeal A2103/ Dated 11.09.2009 / Remand the case to NRC for consideration of the case on merit after obtaining a reply from the institution towards the show cause notice. / NCTE Hqrs. Appeal order noted. NRC to comply with. The Committee observes the following deficiency:
- Building plan approved by competent authority not submitted.
8 / 7 / MODERN COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, VILL- RANWAN, POST- KHANPUR, TEHSIL- MALERKOTLA, DISTRICT- SANGRUR-148023, PUNJAB.
PB-338, COURSE- B.ED / F.No. 89-686/2009- Appeal A2263/ Dated 11.09.2009 / Remand the case to NRC for examination of the staff profile and thereafter pass appropriate orders. Accordingly, the case was remanded to NRC. / NCTE Hqrs. Appeal order noted. NRC to comply with.
The original file of the institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee decides to issue letter under 7(11) of Regulations, 2007.
9 / 8 / PARMAR COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, VILL- KAILASH NAGAR, NEAR BENEHRA, POST- BENEHRA, TEHSIL- AMB, DISTRICT- UNA, HIMACHAL PRADESH.
HP-281, COURSE- B.ED / F.No. 89-444/2009- Appeal A2083/ Dated 11.09.2009 / The Appeal was rejected and NRC’s order dated 28.05.2009 was confirmed. / NCTE Hqrs. Appeal order noted.
10 / 9 / SHAHEED UDHAM SINGH TEACHER TRAINING INSTITUTION, VPO- MEHLAN CHOWK, TEHSIL- SUNAM, DISTRICT- SANGRUR, PUNJAB.
PB-479, COURSE- ETT / F.No. 89-708/2009- Appeal A2287/ Dated 11.09.2009 / The Appeal was rejected and NRC’s order dated 04.06.2009 was confirmed. / NCTE Hqrs. Appeal order noted.
11 / 10 / RIMT- COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, VPO- MANDI GOBINDGARH, TEHSIL- AMLOH, DISTRICT- FATEHGARH SAHIB, PUNJAB.
PB-671, COURSE- M.ED / F.No. 89-612/2009- Appeal A2095/ Dated 11.09.2009 / The Appeal was rejected and NRC’s order dated 10.06.2009 was confirmed. / NCTE Hqrs. Appeal order noted.
12 / 11 / BRIGHTLANDCOLLEGE OF EDUCATION, REWARI, DISTRICT – HARYANA.
HR-1100, COURSE – B.ED. / F.No. 89- 716/2009- Appeal, dated – 08.10.2009 / Theremand back the case to NRC for deciding the case on merit with 15 days of issue of this order. / The NRC has examined the case thoroughly and is of the opinion that the recognition may not be granted.
13 / 12 / LORD KRISHNA COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, HISSAR, HARYANA. HR – 1731, COURSE – B.ED. / F.No.89-475/2009- Appeal, dated – 04.09.2009. / Theremand backs the case to NRC for inspection of the institution immediately. / Appeal order noted. NRC to comply with.
The original file of the institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committeedecides to conduct inspection.
14 / 13 / BABU JAI SHANKAR GAYA PRASAD MAHAVIDYALAYA, UNNAO, UP
UP-2971, COURSE- B.ED. / F.No. 89-848/2009- Appeal/ Dated 08.10.2009 / Accept the Appeal and remand back the case to NRC for furthers processing the case for causing inspection of the institution to ascertain the availability of adequate infrastructural and other facilities as per NCTE Norms within one month of issue of this order and thereafter pass appropriate order. Accordingly the case was remanded back to NRC. / Appeal order noted. NRC to comply with.
The original file of the institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committeedecides to conduct inspection.
15 / 14 / NANDKISHORESINGHDEGREECOLLEGE, ALLAHABAD, UP
UP-2862, COURSE-B.ED. / F.No. 89-779/2009- Appeal/ Dated 08.10.2009 / The appeal was accepted and NRC’s order dated 10.06.09 was set – aside with the direction that VT report of the institution be placed before NRC for deciding the matter on merit / Appeal order noted. NRC to comply with.
The original file of the institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee observes the following:
- All labs. are ill-equipped
- All labs. without furniture
- Language lab. not developed
- Play ground not developed
- 1000 titles not there
- Website not functioning
16 / 15 / MANNIYA KANSHI RAM COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, BULANDSHAHAR, UP
UP-3041 COURSE – B.ED. / F.No. 89-730/2009- Appeal/ Dated 08.10.2009 / The appeal was accepted and NRC’s order dt. 31.8.09 was reversed. / Appeal order noted. NRC to comply with.
17 / 16 / G.S. MAHAVIDYALAYA, BASTI, U.P.
UP-3035, COURSE-B.ED. / F.No. 89-931/2009- Appeal/ Dated 08.10.2009 / The appeal was accepted, NRC’s decision dated 12.07.2009 to 14.07.2009 was set aside and the case was remanded to the NRC for further necessary action. / Appeal order noted. NRC to comply with.
The original file of the institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committeedecides to issue letter under clause 7(9) of Regulations 2007.
18 / 17 / SHRIP.L.MEMORIALDEGREECOLLEGE, BARABANKI, U.P.
UP-2672, COURSE-BTC / F.No. 89-650/2009- Appeal/ A- 2211 Dated 11.09.2009 / The appeal was accepted and NRC’s decision dated 22nd – 24th May 2009 was set aside. / Appeal order noted. NRC to comply with.
The original file of the institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committeedecides to issue letter under clause 7(9) of Regulations 2007.
19 / 18 / B.L. ACADEMY OF HIGHER EDUCATION, MEERUT, U.P.
UP-3185, COURSE- B.ED / F.No. 89-664/2009- Appeal/ A- 2131 Dated 11.09.2009 / Accept the Appeal, set aside NRC’s decision dated 27th to 29th June, 2009 and remanded the case to NRC for causing inspection the institution to ascertain the availability of staff in particular and other facilities as per NCTE norms and thereafter pass appropriate order. Accordingly, the case was remanded to NRC. / Appeal order noted. NRC to comply with.
The original file of the institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committeedecides to conduct inspection.
AGENDA ITEM NO 150.03.00CONSIDERATION OF THE COURT CASE - NIL
AGENDA ITEM NO 150.04.00CONSIDERATION OF THE REPLIES RECEIVED FOR CONVERSION FROM 7(9) TO 7(11).
SL. NO. / AGENDA NO. / BRIEF DESCRIPTION / COURSE / FILE NO. / DECISION OF NRC20 / R.B.S. COLLEGE, KHASRA NO-134, PLOT NO.-1091, PO-MADORA, DIST. MATHURA, U.P. / B.ED. / UP-3414 / The original file of the institution, Reply of the Institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee decides to issue letter under clause 7(11) of Regulations 2007.
21 / SHRI RAM TIRTH CHAUDHARY MAHAVIDYALAYA, VILLAGE – IMILA BANGHUSRA, POST – REHRA MAFI, TEHSIL – UTRAULA, DISTT. – BALRAMPUR, U.P. / B.ED. / UP-3276 / The original file of the institution, Reply of the Institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee decides to issue letter under clause 7(11) of Regulations 2007.
22 / MAHARAJA BALBHADRA SINGH RAJKVAR MAHAVIDYALAYA, VILLAGE – BANKATA, POST – LALPUR, DISTT. – BAHRAICH, U.P. / B.ED. / UP-3269 / The original file of the institution, Reply of the Institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee decides to issue letter under clause 7(11) of Regulations 2007.
23 / SHRI RAJPATI SINGH SMARAK PRASHIKSHAN MAHAVIDYALAYA, DIHDHAGAUPUR, SULTANPUR, U.P. / B.ED. / UP-2912 / The original file of the institution, Reply of the Institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee decides to issue letter under clause 7(11) of Regulations 2007.
24 / SHRI HANUMANTSHIKSHAN SANSTHAN PRASHIKSHAN MAHAVIDYALAYA, VILLAGE – RAIPUR, POST- HAKEERUPUR, TEHSIL – KADIPUR, DISTT. – SULTANPUR, U.P. / B.ED. / UP-3205 / The original file of the institution, Reply of the Institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee decides to issue letter under clause 7(11) of Regulations 2007.
25 / SANT BOOLA SATYANAM DAS BIRBAL DEGREE COLLEGE, AMARI, DULLAHPUR, GHAZIPUR, U.P. / B.P.ED. ADD. / UP-2447 / The original file of the institution, Reply of the Institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee decides to issue letter under clause 7(11) of Regulations 2007.
26 / KEWLA SUNDER MAHAVIDYALAYA, VILLAGE – SATHIPUR, POST – CHAPIYA, TEHSIL – SAHAJANNA, DISTT. – GORAKHPUR, U.P. / B.ED. / UP-3034 / The original file of the institution, Reply of the Institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee decides to issue letter under clause 7(11) of Regulations 2007.
27 / KRISHAK MAHAVIDYALAYA, VPO – RAJGARH, NARHAN, DISTT. – MIRZAPUR, U.P. / B.ED. / UP-2942 / The original file of the institution, Reply of the Institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee decides to issue letter under clause 7(11) of Regulations 2007.
28 / CHARAK INSTITUTE OF EDUCATION, VILLAGE – MAURA, POST – CHOWK, LUCKNOW, U.P. / B.ED. / UP-3080 / The original file of the institution, Reply of the Institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee observes the following:
- Affidavit on Rs.100/- stamp paper by the management and on Rs.10/- stamp paper by the faculty are not authenticated
- Details regarding HOD not given in the affidavit
- Details of website as per NCTE requirement not submitted.
29 / KATYAYANI COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, VILLAGE – BADRUDIN NAGAR NANU, POST – NANU, TEHSIL – SARDHANA, DISTT. – MEERUT, U.P. / B.ED. / UP-3068 / The original file of the institution, Reply of the Institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee decides to issue letter under clause 7(11) of Regulations 2007.
30 / CITY PUBLIC DEGREE COLLEGE, NEKPUR CHAURASI, FATEHGARH, FARRUKHABAD, U.P. / M.ED. / UP-2974 / The original file of the institution, Reply of the Institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee decides to issue letter under clause 7(11) of Regulations 2007.
31 / A.B.R.L. DEGREE COLLEGE, VILLAGE – GITHONI, CHANDHAR, TEHSIL – KHALILABAD, DISTT. – SANT KABIR NAGAR, U.P. / B.ED. / UP-2966 / The original file of the institution, Reply of the Institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee decides to issue letter under clause 7(11) of Regulations 2007.
32 / MAJOR SHIV DAYAL SINGH MAHILA MAHAVIDYALAYA, VPO- MOHAMMADABAD, FARRUKHABAD, U.P. / M.ED. / UP-3129 / The original file of the institution, Reply of the Institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee observes the following:
- Qualification of HOD appointed is not as per NCTE norms
33 / SUBHI DEVI MAHILA MAHAVIDYALAYA, VPO- KHALILABAD, DISTT. – SANT KABIR NAGAR, U.P. / B.ED. / UP-3022 / The original file of the institution, Reply of the Institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee decides to issue letter under clause 7(11) of Regulations 2007.
34 / N.S.S. COLLEGE OF EDUCATIONAL, CHHAULI, CATHURA, POST – BALDEO, DISTT. – MATHURA, U.P. / B.ED. / UP-3444 / The original file of the institution, Reply of the Institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee decides to issue letter under clause 7(11) of Regulations 2007.
35 / NIRMAL GANGA INSTITUTE OF EDUCATION, VPO – JARGAWAN, DISTT. – BULANDSHAHAR, U.P. / B.ED. / UP-3071 / The original file of the institution, Reply of the Institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee observes the following:
- The institution’s website is not as per NCTE norms
- The qualifications of Mrs. Gargi Sharma, Lecturer is not as per NCTE norms
36 / PRADEEP MEMORIAL COMPREHENSIVE COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, PRATAP VIHAR, KIRARI EXTN. NANGLOI, DELHI. / M.ED. / DH-365 / The original file of the institution, Reply of the Institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee decides to issue letter under clause 7(11) of Regulations 2007.
37 / SHRI BABU SINGH DEGREE COLLEGE, VPO – NAWAS GANJ, DISTT. – FARRUKHABAD, U.P. / B.ED. / UP-3127 / The original file of the institution, Reply of the Institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee decides to issue letter under clause 7(11) of Regulations 2007.
38 / RAJA DEVI DEGREE COLLEGE, VILLAGE – BADOKHAR KHURD, DISTT. – BANDA, U.P. / B.ED. / UP-3156 / The original file of the institution, Reply of the Institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee decides to issue letter under clause 7(11) of Regulations 2007.
39 / ROHIT MEMORIAL DEGREE COLLEGE, MAHADEO NAGAR, CHHAPER, SULTANPUR, UP / B.P.ED. / UP-2383 / The original file of the institution, Reply of the Institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee decides to issue letter under clause 7(11) of Regulations 2007.
40 / 21 / GURU TEG BAHADUR COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, VPO- DALELWALA, TEHSIL- BUDHLADA, DISTRICT- MANSA, PUNJAB / B.ED / PB-580 / The original file of the institution, Reply of the Institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committeedecides to issue letter under 7(11) subject to updating website as per NCTE norms.
41 / 22 / GURU HAR GOVIND COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, VILL- GONDWAL (RAIKOT), DISTRICT- LUDHIANA, PUNJAB. / B.ED / PB-577 / The original file of the institution, Reply of the Institution along with all other related documents, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee observes the following:
- Documents of approval of the Principal and faculty by the university is not submitted.
- Principal is over age
- Details of website is not submitted.
AGENDA ITEM NO.150.05.01CONSIDERATION OF THE REPLY UNDER SECTION 14(3) (B) OF NCTE ACT 1993.