Defined by Kohlberg
/ Statements we expect to receive with regard to a given dilemmaStage 1: Obedience and Punishment Orientation /
- Concern on a fixed set of unchanging rules
- We worry about what authorities will permit and punish
- Punishment=wrong
- “It’s bad/wrong to…”
- “You’ll get punished”/ “You won’t get punished”
- “It’s a sin to…”/ “It is against the Commandments…”
Stage 2: Individualism and Exchange /
- Everything is now relative; punishments are now a risk
- Individuals are seeking favors
- Fair exchange policy
- “Just because one person thinks it’s right, someone else might not”
- “This person may think it’s good/right for him”
- “It was unfair”/ “The fair way would have been…”
Stage 3: Interpersonal Relationships /
- “Good Boy/Nice Girl” Orientation
- Now there is a look at motives of each party involved
- The children now see the multi-dimensional aspect to a problem
- Character traits are described
- “ This person had the right idea”
- “His intentions were good, but…”
- This person was “greedy, selfish” or “caring and loving”
Stage 4: Maintaining a Social Order /
- Emphasis on obeying laws, respecting authority, and performing one’s duties so social order is maintained
- Not only do we say it’s wrong, but we explore the reasons why it is so
- “Stealing or breaking the law is never right, even though it is understandable why the person did it”
- “What would happen if we all did that”
- “It’s against the law to…”
Stage 5: Social Contract and Individual Rights /
- Stress on basic rights and democratic procedures to change unfair laws
- Strong language is used; the idea of right to life
- “The person has a right to live”
- “Laws are social contracts that everyone agrees to uphold”
Stage 6: Universal Principles /
- Look at problems through all eyes- clear concept of universal principles
- We decided no child would reach this stage at age 10 or 11